About Thistle Lodge Restaurant
Grand Views... Rave Reviews. At the Thistle Lodge Beachfront Restaurant, delicious cuisine is served in a historical heirloom setting overlooking the Gulf of Mexico. Swaying palms and gently breaking waves further set the scene for romance.
Fusion / Eclectic, Contemporary American
Hours of Operation:
Brunch: Sunday: 11:00am - 2:30pm; Lunch: Monday - Saturday: 11:30am - 2:30pm; Dinner: Sunday - Thursday: 5:00pm - 9:00pm, Friday - Saturday: 5:00pm - 10:00pm
Casa Ybel Road
$31 to $50
AMEX, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
Thistle Lodge provides live Jazz entertainment on Friday nights and Piano on Saturday nights. We also have Sunday Jazz during brunch.
Private Party Facilities:
Casa Ybel Resort, along with Thistle Lodge Beachfront Restaurant, has been hosting weddings and events for over 100 years. Overlooking the Gulf of Mexico, and situated on 23 acres of pristine private beach, Casa Ybel Resort is the perfect place to host your event!
Private Party Contact:
Jessica Pasek: 2394720693x1351
Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Entertainment, Full Bar, Happy Hour, Non-Smoking Restaurant, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Personal wines welcome, Personal wines welcome (corkage fee applies), Takeout, View, Weekend Brunch, Wheelchair Access, Wine
Thistle Lodge Restaurant Ratings and Reviews
A "just ok dinner" not worth the price t ...
A "just ok dinner" not worth the price tag. I ordered the special -- two lobster tails -- which were tasty but rather small. What was not small was the price tag for the entree -- $52, which the waitress failed to mention but highly recommended the dish while I was trying to make up my mind. I think it's reprehensible when they don't tell you the price. (You feel taken for a ride as the most expensive entrees on the menu are in the 30-40 range). The accompanying rice was tasteless and the broccoli overcooked and bland. The appetizer salad with gorgonzola, on the other hand, was nicely made and delicious. Creme brûlée for dessert was ok, nothing outstanding. View and ambiance is real nice and the staff friendly. However, the price paid vis-a-vis the food is not worth it.
We had a wonderful dining experience as ...
We had a wonderful dining experience as we were celebrating with friends. It is a tradition for us to celebrate three birthdays and two anniversaries with a special dinner. The Thistle Lodge was a perfect venue with excellent food and service.
We were spending Father's Day weekend in ...
We were spending Father's Day weekend in Captiva and I wanted a more upscale waterfront dining option than most of the island has to offer. This was exactly what I was looking for. My husband felt very special and the food was amazing. Everyone raved about their dishes, even the kids. The kids menu was also perfect. Not your typical Mac n cheese and hot dogs menu. My kids really enjoyed the cheese and crackers appetizer.
I had the macadamia encrusted magi mahi and my husband did the surf and turf. We didn't leave anything on our plates. Great wine selection too!
Great location overlooking the beach on ...
Great location overlooking the beach on Sanibel. Decor was upscale for a beach resort. Very attentive waitstaff. Nice list for specialty cocktails and good wine list. Appetizers were very good in size and well prepared. Entrees were served promptly and were at temperature. Steak was cooked as requested. One of three lobster tails was over cooked. Desserts were very good and there was good variety. I definitely will return.
A birthday dinner
Once again we were in Captiva for vacation to celebrate my husband's birthday. That means the Thistle Lodge for his celebration dinner. And as always, they were outstanding in service, ambiance, and, especially food. There was a card signed by all of the staff for my hubby and a brownie, ice cream, whipped cream and a candle for his complimentary birthday dessert. It was pretty wonderful. My oriental shortribs were a flavor like none other and my husband's pork "osso bucco" was just as flavorful. Both meats were "fall apart" tender. Natalie took great care of us. Thank you guys for being the highlight of our trip.
Excellent, excellent food, service and a ...
Excellent, excellent food, service and ambiance! What better place to watch the beach and sunset while dining on some excellent food on the island! We particularly enjoyed the freshly made bread, warm and service sliced with the knife in the center of the loaf -- very creative!
Quaint with an Ocean View
My wife and I are always looking for a hidden gem when it comes to dining while visiting the Fort Myers area and we came upon this one after doing some research. Cute little island resort with plenty of history, a beautiful view and very surprisingly good food. Our waitress was more than helpful and attentive. We had a very enjoyable meal only to be outdone by the great desert choices!
This is my 4th time vacationing in Sanibel. One of my favorites to dine is the Thistle Lodge. This is beach dining at its best. Our server, Dan, was very nice and remembered me from last year. The food is delicious and the drinks are wonderful. I truly love this place. Thanks to all for a memorable dinner.
It has been a few years since we ate at ...
It has been a few years since we ate at Thistle and we chose it for our 46th wedding anniversary
I was very disappointed in the deterioration of service and the food was just so so
I have removed it from my favorite list
We had Caesar salads and an order of Oct ...
We had Caesar salads and an order of Octopus. The salads arrived drenched in dressing so that much of the salad was inedible and the octopus arrived charred and burnt instead of grilled and tender. Was so disappointed with the meal!
Just a Fair Restaurant
Service was extremely slow, and the waiter never offered an explanation. We had to flag him down a few times before he paid any attention. We waited 45 minutes after placing our order - much too long.
The salmon and snapper (ordered by 2 of the group of 4) were good. The others had soft shell crabs. Mine were almost tasteless and cold to boot.
The food was delicious, seafood tower fo ...
The food was delicious, seafood tower for 2 was perfect, the lobster bisque was the best I've ever had (and I'm from New England), great wine selection, keylime cheesecake was delightful. Best dinner on the island, set in a great atmosphere with live piano. Our waiter Chris was the best. I will be coming back the next time we visit!
Wow what a special Mother's day
We had a great meal, a fantastic Old Fashion made by Casey the bartender and a very romantic setting as we gazed out onto the Gulf of Mexico. We would definitely recommend the Ahai Tuna appetizer and the fresh fish special of the night.
Thistle Lodge is quaint and reminds you ...
Thistle Lodge is quaint and reminds you of the the past. While sitting and enjoying a wonderful meal and watching the waves roll in you can imagine all the grand ladies and gents strolling along the beach to take in some fresh air before enjoying their evening meal.
Thistle Be A Great Meal
Thistle Lodge is an ideal place for a special dinner or celebration. Beachfront, with a view (unless wedding tents are up) and so elegant inside. Outdoor dining also possible. The food is extraordinary, with seafood, meat, and veggie entrees, as well as a host of starters. My wife opted for a iceberg wedge with French dressing that was not as good as my lobster bisque. ON the opther hand, her scallop with lobster meal was outstanding, besting my overpriced nightly fish special, tripletail. Their private label wine is a bargain, and the experience is worth the expense. Service was terrific, and we got to chat with the pianist, who is an accomplished songwriter and professor! It's still 5-star, but once a year is appropriate.
Fine dining on Sanibel
We were looking for a good restaurant to end our week on Sanibel and Thistle Lodge exceeded our expectations. From Richard our excellent server to the great food, we had a wonderful evening. The live background music was just right. Will definitely be coming back.
Beautiful view although ours was slightl ...
Beautiful view although ours was slightly blocked. Service was excellent, mojito was perfect. Snapper was very salty (and I like salt), surf and turf was just ok. A lot happening on the plate and the sauce was rather bland. Cut of steak was mediocre.
My friend and I have made The Thistle Lodge our 'last night swan song on Sanibel' dinner for the past 3 years. Under normal circumstances the view is absolutely to die for, especially if you go before but leading up to sunset. The manicured lawn, well groomed trees and tall lean shadows draw your eye right to a gorgeous view of the Gulf. You don't see the sunset directly, you catch the glow and all it's colorful play on the water, waves and the clouds that may hover above the horizon. Glorious! The well groomed grounds, quaint bar, player piano and wonderful outdoor eating patio add up to old plantation charm. My star rating reflects my third visit to Thistle Lodge. The whole entire lawn and view was blocked by a HUGE white tent that was set up for a next day's wedding. Those lucky guests will get that Gulf and sky view, not anyone dining in the restaurant. Saving grace was Rosie, a wonderful waitress and the food. In the past my friend and I had enjoyed the uniqueness of the Ahi Tuna Trio (amazing explosion of all kinds of exciting flavors all centered on perfect Ahi Tuna) for the appetizer. This year we both went for the Lobster Bisque. Hands down it was the creamiest and most wonderful preparation I've ever had. Note here, it was served in the widest brim bowl I've ever seen! That brim caught every drip that didn't make it to my mouth instead of on my dress or table. Main course, both of us chose the treasured Lobster & Lump Crab “Diver” Scallops. Presentation was great and the taste was grand...but, something was missing of which my friend (who gets this dish every year) discovered quickly. What makes the dish over the top exceptional is the Citrus Buerre Blanc sauce. Once alerted Rosie brought us a very small dish of the buttery sauce to add on our own portion. Our final good bye dinner on the island was less than the usual spectacular, but still wonderful! Thistle Lodge Wines are better than some high dollar wines and at a great price point.
A lovely upscale spot
Loved the lodge and it's quiet, upscale, yet very unpretentious atmosphere. Our waiter was very attentive and willing to accommodate or special requests. The menu has some outstanding selections we would have loved to try but alas, we had eaten such a large lunch that we had to go light on dinner. Had we known what the menu would have been like, we would have saved ourselves for a more scrumptious dinner! As it was, we each simply had a salad and had appetizers as our main course, but we were quite happy with that. The food was fabulous and we loved the peace and quiet.
Thistle Lodge was our favorite of the several wonderful restaurants we sampled in Sanibel. The cocktails and food were exceptional, perfect attentive friendly but not intrusive service, beautiful surroundings and a nice view of the Gulf. The baby lamb chops were outstanding, and we really enjoyed the portobello Napoleon appetizer that we shared. All in all, it was a perfect evening. We ate inside, but the spacious outdoor patio looked quite inviting, too, maybe we'll try it next time.
Great experience again. Food was good. W ...
Great experience again. Food was good. Would love more farm to table or organic choices but that's my preference. Everything was cooked perfectly and had great flavor. Lovely setting and ambiance. Service was great.
Special occasion disappointment
We booked this restaurant for a special occasion after having such great experiences in the past. Upon arrival we were extremely disappointed to find that our view of the beach (one of the most charming things about this restaurant) was completely obliterated by a large white banquet tent on the lawn. I would never have driven 45 minutes had I known that we would have NO view! Dinner was good but not as exceptional as we have experienced in the past--perhaps our feelings about it were also tempered by our disappointment in the view (or lack thereof). Overall, an expensive yet disappointing evening.
Romantic dinner with delicious seafood.
We had the Grilled Octopus appetizer and it was cooked perfectly. My husband had the Filet and Lobster and the lobster melted in our mouths. I had the scallops topped with crab and lobster meat. I wish the lobster pieces were more prominent, but it was delicious. We had been there before for Valentines Day and our most recent meal was just as romantic as the first time. We will be back again soon.
Amazing Salmon! Extraodinary Chef creations!
This quaint dining lodge built in 1929 is a hidden gem! Overlooks the Gulf of Mexico with a nostalgic old Florida feel . It's just a special place with exceptional cuisine and an impressive wine list to match. I almost didn't want to share this review and keep this wonderful place for ourselves!
LD - Ft Myers, FL
Beautiful water view setting with grand ...
Beautiful water view setting with grand piano music and wonderful lunch menu including lobster bisque and fresh fish selections. The service was absolutely perfect. Could not have found a better way to celebrate my father's 85th birthday.
I love the Thistle Lodge because of it's historical significance on the island and it's always a place where you can talk and hear each other without shouting. Great spot for lunch and lovely for dinner. You can depend on the food being good and the service excellent.
They got one of our orders incorrect three times.
One of our orders was wrong three times and our guest gave up and did not eat. We were not offered anything for the poor service. We asked that the meal be comped. They agreed to 1/2 and then changed their mind and gave us two free meals while stating they would not charge us for the omelette that we never received.
Thistle Lodge has a "country club dining while viewing the water" feel. Dark paneled wood, white ceilings and black/white bistro chairs give it an elegance unusual for Sanibel where decor is often more casual and Florida pastels. There is a live piano some nights which adds to the supper club atmosphere. Food is good, and service is attentive. Lobster bisque excellent, Caesar served w a real anchovy filet, not the bony skinned standard. Similar restaurants: Il Cielo, Mad Hatter, Traditions. Thistle is located within a resort.
We had not visited the Thistle Lodge before. We were meeting friends for dinner that we had not seen in over 10 years. Because we had so much to catch up on we did not focus heavily on the menu and went with the recommendations of Jake the bartender and Richard our waiter who were both great guys. This ended up being the right decision. All of our meals were absolutely amazing. I had the Blackened Yellow Tail Snapper and don't remember ever having as good a dish anywhere. My wife had the Herb Crusted Lamb Rack which also was exceptional. While we really enjoyed our meals I have to admit we were so caught up in conversation with our friends I don't think we got the full enjoyment so we will definitely be making plans to go back in the very near future so we can focus on the food and the great scenery. My only ask of the restaurant is to please lower the volume on your pre-programmed player piano. I'm sure the intent is to have this as background music but unfortunately it was more out front than behind.
Please sign in to record your input. Thanks!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.