About Shula's Steak House - Birmingham
Rated "One of the top 5 Steak Houses in America", Shula's offers Premium Black Angus Beef & the freshest seafood. This elegant dining experience is themed after the Miami Dolphins 1972 perfect season.
Steak, Seafood, American
Hours of Operation:
Bar Area- 4:00 PM-9:30 PM
Dining Room- 5:00 PM-9:30 PM
$50 and over
AMEX, Carte Blanche, Diners Club, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
Complimentary parking available at the front of the Hyatt Regency Birmingham - Wynfrey Hotel
Bar/Lounge, Beer, Full Bar, Gluten-free Menu, Non-Smoking, Private Room, Wheelchair Access, Wine
Shula's Birmingham offers 2 private dining rooms, The Wine Room accommodating up to 16 guests & the Private Dining Room accommodating up to 32 guests. Both rooms offer a 50" plasma screen for presentations & sporting events.
Shula's Steak House - Birmingham Ratings and Reviews
My experience at your Birmingham locatio ...
My experience at your Birmingham location was more than disappointing. The New York Strip steak was improperly cut and prepared. My date had a Prime Rib that was good. The waiter offered to remove the steak from my ticket or replace. I came to eat, so I said replace with a Prime Rib. The manager came over later and I confirmed my choice, but asked for it to be a "to go" order. When I got home, the steak was not replaced. It was another poorly butchered New York Strip.
I will not be back.
W. Larry Hunt J.D.
The service and food both met our expect ...
The service and food both met our expectations! My wife and I were there for our anniversary so looking for a nice evening and unrushed dinner this was a perfect choice. I asked to be placed somewhere quiet which they did for us and made sure we were taken care of without being bothered. I would highly recommend for special occasion for sure.
If you know your death would come tomorr ...
If you know your death would come tomorrow, eat at Shula's for your last meal! I travel the country for business and have eaten everywhere, but Shula's steaks are the best I have had bar-none. I just wish I saved room for desert. Excellent food in every respect!
The restaurant met and exceeded my high ...
The restaurant met and exceeded my high expectations. It is not cheap, so this is not the place for you if you a wanting a cheap meal. However, it was one of the best meals I have ever had. One thing I wish I had known was that the sides are big enough to share. They are separate from the meal, and we all got sides when we could have shared. That will save you some money and keep you wasting food. Overall, I highly recommend this restaurant!! We will definitely be returning!
The Good- Dave provided great detail ser ...
The Good- Dave provided great detail service with a teammate to help..they are great.
The Bad- The Steak...I ordered my Strip Steak "Pittsburgh Style"...when it was served...it was obviously not Pittsburgh Style...i informed Dave...and he took it back.... then returned with same steak with a little darker (and dryer) top part of the steak. There was NO CHAR like a Pittsburgh Style should have. I really question if ya'll even know what "Pittsburgh Style" means. All nice steak restaurants do.
I was not about to send it back again. So...it cut into this steak...it was tough...huge piece of Grissle running thru it. It was not tender....Itty was NOT a prime cut of meat. Disappointed.
At the end of the meal...a manager named Shawn came by and asked how our dinner was...I shrugged my shoulders...he inquired...and I told him ....he asked if the chef came out after I sent steak back...I said no. I reiterated my disappointment in the steak. He apologized. The End.
I am not sure Don Shula would have been served such meat.
Upon discussing with my dinner mates on the way home, they complained about the quality, toughness of their steaks as well.
I am kicking myself for making reservations there...spending $300 for 3 for dinner there.
Now...get this....today...3 days after this dinner...and lady from Shula's calls me for me to rate my experience...and I rated the service by Dave a 9...the food a 3 and gave details.
She was not taking notes nor asking follow up questions.....after I gave my review. "Thank you, I will pass this along...looking forward to seeing you again soon"
Lady, were u listening or just making the standard call.
After that call...Been there twice...First n Last
Tasty but loud
My husband and I frequently done here when we want to celebrate. The food is almost always amazing, and the wait staff is great. Hector is always so attentive and friendly. This visit, however, we were sat next to a loud business group conducting an eat and meet session and it was extremely distracting. Having a section for larger tables away from couples dining might be a good idea, especially when it is not busy.
Our family dined at Shula's on Saturday 14th and had a wonderful experience. The food was great - most of us had steaks which were excellent and cooked perfectly, one had scallops which were delicious. For an appetizer we had the seafood trio was a good choice. To top off the night we had chocolate lava cakes for dessert which were out of this world!! We found the wait staff to be very attentive and experienced an overall first class experience.
I can't believe our level of disappointment
My husband and I were in town for a concert (a birthday celebration for him). I thought I was treating him to a Five Star dinner- this was by far my worst dining experience ever. Our waiter - Lionel was rude, condescending and very inattentive. The one bright spot were the steaks, almost the only edible food we received. The lobster tail (at $32.00 additional) was dry and overcooked. The asparagus very, very bitter. The potato au gratin tasted like cardboard. The Shiraz came with a twist top (after being told he had to go down to the wine cellar to get our choice- it may have been poured into the bottle received from their "house wine"). We had to ask the maître 'd twice where our dinner was because we didn't want to be late to the concert.
We intentionally made an early reservation and the restaurant was not crowded.
All of this for the BARGAIN PRICE of $284.65
DO NOT WASTE YOUR TIME OR MONEY!!!!!
Shula's Steak House Birmingham Fantastic Filet
My wife and I had a great meal. We each had an 8 oz wet aged filet that was probably the best I have ever had. Very attentive service, great food and wine. It was our anniversary so they gave us a complimentary desert that was awesome.
Excellent dinner for a special evening. A bit pricey, especially the sides although delicious, but absolutely perfect steaks and service with nice surroundings. One suggestion, particularly for a restaurant at this price level, that maybe couples such as ourselves could be seated in a different area than families with children or larger groups? This location is in a nice hotel so may have a bit different clientele than other locations. Still overall a wonderful experience!
Skip this place. Go to Ruth Chris instead.
I'll try to be brief, the steak was fine, however the potatoe was rock hard not acceptable for twice baked.
The wine we selected, all $30-40 range were unavailable , the scotch a12 year old Dalwhinie was charged out as an 18 year old twice the price. I had that corrected by " Dave" the waiter who then charged our room twice for the dinner.
To summarize our dinner room charge was $465, oops, so sorry.
The general manager took no time to correct this "slight" error the next morning.
Next visit We suggest Olive Garden 100 yards from this hotel.
Our initial waiter came and introduced himself (I don't remember his name but he was a very tall, young, white guy. Then he disappeared. A very lovely man named Lionel took over and provided excellent service so it made things a little better. The food was not as good as it had been in our previous experiences. It was definitely not worth $250. We will not be back.
Went for our anniversary, Filet was awfu ...
Went for our anniversary, Filet was awful, no flavor. Too expensive... asked for sweet tea received un sweet when I told waiter, he brought back my tea with spoonfuls of sugar that had settled in the bottom... like they had just put the sugar in my cold tea, so it would not dissolve. Plan on never going back.
My husband and I visited Shula's for our Valentine's dinner. We were seated promptly and ordered quickly (we already knew what we wanted). From the time we sat down at the table till the time we left the restaurant took over two hours. It took our entree over an hour to be served to us and it was lukewarm at best. I don't know about other couples, but this was a special outing for us and I would have preferred not to spend two hours in a restaurant after being seated. On top of that, our server rarely came to our table. We waited on water several times until a bus boy finally came around to refill our glasses. The service was just pitiful! The crazy thing is the restaurant was not as busy as I expected, so there is no excuse for such lousy service. I will definitely think before I plan to go there again. That's a lot of money to spend on just a so-so experience.
One thing ruined it all
We celebrated Valentine's Day dinner at Shula's - our first trip there. I got a complimentary rose and my husband and I also got a complimentary glass of champagne - very nice. The cocktails were generous. We both had steaks with creamed spinach and potatoes gratin - all were very good, as was the Creme Brulee we had for dessert. The restaurant was out of the first 2 bottles of wine we ordered and then brought us the wrong bottle on our 3rd request. That was disappointing, but it was good and we drank it. The really disappointing aspect of this dinner (and I didn't realize it until the next morning when I was at home and had good lighting enough to really read the bill) was that the waiter did not tell us that they had added the gratuity in to the check already. I didn't notice it and added a generous gratuity on the line that said "room service charge" - wasn't really thinking about the fact that we were in a hotel and that line would be on the bill. We were not guests at the hotel, by the way. Usually when a gratuity has been added (typically when there is a party of 8 or more), the waiter points that out so that people don't add a full tip to the one already included. I called Shula's the next day to ask that my additional gratuity be removed (not a small amount). I had to leave a message and the Food & Beverage Coordinator called me back (she thought my call had to do with a room service charge!). When I explained what happened, she apologized and took my debit card information, email address, ticket number and waiter number and told me she would forward it to the manager at Shula's and copy me on the email so that I could see that it had been forwarded and correspond with the manager directly, if necessary. It is now 4 days later and I have received no email and the charge went through with the tip included. No credit has been issued to date. I am extremely disappointed with the lack of follow-through with this situation and will not be returning to Shula's.
Not so impressed
My date was not enthused with the ambiance nor the service. Price was a bit over what I expected for the amount of food received. Our salads were not delivered until we asked about them after the main course came out and were not true Caesar salads, more like alacart from the grocery store, not good. The constant attention by the staff to our water glasses on half full deterred from our conversation on a Valentines weekend date, which broke the mood and two visits from the manager to our table was a bit much as we did not ask a lot of questions. All in all, it was not the time I expected to have, even though I thought the steak was delicious and she enjoyed the crab cakes.
Not very good
Food was mediocre , staff was ok, waiter wiped his noise with his had taking the order, we stepped out for a moment and told our waiter we would be right back. When we returned our table and food had been cleaned off. They threw away my roses. Seemed rushed. Staff was eager to go home. Cleaning around us , sweeping the floors. Not very good for 250.00. Probably want be back or recommend .
Shula's for us is a "been there, done th ...
Shula's for us is a "been there, done that" kind of place. For the price I expected more. We have eaten at some top tier restaurants in the country for the same price that Shula's couldn't hold a candle too.
We had the calamari appetizer, it was some of the best I have had to date. I then had a wedge salad, good taste but nothing separated it from one I could have gotten at outback. Then came the steaks. We were disappointed in the preparedness of both of our steaks. We ordered both at medium rare. Mine was cooked to MR but my wife's was over cooked to near medium well. Both steaks were missing proper seasoning. They were just bland pieces of meat on a plate. We shared three of the sides, lobster mac & cheese, good flavor but a bit dry. Mashed potatoes, very good mashed potatoes. Steamed asparagus, cooked perfectly for the size but also was laking flavor. We had to use the leftover butter that came out with the bread to flavor it.
Water and tea was always empty. Holland ...
Water and tea was always empty. Hollandaise was refrigerator cold. Steaks were under cooked and when brought back everything was cold. Very expensive and disappointing meal. Waiter was rushed seemed to be serving all of the tables.
We had an outstanding dinner for my wife's Birthday. This place holds special meaning for us because I actually proposed to my wife in this restaurant (long story). The food was incredible. Service was attentive. Servers were knowledgeable and eager to please. Steaks were perfectly cooked, appetizers, salads, drinks....everything was just so well done. If you're in Birmingham and have given up on Shula's....reintroduce yourself. I would eat here every day of the week over Fleming's, Ruth Chris, or any other prime steakhouse in the area....its really not even close. Entree Suggestions: Bone in Filet and the Mixed Grill. Crabcake is a must for appetizer or as part of your meal. Thanks Shula's for a great experience. We will visit again soon!
Me and my Husband recently celebrated our 24th anniversary at Don Shula's steakhouse. I tried to get him to take me to my favorite restaurant Ruth's Chris but him being a sports fan in originally from Miami Florida he really wanted to go to Don Shula's so I made the reservation for the both of us we got there as soon as they open & were the first ones there. Immediately seated but that was the only good thing about the restaurant. Every drink we tried to order they could not find the mix or was out of, it took over hour for our food to arrive, our steaks were highly priced but very bland, my Spinach was very salty I had to add water to take some of the salt out, my husband said his mashed potatoes were the worst that he's ever had.I reported all this to our waitress and she apologized profusely but that does little when it's your anniversary and and you're spending top dollar for a meal. Completely ruined it fir us. If you are going to spend a large amount of money and you you want good food this is not the place. I recommend you stick with Ruth Chris or Pappadeaux's or somewhere familiar that you know we will never go back again and that says a lot because he is a hardcore Don Shula Fan being raised in Miami Florida.
Our dining experience was exceptional. My wife and I celebrated our 34th anniversary by taking our adult children out for dinner. The only issue I had was the pricing was a little bit higher than I expected. They are more expensive than Ruth's Chris steak house, so be prepared for the bill. Otherwise, a wonderful experience.
A steak house that lives up to its character. Not inexpensive but worth the price when you bite into one of the thick, juicy, cooked as you requested, steaks. They also had non steak entrees but why would you order something other than a steak here? Our waiter brought over a table filled with the actual steak types that were available before we made our choices. The various sides , priced separately were spot on. Cocktails were of ample size. Service was very good. You are not rushed. Overall a great meal . Wish there was one were we live. This one was in Birmingham, Alabama.
Unfortunately, I had high expectations that simply were not met. The restaurant was not busy and the food came out slowly. While the servers were well trained and very polite, service was just off a beat. The steak, which was presented as "the best money can buy" helped with the high expectations and between being prepared poorly and the gristle, it simply did not meet that of a premium steakhouse.
Above & Beyond
This was an anniversary dinner and I noted this when reserving the table. Unlike other places, Shula's Steak House staff actually made the night special for us. First, our waiter congratulated us and then we were offered a free dessert (made to order apple cobbler a la mode...I highly recommend this). Everything was top drawer!
Please sign in to record your input. Thanks!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.