Welcome to our beautifully restored Victorian with a contemporary twist. Neumanali opened six years ago and quickly became a neighborhood favorite. The menu features both fresh and seasonal entrees in addition to a selection of fun and unusual small plates. Perennial favorites are the pan-seared day boat scallops and "made to order" cioppino. The wine list is a bit eclectic and features smaller, more difficult to find winery selections. Lush garden dining is available in the summer and fall.
Hours of Operation:
Dinner: Tuesday - Saturday: 5:30PM - 9:00PM
$31 to $50
AMEX, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
Located behind restaurant.
Located across the street from Hayward City Hall, BART and all bus lines.
Julie Romic Mckillop
Private Party Facilities:
Restaurant available for private parties. Please contact us for further details.
Private Party Contact:
Julie McKillop: 5107503921
Banquet, Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Corkage Fee, Counter Seating, Farm to Table, Non-Smoking, Outdoor dining, Wheelchair Access, Wine
Neumanali Ratings and Reviews
My husband and I have been going to Neum ...
My husband and I have been going to Neumanali for the past 7 years, for all kinds of occasions, with friends and family. It is one of our top 5 restaurants to go in the East Bay. We love this hidden gem, a lovely Victorian building, on a quiet street near downtown Hayward. The resturant has about 12 tables, and an outside patio for the warm summer nights. The ambience is elegant, and romantic, with candlelights, fresh flowers, and original paintings on the walls. Tables are arranged spaciousoy apart so you can enjoy the meal, without being forced to hear other people's conversations.
The food is always superb, with a great variety of selections. We like to order their Cajun shrimps, rack of lamb , filet mignon and pork chop. Portions are quite generous, and very often, my husband and I just share the food. They automatically split the dish for us without extra charge. Their bread pudding is my favorite dessert. They also have a great wine list, reasonably priced. We enjoyed their Argentinian red wine from the Melbac region. It is only $28 a bottle.
Service is impeccable. Abram is the host, and waiter. He runs the whole dining room, but keep things flowing smoothly alone.
We love going to Neumanali, and highly recommend others to treat themselves there for an enjoyable dining experience, or celebrating some special occasions with loved ones. ( without breaking the bank!)
I stumbled upon this place while killing ...
I stumbled upon this place while killing time waiting for the bus. the location places it off the beaten path making the experience quiet and quaint. the historic Victorian house looks exquisite and the dining room is cozy and inviting. the paintings that adorn the walls add to the ambience and the wine racks located toward the entrance are impressive even if you don't imbibe. this truly is Hayward's best kept secret and I highly recommend this location to any foodie.
We were celebrating two birthdays in one ...
We were celebrating two birthdays in one dinner night out, and our kids (sons ages 13 and 10) really enjoyed their meals. My older son thought it was a bit dark in the restaurant. The service was spectacular and the restaurant is managed very well. We felt very cared for and the staff was super friendly. We received our meals very quickly. The food was tasty. We would recommend our friends to give Neumanali a try. Thanks! :-)
Interesting location, small menu but onl ...
Interesting location, small menu but only a few wine by the glass options, but the chardonnay was very good. Dinner was very nice and my Caesar salad was fresh but a little blah. I wish some of the small plates were offered as a dinner just to have a few more options. It would be nice to have some salt and pepper shakers on the table. Only one waiter is the norm according to previous reviews. But he was very good at his job. Plan on a long and leisurely evening to enjoy your dinner.
Second time there. Seems to only be one ...
Second time there. Seems to only be one wait person who manages to take care of everyone. Unfortunately, I think he's too busy to chat a little, but he is efficient and keeps things going. I'm amazed at how he handles it all!
Food is very good, wine selection good too! I've been there once without a reservation and had no problem. Second time with reservations for 4 people, no trouble at all.
The food was good but not quite in line ...
The food was good but not quite in line with the price and the service was solicitous but clunky- reaching across me to move plates around many times. Since we were at a small table in the middle of the dining room, there was plenty of room to move around the table, rather than forcing me to dodge repeatedly. The wine by the glass menu was limited.
Service was unusually slow due to the si ...
Service was unusually slow due to the singular waiter on a Friday night. 45 minutes of wait time for dinner. The customers next to us were served first although they were seated 20 minutes after we were. The waiter was pretentious, acting in affected formalities, like handing over the knife with his pinky up & using a tone of voice that can be described as declamatory. Why the need for all this grandiose affectations? Only to be served food that was barely seasoned & lukewarm.
The solo waiter opened the evening and w ...
The solo waiter opened the evening and was kept busy. This may account for the fact that while cordial in attending our table well, he telegraphed a stern and unapproachable demeanor that was somewhat off-putting. He did, however, remembered that this was a birthday celebration and brought out the dessert with a celebratory candle. On the whole, we enjoyed Neumanali for its lovely setting and ambience, as well as the relaxed pacing of our dinner.
Neumanali is a special "find" in Hayward ...
Neumanali is a special "find" in Hayward. Great food and excellent service in an intimate setting. The restaurant is housed in a historical victorian with great jazz oil paintings. I have never had a bad meal here. If you order the pork chop make sure that you haven't eaten for a day. It is a double double. I like their lamb and chopped avaocado salad. You can't go wrong
My wife and I were on our way from Castr ...
My wife and I were on our way from Castro Valley to Dublin for a Friday night date night when we were met with unforgiving traffic. I quickly went to Open Table and found Neumanali as a local and available for reservation. We quickly cancelled our original reservation and made a new one with Neumanali. I was previously aware of this restaurant but quite honestly my wife and I both enjoy a cocktail before dinner and Neumanali only serves wine and in the past this had kept us from dining there before. What a mistake on our part. We were greeted by one of the partners at the door and sat in a particularly pleasant surrounding. Beautiful decorated surroundings and most enjoyable jazz music filled the room. We started by sharing Goat Cheese Salad...Wonderful! A great start. My only regret was that I did not order my own. Although everything on the menu looked great, we were both in the mood for meat. I selected the Rib Eye and my wife chose the Filet. I have had a few steaks in my day and I have to say this was one of the best seasoned steaks that I have ever had. Perfectly cooked too. My wife's Filet was equally enjoyable. We finished with Cheesecake for desert and it was the perfect finish to a fantastic meal. Oh by the way...we never missed not having a cocktail and enjoyed very much the wines recommended by our server. We will be back!
a wonderful repeat location for us. as ...
a wonderful repeat location for us. as before, food was amazing (still thinking about the steamed clams), service was charming and perfect (despite having to cover the garden/dining room/front), a wonderful meal in such a peaceful setting (garden). would be nice to see a freshening of the menu, always high quality ingredients.
What a fantastic neighborhood find on Op ...
What a fantastic neighborhood find on OpenTable. Thank you! We were seated promptly and the pacing of service was excellent.
We wanted a quiet place with good food so that we could have dinner with our 82 year old mom and her caregiver and easily converse. This restaurant has convenient parking and is easily accessible by people of limited mobility. The food was fantastic.
And we ran into some diners on the back patio that had their dogs with them as they dined. We'll definitely come back with our dogs next time.
A great restaurant that serves as both our "perennial favorite" whenever we want to dine out but also the sophisticated "foodie" restaurant where I can take corporate clients and partners who are tired of the typical high-end chain restaurants.
I strongly recommend reservations since it is a small intimate restaurant but I can typically get in without much advanced planning.
Upscale Neighborhood Restaurant
This restaurant is a charming find in downtown Hayward. It is in a converted Victorian house, and the ambience is both elegant and homey. The food was excellent, and the service was even better. A definite for a return visit.
Great food, great service
I took my wife here for her birthday, I had the ribeye and my wife had the fillet. They were both cooked perfectly but my wife's steak had way too much cracked pepper on it. She scraped off as much as she could but it was overwhelming with pepper. See had to send it back to the kitchen where they happily grilled her a new steak.
We had a nice romantic dinner and the waiter even bought my wife a slice of cheesecake for her birthday. The service was excellent and the food was great.
Please sign in to record your input. Thanks!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.