About Sarabeth's Central Park South
Great any time of day! Breakfast, Lunch, Afternoon Tea, Dinner and Brunch(Sat-Sun)
“Not just for Brunch.” "Not for many, many years now, and certainly not on Central Park South,” comments Frank Bruni of the New York Times about our wonderful dinner menu. Join us for an evening meal and reverse your thinking - Sarabeth's for Dinner.
Hours of Operation:
Breakfast: Monday - Friday: 8:00am - 3:30pm;
Lunch: Monday - Friday: 11:30am - 3:30pm;
Afternoon Tea: Monday - Friday: 3:30pm - 5:00pm, Saturday - Sunday: 4:00pm - 5:00pm;
Dinner: Monday - Saturday: 5:00pm - 11:00pm, Sunday: 5:00pm - 10:00pm;
Brunch: Saturday - Sunday: 8:00am - 4:00pm
Between 5th and 6th Avenues
$30 and under
AMEX, Diners Club, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
Discounted parking is available at Quik Park Garage located at 125 West 58th Street.
N, R & W trains to 5th Avenue, A, B, C, D & 1 trains to Columbus Circle, and the F train 57th Street.
Private Party Contact:
Greta Tralongo: 646-590-4184x
Banquet/Private Rooms, Bar Dining, Beer, Cafe, Counter Seating, Delivery, Full Bar, High Tea, Non-Smoking Restaurant, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Personal wines welcome, Personal wines welcome (corkage fee applies), Private Room, Takeout, View, Weekend Brunch, Wheelchair Access, Wine
Special Events & Promotions:
For special events details, pricing and availability please email email@example.com or leave us a voicemail at 646.590.4184
Sarabeth's Central Park South Ratings and Reviews
We've dined at Sarabeth's multiple times ...
We've dined at Sarabeth's multiple times and we love the food. I was bit disappointed that we were asked to leave right after we were done paying. We were told that there is a 2 hour limit for brunch. It would be nice to have known that beforehand. The wait had to confirm the order again and when the food came out, they weren't sure who ordered what. I'm glad i used to restroom afterwards because i saw cockroaches in there and grossed me out. I can only imagine what i would find in the kitchen. I was disappointed and expected better from a place that's not the cheapest.
Love this place! The food is excellent , ...
Love this place! The food is excellent , the service is great and the location is fabulous. I'm surprised to see reviews saying it's expensive. We paid less than we would have at the same quality restaurant in our small town.
Had a late lunch with my girlfriends and ...
Had a late lunch with my girlfriends and the staff was friendly. The food was outstanding. We ordered the seafood guacamole as an appetizer. I got the seafood Cobb salad also Delicious, my friend got the adult grilled cheese it came with a tomato soup on the side( it complimented the grill cheese), and my other friend got the crab cake sandwich which came with fries. I would go there again for a date or even another hang out with friends.
The food was a big disappointment. The p ...
The food was a big disappointment. The poached eggs on the eggs Benedict had to be sent back as they were over cooked.
The French Toast was dry which was a shame since it was a good quality bread (they needed to soak a bit more in the eggs).
At least my short rib hash was good.
Would not likely return.
I was alone and seated as soon as I came ...
I was alone and seated as soon as I came in. Shortly afterward, two 2-top tables were seated on either side of me. I ordered first (a Berry Bowl and pancakes) then the two tables shortly afterward. Both tables were served their food and nearly done with their dishes (all egg orders) by the time our waiter decided to check on everyone's progress. This was the first time I was able to ask about where my order was. It finally appeared about five minutes later. I can only assume that he originally failed to give my order to the kitchen. I never received an apology from him. Unfortunately, I was only able to eat the berry bowl as the pancakes were under cooked and gummy. I wasn't about to request a new order as there was no telling how much longer everything would take. Coffee, berry bowl, and pancakes came to just under $50.
The buttermilk pancakes are still the be ...
The buttermilk pancakes are still the best and my daughter has them every time we come to visit. I try something different and this time had the short rib hash. It was ok...not amazing. I think I will go back to the lemon ricotta pancakes. Our reservation was for 8 am and though the place was not packed (yet), the server was not as attentive. I am not sure if I prefer the ones who are constantly checking to refill your cup of coffee or the ones who leave you alone to enjoy and "stay a while" ( I.e. not rushing you out the door to make way for the next party). There must be a nice balance somewhere. I always look forward to Sarabeth's but maybe it's time to try something new for breakfast in NYC.
Although Sarabeth's is famous for brunch ...
Although Sarabeth's is famous for brunch, we went for dinner and the food was pretty good - the beet salad and the farm chicken were great even. The desserts were good, but nothing to write home about. The service was inconsistent - our waitress went from overly bothersome when we were waiting for one of the guests to arrive (he was in the restroom and the same waitress came by THREE times to try to take his place setting away) to unable to track her down to get dessert menus. Overall, it was fine for dinner. Simple, American food at reasonably elevated NYC prices.
I thought this restaurant was incredibly ...
I thought this restaurant was incredibly overrated. Not one person cracked a smile the entire time. The hostess just seemed perturbed and the waiter had a scowl on his face and walked away before I had even finished ordering. If the food had been any good I might have overlooked this. The omelette was mediocre at best and I have had better at my local greasy spoon. The French toast was okay but nothing special and pretty dry. Decor is completely dated and the bathroom was disgusting. Honestly, there are many better places to eat in New York and this was by far the worst meal we had on our trip.
Good food, great location, terrible serv ...
Good food, great location, terrible service. The crabmeat guacamole was worth going back for on it's own, the tomato soup was the best part of the adult grilled cheese, the meatballs left me wanting more, while the charred broccolini was not charred at all but doused and sauteed in too much butter - disappointing. Awesome location just across from Central Park and next to The Plaza. Cute and quiet outdoor patio. Waiter would not stop pressing us to order cocktails - at least 4 or 5 times he mentioned it and followed up with multiple 'are you sure's when we continued to decline. Took forever to order and get the bill.
I took my 11 year old niece to Sarabeth' ...
I took my 11 year old niece to Sarabeth's for brunch before a Wednesday matinee theatre performance. Brunch was very good, as expected. I had lemon ricotta pancakes, she had buttermilk pancakes and of course, we took home some signature muffins and preserves. The omelettes looked delightful, but we did not order one.
Sarabeth's is popular with locals and tourists, so we had to wait about 20 minutes beyond our after our reservation before being seated, but food was served quickly and it did not impede our outing.
I book Sarabeth's for business breakfast ...
I book Sarabeth's for business breakfasts on a fairly regular basis. The food is not cheap, but the quality is very high and the service is good- they always are quick and attentive. At times it can be bit noisy, but not overbearing by any means. For breakfast, it is a good option outside of the hotels and you don't have to wait in line as you would in a diner. I recommend it highly.
Disappointed in the Restaurant Week Lunc ...
Disappointed in the Restaurant Week Lunch Menu. Two of us dining. The first courses were good, not great: Gazpacho and Bruschetta. The main courses were good, not great: Crepes and Jumbo Prawns. The desserts were forgettable for sure and seemed to just be an accommodation. We had both and only ate barely half of each. We will only go back for breakfast and hope it is as good as we remember.
Expensive for two people for an ordinary ...
Expensive for two people for an ordinary breakfast. Service was not The decor is unappealing. Low ceiling and crowds of people waiting for tables surrounded us while we ate. It was loud and generally unpleasant. I prefer other Sarabeth locations more than CPW one. The location on CPS is convenient to where we live, but I probably will not return.
To be clear, Sarabeths is one of my favo ...
To be clear, Sarabeths is one of my favorite brunch places- anywhere. That being said, the Central Park South location was a far cry from the Madison Ave location. The food was great -- but the noise and service was a far cry from what makes Sarabeth's special.
We anticipated a great breakfast based o ...
We anticipated a great breakfast based on the menu. It was mediocre and while we never mind high prices for a great experience and food, this was overpriced for the value. Every coffee they poured me was cold. The wait staff was aloof.
My wife and I dined on Sunday early even ...
My wife and I dined on Sunday early evening with a friend. Our first visit. We made our reservation via Opentable for 6:15pm. We arrived a few minutes early to find they did not have our reservation. I found out later that they had actually canceled it for some unknown reason. Anyway, they sat us a nice table and our dinner began with no issue. We had questions on the menu due to some minor food restrictions we have. The waitress was certain that any vegetable changes to our entrée would require a "side dish" upcharge. I politely insisted for her to check with the Chef or her management and she reluctantly did so. Amazingly, they would substitute one vegetable for another. The overall service level was just average. Seemed forced!
Food was good. When our bill arrived I'm glad I reviewed it carefully as there was a significant mistake. The manager corrected it.
Maybe we just caught them on a bad night or they feel that their location on 59th across from Central Park is enough but I will not go there again.
I loved the food and smoothies! The plac ...
I loved the food and smoothies! The place was very busy so needed a reservation but was wept th it. Didn't have wifi which was disappointing in a restaurant so lovely. The waiter who served us seemed very unhappy to be there, again a shame. But overall, I would be back for the delicious food. Well done Sarabeths!
I used to go to upper east side one of t ...
I used to go to upper east side one of their restaurant, and first time to go to CPS one.
Good ambiance and we like it.
One thing we would like them to improve is that they have very limited choice of things for the gift. Hope they have a few more.
First time at this specific Sarabeth's l ...
First time at this specific Sarabeth's location. A little too touristy, but the same excellent food, and the best coffee in New York City. Had the lemon ricotta pancakes. The best pancakes I've eaten. Everyone (4 of us) loved the brunch.
Overrated. I don't get the hype. I can g ...
Overrated. I don't get the hype. I can get a better, cheaper breakfast at a diner than this place. I went there on a Friday morning for breakfast. I ordered apricot coconut waffles and a side of sausage; my friend ordered lemon ricotta pancakes and a side of bacon. In addition, we had two glasses of juice and one cup of coffee. The waffles were awful. They were so over-cooked and tough that I needed a knife to saw through them. In addition, the flavor was bland. They simply burned up some plain waffle batter and threw some apricot preserves and coconut on top. The sausage had decent flavor but I really didn't taste any apricot, except for the dollop of apricot preserves that were on top of the sausage. The lemon ricotta pancakes were pretty good. Light and flavorful. The bacon was so-so. The service was awful. Perhaps their brunch is worth the time and money but based on my experience, I'm not a fan and don't plan on coming back.
I don't normally write reviews but I was ...
I don't normally write reviews but I was so disappointed with Sarabeth's that I feel compelled to write this review. Bottom line - very overpriced and uninspired. I would not have minded spending over $100 for three people if the food was great. It was not. For over $100 we received one orange juice, two cups of coffee and three entrees. My omelette came with two small pieces of toast - nothing else. Not even a sprig of decoration. Other higher end venues (Norma's, The Smith, Bubby's, Fig and Olive) are a much better value and more fun. I had taken two people from out of town for a treat. I left feeling disappointed.
I apologize this is so long but it's nec ...
I apologize this is so long but it's necessary.
Food was great. Service was terrible from start to finish. Visited for dinner on a Wednesday night during restaurant week. Place was relatively empty. Our server was very nice but that was about as far as the service went. Took a while to get our drinks & in the 40 minutes we sat waiting for food, we were never offered bread (i had to ask a random person for it who told our waitress & then 10 minutes later I had to ask the waitress again), our drinks (water included) were refilled once during the hour & a half we sat at the table. It was like everyone was told to look busy but no one was actually doing anything. Except our server, who was running back & forth constantly. She never had anything in her hands mind you. If she wasn't running around she could be found at the computer station. Entrees were dropped by a food runner & our server came over once during the meal to ask how things were - fine. I ended up doing the restaurant week menu but my boyfriend ordered from the regular menu. 15 minutes after we finished eating our plates were cleared by someone other than our server & then she came over to ask if I was ready for dessert. (just me, no acknowledgement to my boyfriend) We were never offered coffee & my boyfriend wasn't even offered a dessert menu. When the dessert came I then had to wait to separately find the server again & ask for a spoon. Ugh! if the food wasn't so good...
On a side note: I made mention of the bad service to the "manager" before we left. She took my name, phone number & email address & seemed shocked & completely understanding & horrified when I told her about our experience. My guess is she is an actress waiting to be found because I did not hear one peep from the place!! I waited 2 weeks to hear from anyone before writing this. I shouldnt've.
There are thousands of restaurants in the city & this one just got put on my never visit again list.
-Sincerely, a first & last time customer
Please sign in to record your input. Thanks!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.