They ambiance was perfect, this wasn’t our first time, however, everything always gets better!
The ambiance was great! We had the New Zealand Rack of Lamb for dinner and it was outstanding. For dessert we shared the Creme Brule which was delicious . We can't wait to come back.
Mother’s Day dinner. The meal was nice but the price point seemed higher than the overall product and experience. The staff was friendly and the food was good.
Mother’s Day brunch. Limited menu, but done very well.
Excellent overall restaurant with nice outdoor seating and tasty menu. Our service was superb as well.
We had just completed a sunset sail and were looking for a new place for dinner. We found Old City House on Open Table, and thought we'd give it a try. It was close to our hotel and had an 845p available reservation. Upon arrival, we announced our Open Table reservation, and the person (manager? ) said "well... OK, but we close in 15 minutes". 1) if you plan to close in 15 minutes, why did you advertise having a reservation available? Advertising an available reservation says "come eat here!". 2) even if THAT was a mistake, why be rude?
We sat at the bar, and my husband ordered dinner. The food was just average, and because it was so late, the salad didn't seem fresh. Like it was the last of the lettuce for that day and overly dressed to compensate. The cioppino wasn't a classic cioppino in terms of flavor, but was OK. It was mostly fish and the few mussels were enormous and rubbery. We had just eaten at Collage the night before, so that amazing meal combined with the rude greeting might be coloring the rest of my experience here, but with so many other great dining options in St. Augustine, I can't see any reason to go back.
We had a reservation for 8pm and finally got seated at 845. The food was good but that about all I can say.
Everything was prepared perfectly and tasted great.
Amazing place. We were visiting st Augustine and this was recommended. Perfect meal!
Great food. Service not so much. Had a 60 ish year old woman as our server. She was also the bar tender so we waited on everything and she didn’t know the flavor sorbet she served us as the “pallet cleanser” and didn’t know the cheeses on the cheese plate. That is plain odd. But all food was great!
Worst experience ever have had. Reservation was for 8 pm got there at 7:45 and got seated at 8:10. We ordered drinks and food. I ordered my steak medallions extra well done. After 35 minutes the waitress came out and apologized for the wait and said "it's because the way you ordered it" then laughed. Well another 15 minutes went by and she said " ETA is 4 minutes". After another 20 minutes we left money on the table for drinks and started walking out. She came out of the kitchen and saw us and yelled back into the kitchen " don't worry about it they just left". This was my husband and my 28th anniversary and we ended up getting 2 slices of pizza for dinner. Thanks for nothing Old City House.
Nice atmosphere and excellent food. Perfect for special occasions.
Convenient location and great food in heart of historic district.
Great food but the service was not so good. We waited for 45 minutes to be seated for a reservation.
We both had the rack of lamb and it was excellent. We also loved the corn risotto -- very imaginative and a little bit of a kick from the Dalit Pepper. Service was responsive and thoughtful. Would definitely return.
We started our meal with a cheese plate. Nothing to write home about. Certainly this high end restaurant should have high end cheeses. Our entrees--chicken parmesan Milanese and the Swordfish special were outstanding. The corn risotto was very tasty. We ended our meal with a key lime tart which was compliments of the restaurant for our anniversary.
A good meal in a vintage home turned inn.
Thematically confused. Is this Italian or French not really sure. Starting at the beginning. The bread was hard the baked garlic rubbery. The wine selection uninspired and limited. We ordered the escargot and crab soup. The latter good the former rather weak with little flavor too heavy on the garlic. We both ordered the bouillabaisse which was just okay. We order a decent wine that was served on dishwasher safe glasses. Hardly appropriate glassware for fine dining. Interestingly the palate cleanse was very good suggesting that the talent is there just restricted. Don’t understand how this rates #2 when #1 stands so far apart.
Nice cozy restaurant. A bit pricey but good food. Great location.
Service very slow. Took 20 minutes to get first drink. Waitress insisted on us hearing the specials before doing anything for us. Will give it another try since the food and venue were very good.
Great location, Fabulous food. Peggy was great host/server. We had tomato soup and a special swordfish covered with crab and crab soup and veal meatloaf. Will definitely tell others about this restaurant and will come back again.
Was a little disappointed in the menu. Very small. Had a good glass of wine and the veal meatloaf I had was very good and the chef didn't overcook the asparagus. The portion was enough I took home part of the entrée for a meatloaf sandwich.
A bit disappointing. Escargot Bourguignonne came out swimming in butter and garlic: no red wine at all. I mentioned to her that the menu said Bourguignonne and she said she didn’t know what Bourguignonne sauce was. She was very sweet and I think she was helping serve because it was a busy day (Easter Sunday). She said she would ask the kitchen but never gave us a response and I didn’t want to ask again because it wasn’t her fault. My wife’s Chicken Milanese was very good. I tried the vegetable lasagna (no pasta) and I didn’t like the flavor. There was too much filler. Not sure what the filler was but it gave it a weird texture and flavor. This is a high dollar restaurant and the overall experience was not at all worth what we paid.
It was good food but the parking is an absolute nightmare. We actually had some crazy woman standing in a parking place “saving” it for someone “on the way”. Too many other good restaurants to have to deal with this.
We made a reservation for Easter lunch...we were absolutely overwhelmed with how great the restaurant was on all levels. Delicious desserts, too! Can’t wait to return for dinner soon.
Fabulous meal on Easter Sunday
We've lived in the area for our lives, but have never tried Old City House. That was a misstate and we have some making up to do by frequenting this restaurant again in the near future. The meal was great and the intimate dining room and personal service made for a great night to celebrate my wife's birthday. Its not cheap by any means, but a good value due to the quality of the meal served. Definitely at the top of our list in St. Augustine from now on!
Our server Mack was attentive and provided us with wonderful service of a delicious dinner
Second time here and loved it again. Food was excellent and love the size and quietness if this restaurant. Wish the wine list was a little more extensive.
Food was amazing
Very good food and pleasant service !! We enjoyed cappuccino martinis and a delicious meal ! Highly recommended !!
Excellent restaurant and would definitely go back. Service was very good food was excellent.
We were celebrating a family birthday. The experience was perfect. The food exceeded our expectations. Our server made sure that every detail was perfect, including a dessert for the birthday girl. We can't wait to go back.
Good food, good service. Older crowd and very quiet. Ambiance was nice but nothing too exciting or unique which may be perfect for some and not ideal for others.
Great food, great service!
We were a group of four friends, arrived for a 730pm reservation. We were sat immediately ordered drinks and appetizer. The wine list was great , I got a bottle to share which was excellent and friends had cocktails which they enjoyed. We ordered escargot for our appetizer YUM! And no shells so we cleared them in no time. I shouldve kept the bread to sop up the left over yumminess! We ordered pork chop, rack of lamb, osso bucco and fish. There was a delay getting our entrees, we were informed by our waiter, due to a mishap in the kitchen with one of them, we were given extra drinks and dessert to compensate. All the food was excellent, my fav was my hubbys rack of lamb. The waiter was friendly attentive and informative. Id say the place is best suited to special occasions and quiet intimate date nights. We sat inside but next time wed like to try the patio seating it looked cozy and charming.
Food was very well prepared! Our server was informative, friendly, and attentive. We will be back!!!
All other reviews were in line with our experience. Seats were uncomfortable, service was slow, food was good (not great) but overpriced. Decor is dated. Very poor bar selection. Needs a Reno/refresh.
Excellent food. If you are a fan of rack of lamb, theirs is terrific! The patio is a very nice setting in the evening with the lights in the trees. It was very chilly, so we asked to have the outdoor heaters turned on. The first osne was broken so they had to bring a second one. The only other snafu was our cocktail order. Although two of us ordered the same drink, was one served in a much smaller glass.