About Theo's Fayetteville
If the date and time you are looking for is not available online, please contact the restaurant at 479-527-0086.
Theo's blends the freshness of coastal cuisine with the comfort of regional cooking and hospitality...simple, yet elegant food in the Contemporary American style. The premier lounge and bar in NWA for the last seven years, Theo's produces the finest cocktails made from fresh ingredients and quality spirits. A smart wine list places equal emphasis on all regions of the world and value at every price point. With it's unique setting just off Dickson Street, Theo's is the perfect spot for happy hour after work or a special night out in Fayetteville. You can also visit the Rogers location at The Shoppes at Pinnacle Hills.
Contemporary American, Seafood, Steak
Hours of Operation:
Dinner: Monday - Thursday: 5:00pm - 10:00pm, Friday & Saturday: 5:00pm -11:00pm.
Lounge and patio open late.
$31 to $50
AMEX, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
Valet is complimentary to our Guests and is located on Campbell Ave. between Dickson Street and Watson Street.
Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Full Bar, Gluten-free Menu, Happy Hour, Late Night, Non-Smoking Area, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Personal wines welcome, Personal wines welcome (corkage fee applies), Smoking Area, Smoking Area (patio only), Takeout, Wheelchair Access, Wine
Theo's Fayetteville Ratings and Reviews
Hands down my fiancé and I's favorite re ...
Hands down my fiancé and I's favorite restaurant in Fayetteville! Kristen(sp?) is the best waitress in NWA!!
One of my favorite places in NWA. Always ...
One of my favorite places in NWA. Always enjoy it!
Best steak in town
Theos Fayetteville is awesome. Consistently the best steak in nwa. Good food paired with good wine make for a great date night. The grilled shrimp bruschetta was really good too.
It was my Grandson's 21st Birthday! They made it very Special for him and gave him a free Birthday dessert with Happy Birthday written on the plate! Very Special Evening! Highly recommend Theo's in Fayetteville!
We loved it. Went for New Years and had a great evening. Great service!
Wonderful dining experience
I recently to my wife to Theo's for her birthday dinner. It was our first time to try the restaurant. We went into the bar area first for drinks and an appetizer. They have $5 specials on both, which is a good deal by today's standards. The duck confit appetizer was fabulous, and the martinis were "honest". Then we moved to the dining room, where both the food and service were excellent. My wife had the pork chop, which was delicious and very generous in size. I had the pasta with filet bites - it was good, but not up to the level of her pork chop. We will most definitely patronize this restaurant - it was quite possibly the best dining experience that we have enjoyed in our four years living here in Northwest Arkansas.
The main course was very good but the tw ...
The main course was very good but the two appetizers were fishy tasting. We had the shrimp bruschetta and tuna tartare. The shrimp was actually terrible.
Good fare and vibe
Theo's has a nice menu, and most of the meal was quite savory. One dish didn't hold up to the others, lacking in taste, as well as the risotto being a bit under cooked. The server might have been on his first day, as he lacked the niceties you would expect in a better restaurant, as well as a real understanding of the menu. The bar scene seemed like quite the spot, and upon leaving and heading to another location for a nightcap, we did hear that Theo's is definitely a place for drinks. Overall, a solid meal, and would give them another shot.
Great place but the chef does not know h ...
Great place but the chef does not know how to cook sordfish. I'd go again but stay away from delicate fish.
You have to try the Double-Cut Pork Chop ...
You have to try the Double-Cut Pork Chop served on Kale, cheese grits, Ouster mushrooms with a bourbon reduction. Best dish on the menu. Yes, even better than the Filet.
Creative cuisine, well-prepared. Attent ...
Creative cuisine, well-prepared. Attentive service. Only negative (minor) was kitchen noise.
Just cocktails; Skip the food
Our bartender was knowledgeable and made great cocktails. However, the food we ordered ranged from bland to creepy. My husband had risotto which had a Halloween-ish green color but was decent tasting. I ordered a rigatoni pasta dish which had a few bites of steak on it and zero sauce. I found a few diced vegetables in the bottom of the serving dish but even a little white wine or olive oil would have been really helpful. Very disappointed in the food.
Fayetville at it's best.
Great food, great service never rushed between courses. An overall excellent time. Will be returning in the future. Thanks for the great time we had with my wife's birthday dinner.
First visit to Theo's
I had the mussels because I had read raves about them. They were OK; I wish the broth had been a bit spicier. I also had the tuna, which was good. The fried bok choy was a bit hard to cut; sauteed would have been better. The pile of wasabi mashed potatoes was a bit overwhelming, but they were tasty. The coffee was a bit weak.
Has gone downhill
My duck confit risotto was horrid. It resembled a hash slop. Embarassing. Duck pieces were hard as a rock. Vegetables were unidentifiable. Won't go back. Mussels were good though.
We were taken good care of.....
Mussels were a very good appetizer and our steaks were fork tender and very flavorful. All-in-all a very nice experience.
Went with another couple and we had a great time. Food was excellent and the service was even better - Thanks Sarah!
Four of us dined for the evening. The food was very good for three of us but my wife's plate was not good at all. It was a pasta dish with beef. The pasta and the sauce was nice but the meat was not eatable. She's the type that will not send anything back, just keeps moving.
Excellent food, service and atmosphere.
My wife and I went to Theos for our wedding anniversary dinner before a show at the Walton Art Center. Everything was excellent. Our waiter was very professional but also personable. They added a few special touches to help celebrate our anniversay and the food was absolutely great. We had never been there before but we will definitely go again.
Theo's Perfect in Every Way
Outstanding across the board, every time -- food (quality, presentation), service (attentive, but not overbearing), atmosphere (noise level muffled).
Our new favorite spot in Fayetteville
The food was beautifully plated and more importantly it was delicious. Our table ordered a variety of dishes each one cooked to perfection. The pork chop was so tender you could cut w fork! Ahi tune fresh and delish marinated chicken was great. Favorite appetizer was ahi tacos. Best martini in town
Absolutely blown away by this little place on Dickson street. Food is inventive comfort food with layers of flavor beautifully presented. Rigatoni with tenderloin outstanding. Ravioli superb. Salads are perfection. And desserts and cocktails awesome. Atmosphere is great for quiet conversation but it's not a stuffy place at all. New favorite in Fayetteville.
This place was great. Awesome romantic atmosphere. Short simple menu and top notch service. Their chefs really know how to prepare the menu and the daily specials.
Just the most amazing meal and service!
From the valet service, to the friendly hostess, to the attentive and kind waiter, we loved every minute of our special night out! All of those things, although wonderful, don't even come close to the amazing meal! We started with a crisp glass of Prosecco. Followed by a basket of bread that included a seasoned, crunchy flatbread and warmed french bread slices. I would highly recommend giving the flatbread a try. It was really different, and SO tasty! Then we were brought our main courses of ahi tuna and the filet mignon, both opting for the smashed potatoes that were out of this world, heavenly! I may have to see if they would sell orders of just the potatoes, to go. Mine don't hold a candle to smashed they serve! Then we had the decadent molten chocolate cake, which isn't your run of the mill molten cake - it was richer and so amazing! We also had the creme brulee, again amazingly prepared and so delicious, and finished with a dessert drink that I think was called an Almond Truffle, made up of Amaretto, White Chocolate Godiva, and a splash of cream. It was the PERFECT ending for a delicious meal!
Out of sync
Our time was generally delightful; however, we encountered serious problems with our meal. Drinks were promptly delivered although the appetizer came lots later. We were confronted with our meal well before we finished the appetizer. There appeared to be little to no coordination among wait staff, bartenders and the cooks. A wine recommendation was generally inept, but the wait staff was kind to remove the charge from the bill. In short, excellent food, disconnected service. I expect better of a four Benjamin meal.
Used to love Theo's
In the past four years, Theo's has been one of our top three favorite restaurants in Fayetteville. However, our experience this last Saturday was less than ideal. The appetizer we ordered (blue cheese bacon dip) was excellent, as was the bread that was provided. The arugula salad was great as well. However, my main dish was a filet, mashed potatoes, and asparagus. The filet was terrible. The meat tasted bad - I could only eat two bites. The mashed potatoes were average. I did have two glasses of wine, but it was a shame to pay $100 for a terrible meal. The service was not good at all. We normally have good service at Theo's, but our waiter seemed annoyed with us and was inattentive. We had to wait for 20 minutes just to get our check. And he didn't even inquire as to why two of us hardly touched our steak. We may have to take Theo's off our list, especially given other great places in town. Too bad since it has been good in the past.
Everything was GREAT.
The food, service, and atmosphere were all phenomenal. Everything I needed for a wonderful celebration.
Was really nice....
We don't eat out much, but our children gave us a gift certificate for Theo's for our 51st anniversary. It was the perfect place to celebrate an anniversary. Food was great. Ambiance was perfect. Our server was a gem.
Jordan, our waiter and restraunt guide for the evening, was amazing. His reccomendations were spot on and truly helped make our dining experience memorable and enjoyable.
Theos continues to have top notch foods with a menu that changes slowly, allowing you to choose from faithful standards to new entrees and specials. The small restaurant and separation from a large bar helps minimize the volume. While you won't find an out-of-the-way table for a romantic dinner, the dark interior gives a perception of a luxurious room. The shrimp risotto is top notch, and was a previous standard now offered as a special. The fish of the day was a tender, fine white-fleshed fish that is often served over-cooked...but not here! Done perfectly, melting in your mouth. Service is excellent, yet not annoying.
This was a birthdY celebration!
The evening started with seeing our favorite bartender. The restaurant was busy, but our service was excellent. Nether meal was delicious, and they were gracious enough to alter a dish to better suit what I wanted - I didn't want my avocados tempura-fried in the tuna tacos. And they treated my husband to free desert - a Brandy Alexander! It was a fun evening!
Another great meal at Theo's. The ahi tuna I had was great. My husband had the fish special which was sole with the most wonderful ponzu sauce. Our service was amazing and they brought us a special dessert for our anniversary.
Disappointed once again
For some reason, this restaurant never fails to disapoint me. My husband's $34.00 filet was very low quality. He wanted to send it back, but didn't want to ruin the evening. My sole (the special) was just okay and not presented like the waiter described. It seemed all the wait staff were running around like it was a fire drill and the restaurant wasn't even busy. The woman who delivered our food clearly did not want to be there. We will not be going back again.
Second time for special dinner in Fayetteville
I came from out of town to bring some special customers to dinner here for the second year in a row. Last year I found this place on Yelp and decided to go there again because we had such a great time and amazing food! This time did not disappoint either: while waiting for all of our party to arrive, we started at the bar where Mehak served us our drinks. She was very cordial and energetic and even took time at the busy bar to explain a special gin that the restaurant makes. After we were escorted to our dinner, we all began to reminisce about the meals we had last year and started to make our recommendations to the two persons who had not eaten there before. We started with Chorizo Tacos and Fish (Tuna) Tacos, which were very unique and the flavors were so fresh. We all ordered entrees: the Wild Boar Ravioli was ordered on our recommendation from last year and was a hit; I had the Tuna dish, which tasted like we were at a beach side restaurant instead of in the middle of the country; Pork Chops were also enjoyed, lots of "yum's"; the Ribeye did not disappoint; and the Filet got rave reviews: our guest cut up pieces and gave to all of us because he had never tasted a steak as good as this one! The ambiance of the restaurant once again fit the occasion, we like casual but also like a classy feel. This is Theo's to me. Our customers were once again appreciative of a great dinner and an enjoyable time together. Thanks, Theo's!
We came off the road underdressed with kids, but wanting a good meal. Management agreed to accommodate. Luckily, our children cooperated. Our server was excellent & very personable. We ate well and drank well! Our son said the calamari appetizer was the best he'd ever had! I think we ordered just over half the menu for dinner between the 5 of us. my husband and I were pleased with every morsel, except the sliders, which were good but a little overcooked.
The server was knowledgable and friendly. The salads were fresh with quality produce. My son had the asparagus soup which he raved about. I had quite possible the best pork chops I have ever had. We will likely return when we visit my son again.
Fine dining, excellent service
This must be THE place in Fayetteville for special occasions. On the phone and again on arrival, we were asked what we were celebrating. As it happens, we just wanted dinner and it turned out we picked a good spot. The duck confit quesadilla was a delicious start, though we could have skipped the limp calamari--the reason I'm giving only four stars. The wild boar sausage ravioli was a knock-out, but the real winner was the fish of the day. Crisp-skinned walleye served on a bed of corn relish--yum. Can't rate the deserts--we didn't have room. Service was outstanding and the selection of wines by the glass gave us plenty to choose from. Well done, Theo's.
Theo's is classic American cuisine at its best! The food is excellent but the service is what sets this establishment apart from others
second time at Theo's and just as great as the first. We ate outside and had a wonderful meal with superb service.
husband's birthday celebration
Went here for my husband's birthday. We've been here a few other times. It was lovely. I do not recommend the oysters though, they did not shuck them correctly and there were shells in them. It's happened a couple other times here as well.
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.