About Sweet Melissa's Cafe
Executive Chef Melissa Talmage offers a divinely creative menu sure to fit any foodies dream. Serving lunch and dinner, Chef Melissa challenges your taste buds to explore an array of different textures and tastes. Our dinner menu is broken into sections and the entrees are offered in half portions to give you the ability to try a few different dishes in one visit. We also offer an extensive wine list to enhance your dining experience. Come join us for another side to island dining.
Contemporary American, Tapas / Small Plates
Hours of Operation:
Lunch: Monday - Friday 11:30 am - 2:30 pm
Dinner: Monday - Saturday 5 pm
$30 and under
AMEX, Diners Club, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
Acoustic Guitarist Wednesday Thursday Friday and Saturday Evenings
Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Chef's Table, Counter Seating, Entertainment, Farm to Table, Full Bar, Happy Hour, Non-Smoking Area, Non-Smoking Restaurant, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Personal wines welcome, Personal wines welcome (corkage fee applies), Smoking Area, Wheelchair Access, Wine, Wine Bar
Sweet Melissa's Cafe Ratings and Reviews
An absolute gem, a must, beyond expectat ...
An absolute gem, a must, beyond expectations. I dine out regularly for business and pleasure, around the country. This resturant is a must for anyone looking for ambiance, a great and affordable meal. For what is worth this is only my third time written a review, I was that impressed.
One of the Best on Sanibel Island
We had heard about Sweet Melissa's and now wished we had heard about it - and gone there - sooner. A wonderful evening with friends made all that much more special because of the beautifully prepared and delicious food. Quiet location, pleasant decor, outstanding bread, clever cocktails, extraordinarily fresh vegetables, perfectly seasoned dishes, excellent service, and all around great ambiance combined for a great evening. Highly recommended.
Simple menu backed by great taste! Perfe ...
Simple menu backed by great taste! Perfect.
Great dining experience
We had been recommended Sweet Melissa's as a place for a special meal by a friend. It lived up to expectations. The service was excellent and we really enjoyed the food. As a location for a special meal we would heartily recommend it.
We my wife and I really enjoyed the food ...
We my wife and I really enjoyed the food. I had a red snapper special, and my wife had the grouper. Both were delicious. And the watermelon salad was fantastic!
Great as usual. 1/2 plates are an excel ...
Great as usual. 1/2 plates are an excellent idea for folks that don't eat big meals
Our waitress Molly was great. Our meals ...
Our waitress Molly was great. Our meals were delicious.
Always love dining here...
Always love dining here...
Sweet Melissa's is a great restaurant, t ...
Sweet Melissa's is a great restaurant, the best on Sanibel, and would rank at the top anywhere.
Everything was great as usual, small plates make it easy to try different options. Server was exceptional!
Exceeds Its Reputation!
Sweet Melissa's has had consistently strong reviews, but we missed getting there every year during out summer vacation. We finally did and it was EXCEPTIONAL. The menu, the food & presentation were absolutely perfect. We loved that you can get full or half portions of the entrees to tailor to your desires - a neighboring diner did "surf + turf" from 2 half-sized entrees, I got a wonderful appetizer and half-size entree. The selections offered something for everyone, and I saw many choices I would love to try on my NEXT visit. Desert choices were incredible - and LARGE portions. And a live guitarist providing awesome background music - just perfect! A real gem in Sanibel!!!
what a surprise!
i was attending a conference in Ft. Myers and i had friends from South Beach coming over for dinner, i had no clue where to go... i was suggested Sweet Melissa's cafe and decided to give it a try... great dining experience!!! and the service is excellent!!!
Quality food in a charming atmosphere
Sweet Melissa's is the most sophisticated & creative dining spot in Sanibel, barring none. It is great fun to go there as it is eclectic, reliable and delicious. The service is immediate and one can glimpse the chefs in the kitchen hard at work. Everything on the menu is outstanding. In our week in Sanibel recently, we ate there twice and loved everything we ate.
We love Melissa's
Melissa's never fails us! We tried some of the new menu choices , the jars, are so creative, and the ones we picked were delicious . I especially loved the goat cheese. Our entrees of grouper and pompano melted in the mouth, fresh and beautifully prepared. Great service, innovative and interesting cuisine, this should be everyone's first choice.
A lovely experience
Sweet Melissa's was everything we expected and more. We were seated in a smaller, more intimate dining room, beyond the main dining room, which was perfect for the two of us. The menu was very interesting and the food was sensational and perfectly prepared. Best of all, even though the room we were in was full, it was still quiet and relaxing. What a delightful evening...we can't wait to go back. We highly recommend it to anyone who is discriminating and expects a superb experience without pretension. This is the place for you!
This is a very special restaurant in ter ...
This is a very special restaurant in terms of lovely ambience, creative cuisine and price. We are in Sanibel for only one week and are eating at Sweet Melissa's again.
Went to celebrate anniversary based on excellent experience in the past. Instead of enjoying meal, we felt very rushed. From seating to check payment, meal took 30 minutes. There wasn't even a wait so no real reason. We called to share feedback after we left and were told a manager would call us back in the morning. We still have not heard back from the restaurant. It's a shame because we were not looking for anything and the food itself was excellent. Portion sizes were smaller than we recalled compared to last year.
Excellent place to dine.
My wife and I like the fact that it has a relatively small menu which to us means all the dishes are freshly prepared. She also likes it because she can get small plates there. I started with the 5 cheese offering, excellent, and then had the small fillet steak, medium. Melted in my mouth!
Our first visit to Sweet Melissa's although we have wanted to go for many months. Very enjoyable.
Truly memorable meal
Very hard to pick as so many delicious items on the menu. I started with the pate pots. The smoked mullet was magnificent and I had the others boxed for next day's lunch. The chef offers two sizes of entrees which is brilliant and I wish more restaurants did this. I opted for the smaller sized pan baked grouper with black-eyed peas and kale. Fish was perfectly cooked and the dish was well conceived. Alas desserts do not come in two sizes but the waitressed offered to bring me a scoop of one of their myriad house made ice creams & sorbets so I had a single scoop of not too sweet grapfruit sorbet along with a small limoncello. This is a chef working at the height of her powers. Feel very lucky to have booked here. There was live music from a guitarist which added to the special vibe.
Consistently great restaurant w/ outstanding food.
One of the all time best on Sanibel Island. Great food with nice atmosphere.
Just so so
Good but it great! guess I expected more with all the spectacular reviews. Server clearly wished he could have been any where else!
We had dinner at Sweet Melissa's twice w ...
We had dinner at Sweet Melissa's twice while visiting Sanibel Island. Great service and excellent choices, we had Fish Stew & Pompano which were outstanding.
Interesting and unique preparations usin ...
Interesting and unique preparations using fresh and local ingredients. Very nice accompaniments to the main disjes, e.g.lentils CO led with banana. Very good, yet reasonably priced wine list. Definitely a cut above the typical beachside restaurant.
One of our favorite restaurants on the island
This was our third time at Sweet Melissa. We are bog foodies and enjoy going out while vacationing on Sanibel. This is one of our favorite destinations. Always great service and inventive menu items. Would recommend to anyone looking for a nice meal out.
good amibance and great food
the food was great! We had small potion of entree and two side plates. the mussels are delicious. The fish stew was decent, flaovorful and cozy. The only negative part to me is the sauce is a bit salty.
Outstanding in all aspects
Reservations highly recommended. Server was knowledgeable and helpful. "Small plates" are meal size, unusual combinations of ingredients. Goat cheese cheesecake with pistachios & honey was excellent.
WORTH THE WAIT!!!
I made reservations for Sweet Melissa's in February for my very special friend's very special birthday because I had read the reviews and heard all the hype. WE WERE NOT DISAPPOINTED!!! From the moment we arrived to the last bit of dessert; we were able to relax and enjoy the company, wine, and food without feeling rushed or having the conversation interrupted. The menu is simple yet the combination of ingredients make for an exquisite taste experience. Our server was extremely knowledgeable about the preparation of the menu and the appropriate wine pairing. We will definitely return to Sweet Melissa's and recommend this fine establishment.
Interesting & Inventive Menu
We thoroughly enjoyed the interesting and well prepared dishes. Nothing was boring about the food in this restaurant. The wait staff was great. We went there for a special occasion and were not disappointed. It is a bit pricey, but well worth it.
Extraordinary food, superb service, fine wine list - a Sanibel Island favorite for many years now and we will continue to come back!! Did I mention superb drinks from the bar? Heartily recommend!!
Great Dining Experience Every Time
Sweet Melissa's is on of our go-to dining spots. We can always count on interesting choices and tastes.
Innovative and generally delicious food. ...
Innovative and generally delicious food. Excellent pork belly and clam small plate. Also excellent watermelon, feta and heirloom tomato salad. The scallop in the seafood stew was undercooked, but the stew was otherwise outstanding, especially the cobia. Appreciated the thoughtful service of a spoon and seafood fork with the stew. Scallops in entree dish disappointing.
The fish dishes were creative, fresh and ...
The fish dishes were creative, fresh and tasty. The service was excellent. We especially liked the half portion option allowing us all to enjoy appetizers without feeling over indulged. One of the best fine food options on Sanibel.
The food was so salty I sent it back and got a salad which was OK. My friend ordered the scallops which were mushy and overcooked. I would be hesitant to come back again.
I am only sorry it took me so long to discover this restaurant! Our server was top-notch; professional, enthusiastic, personable, and knowledgeable. We are both 'foodies', and the menu was well curated, and every dish lived up to it's description. VERY satisfied!
Sanibel's Best Gourmet Restaurant
Every time we dine at Sweet Melissa's Cafe there is an exquisite surprise waiting on the daily specials. The regular menu items are always delightful, too, and we have a favorite appetizer that we get every time we go there--the cheese platter. It makes for a leisurely start to a lovely dining experience.
Favorite Restaurant in Sanibel
A gem of a restaurant on Sanibel Island.The food is inventive and delicious,wine list excellent with a wide range of prices,specialty cocktails excellent- not your typical "lemon drop ". The bartender smokes the rye and makes special ice cubes for a cocktail called Smoke gets in your rye. The staff is professional in every way.I especially like the choice of half portions on the entrées.An appetizer,half potion entrée and dessert = prefect. I highly recommend it for people who love food. The experience is what Dinning should be.
Love the creativity and the different di ...
Love the creativity and the different dishes we can share.
Not bad, not great.
Just an okay place to eat while on vacation on Sanibel Island. A little pricey but we'd return.
Sweet Melissa's is always a must on ever ...
Sweet Melissa's is always a must on every trip to Sanibel. Incredible food with farm fresh ingredients. The staff is also wonderful. It's just a comfortable place to enjoy some of the best food you will ever experience!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.