About The Carlton
Conveniently located in downtown Pittsburgh, within walking distance of the Convention Center & four major downtown hotels.
A Pittsburgh favorite for over 20 years. Recipient of the Wine Spectator of Excellence 1995-2006 and The Dirona Award 2000 - 2006 (Distinguished Restaurants of North American).
The Carlton has a spectacular cuisine, complimented with an extensive wine list served by polished waiters in a beautiful atmosphere. Pittsburghers know the value of the Carlton making it the spot for business meetings to celebrations.
Hours of Operation:
Lunch: Monday - Friday: 11:30am - 2:30pm; Dinner: Monday - Saturday: 5:00pm - 10:00pm
$31 to $50
AMEX, Carte Blanche, Diners Club, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
Parking is validated with Dinner if parked after 5:00pm in the One Mellon Center Garage (Ross Street entrance).
T-Stop & bus stop
Private Party Facilities:
The Carlton offers private space to accommodate from 25 to 40 guests.
Private Party Contact:
Bill, Janet or Russ: 4123914099
Banquet/Private Rooms, Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Full Bar, Non-Smoking Restaurant, Personal wines welcome (corkage fee applies), Private Room, Smoking Area (bar only), Wine
Send a Gift Card
Buy now and send it instantly by email, or print a card to give in person.
The Carlton Ratings and Reviews
The food and ambiance we're fabulous. W ...
The food and ambiance we're fabulous. We come here often and are never disappointed.
Best dining experience I've had in a lon ...
Best dining experience I've had in a long time. Easily Accommodated friend's allergy requests. Service and food were top notch.
Good food and service. We went before ...
Good food and service. We went before the Pens game. It's convenient and a good value. It's a wine friendly place. Modest cork fee and great selection. However, the room needs to be updated. The carpet is old and worn. Not a good first impression. Otherwise, it's great.
We had a delightful evening. The chef ma ...
We had a delightful evening. The chef made a special vegan meal for our daughter and she loved it! We always enjoy the Carlton and the food is excellent.
The things they do to fish is outstandin ...
The things they do to fish is outstanding. The menu is always changing with different ways of preparing the same fish week after week. If I were wealthy I would eat here at least once a week. The food is well worth the price. Michael is a wonderful and friendly waiter who knows the menu and wine list inside out.
Excellent draft beers, one service issue
Don't remember the option of having a draft beer last time I was there but there were several options and it was hard to choose which to have. I was disappointed that it took so long to receive the check. I asked for it when the entrees were served (we needed to leave shortly) but we sat for another 20 minutes before it was finally presented. Not sure what I could have done to get the message across, but there is no excuse for it taking more than 5 minutes - when the customer specifically requests it, they obviously don't plan to have another drink or dessert.
Great "before game" dining! Delicious me ...
Great "before game" dining! Delicious menu, served hot, quickly and by friendly staff. Thanks!
nothing more to say, then I eat here often. many of our friends consider it the best restaurant in the burgh.
Slow service. Little attention. Not the ...
Slow service. Little attention. Not the typical Carlton experience
We are new to the Pittsburgh dining scen ...
We are new to the Pittsburgh dining scene. We were in town to celebrate our son's engagement and found The Carlton on Open Table. We had a bit of trouble finding it as we were not aware that it was on the second floor of the BYN building. The food was well prepared and beautifully presented. The staff was very cognizant of our time constraints in order that we arrived timely for the engagement party. We will definitely return.
The soup was about the best I've had in ...
The soup was about the best I've had in years (Beef and Bean) and Michael, our server, was outstanding.
Delicious food!!! Great perk having a li ...
Delicious food!!! Great perk having a limo to the Pens game.
My biggest gripe is having to continue f ...
My biggest gripe is having to continue following up with the restaurant to post points earned for the visit. It is becoming the rule and a huge inconvenience, smh.
Great service. Everyone was wonderful.
Great service. Everyone was wonderful.
Great experience. Great food. Great se ...
Great experience. Great food. Great service!
Our server was Bobby. He was well versed in the menu and extensive wine list. Attentive and friendly. One of the best servers we have ever had. My husband and I have three children so date nights are sacred. We purposely book the latest reservation possible when we dine to avoid families. We want to enjoy the ambience and each other without hearing kids. Upon arrival, we were greeted by the hostess who seemed bored and irritated that she had to look up from her phone. The Carlton was practically empty when we got there and she seated us right next to a group with several children. The food was very good. The duck was a bit gamey but overall very good.
Dining at The Carlton on a weekday
Our experience was very pleasurable. The food was excellent and the menu had many delicious sounding choices. We were attending the theater, and the server met the need to eat in a timely manner, without seeming to hurry our meal. I would recommend this restaurant very highly to anyone,
Always great food and great service. Gre ...
Always great food and great service. Great for client entertaining.
Good, not great
The restaurant is located inside an office building so no view to speak of. Food and service were good, not great. With so many other great restaurants to choose from in Pittsburgh, I'm not sure how this one competes. I now understand how they were able to get us in on a Saturday night on very short notice. The atmosphere is interesting, I felt like I was stepping back in time a bit. It is not a bad place to dine, just not my first pick, especially for the price.
Another great dinner at The Carlton
Our second time at the restaurant. I have had steaks both visits and both were great. This time I had the New York strip, perfectly cooked rare, and finished Oscar style with crab and grilled asparagus. The steak was about an inch and a half thick, and absolutely wonderful. Our waiter was professional, and attentive, without being invasive. The restaurant was fairly quiet, but far from empty. Just mostly small groups and couples. This has become one of my favorite places to dine in Pittsburgh which is saying something with all the choices.
Always have a wonderful dinner at The Ca ...
Always have a wonderful dinner at The Carlton, whether it's to celebrate a special occasion or to have an enjoyable dinner before attending a show or concert. The food is fabulous and the convenience of parking on site makes the whole evening thoroughly enjoyable.
I had heard good things, and I was NOT let down...
The Carlton is a prime dining spot to, easily, reach a number of post-dinner show spots (the Theatre District, etc. - even venues down to the CONSOL). I had heard many good things, but I'm much more of an I'll-believe-it-when-I-see-it kind of epicurean myself. Overall, The Carlton is worthy of the praise. First off, if you're enjoying your first time here (especially on an off-hours/weekend, as we were) keep in mind that the Ross Street entrance to the BNY Mellon building is what you want. I reserve but one minor "issue" before I get into the absolutely wonderful dining experience that we had. From an initial reservation phone call, to our reception, to our server, etc. - the staff is overly rehearsed. They were extremely attentive and adept, just overly rehearsed. As for the food, I enjoyed a Mahi Mahi dinner. As a native of Florida, my expectation is to, quite literally, see the fishing craft my dinner is brought in on before it immediately hits and expert grill. That said, the dinner entrée I enjoyed at The Carlton is the very closest I've ever come to a similar experience here in the Northeast. Upon dessert, I chose to press my "Floridian" luck, and chose the Key Lime Tart. Again, I was not let down. Finally, at the conclusion of dinner, and needing to arrive to our post-dinner show in a timely manner, The Carlton offered us complimentary limousine service to the venue. For such a dining experience, my expectations were met and slightly exceeded. The Carlton offers a wonderful ambiance and panache, but, as is usually the case for us all, enjoys a bit of room for minor improvements. As a bottom line, make NO mistake, I will be a repeat client of this establishment without doubt. They are every bit worth your time.
great service with high prices
We had exceptional service but I found the prices to be pretty high for Pittsburgh. We went there because it was convenient to the Consol energy center.
Joel was on his game with recommendations. My wife and I had seafood, Sea Bass & Scallops. Both were very well prepared as we like our seafood slightly cooked. Perfectly done ! I would recommend this dining experience to all. Being from Cleveland it rates as good as the fine eateries in CLE. Appreciate the shuttle to CONSOL Energy, Thank you :) Bill & Monica O'Loughlin
Good food. Can be noisy when full. Excellent wine list at reasonable prices.
Special Occasions Treat
Want to treat someone for a special occasion? If so, The Carlton is the perfect solution. Great food, great service and a menu with a vareity of selections.
The Carlton is one of my Pittsburgh favorites. The menu is diverse, heavy on seafood. The original Carlton salad is a favorite, though the last two times I've had it it was room temperature. The service is excellent. Prices are reasonable and perhaps even a little less expensive than other downtown locations with inferior menus and service. Free parking in the building, as well as a complimentary limo to the theater district make it a no-brainer to choose this restaurant for special nights on the town. On the down side, it's unfortunate that the only entrance is through the bar. On this particular Friday night the happy hour crowd was huge and noisy, making it difficult to work our way to the hostess station. The carpeting is pretty worn, detracting from the overall ambience of the restaurant.
The Carlton is always a hit!
This is by far one of my favorite downtown Pittsburgh restaurants. Everything on the menu is great.
Our waiter Russell was wonderful! The d ...
Our waiter Russell was wonderful! The dinner was delicious and the service even better.
Greeted as a returning customer. Felt l ...
Greeted as a returning customer. Felt like we were dining with friends
Mediocre Salads, OK Entrees
Two well-overdressed uninteresting salads and two pretty decent fish dishes.
Love the Carlton
We ate at the Carlton on a Friday night before a show. This was our 3rd or 4th time eating there in the past 2 years and this was the best yet. The service was impeccable. We weren't rushed and the pour on the cocktails was very good. I had a beet salad as a starter and then had the Halibut entrée. Both were very good. My wife had a house salad and then the seared tuna. The portions were very large and she couldn't finish all of the tuna. One really great thing about the Carlton is the wine list. There are 100's of bottles of wines and the pricing is the best I've seen anywhere. Can't wait to go back.
it is our favorite
and our most frequented. Staff from entering to leaving are great. we often stop at the bar before leaving after dinner.
Service is outstanding! Always a wide va ...
Service is outstanding! Always a wide variety of specials and quality wine selections. Free lino service to the cultural district shows makes for a nice evening out!
I'll never go back
I made a last minute reservation to celebrate valentine's day at the Carlton. I read many of the reviews and they were all very positive. Unfortunately, Our experience was more than disappointing and we will never go back. The restaurant was definitely showing its age. Our service was less than desirable, it took a long time to get our drink order, let alone our food. The food was mediocre at best.
We made reservations for a Saturday evening at 8:30 and didn't get seated until after 9:00. Our seats were in the middle of the action and not at all romantic or quiet. The bread was horrible. Usually at better restaurants the bread is warm and soft inside but this bread was cold and hard. The food itself (prime rib) was good although I'm not sure it was worth the cost - Maybe in a better atmosphere it would be worth the cost. The desserts were way too sweet and we only ate half. The house wine was good and reasonably priced and the waitress was nice. I wouldn't return to this restaurant as the atmosphere wasn't intimate or special and the menu is too exotic and weird for me.
First time there and loved it. Food was ...
First time there and loved it. Food was delicious. Waitstaff were attentive and polite. They gave us complimentary limo service to the theater which we loved. Great experience. Will be returning again!
Always excellent food and service. You c ...
Always excellent food and service. You can always count on a great experience
Can't go wrong with The Carlton!
my husband and i have celebrated many special days at The Carlton and it never disappoints!
The food is Always killer. Service alwa ...
The food is Always killer. Service always great too!!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.