About Nantucket Prime
Nantucket Prime is an upscale island steakhouse, specializing in prime steaks, grilled fish, and raw bar.
American, Steakhouse, Seafood
Hours of Operation:
7 days a week
LUNCH: 11:30am – 5:00pm
DINNER: 5:30pm - 10pm
LATE NIGHT MENU: 10pm-12midnight - be sure to check out our daily additions!
PATIO BAR open until 1am
$31 to $50
AMEX, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
Nantucket Prime Ratings and Reviews
I made a reservation for two weeks in ad ...
I made a reservation for two weeks in advance realizing Nantucket can be a busy place. The restaurant was relatively quiet and we were seated outside, neck to the stairs. I asked to move inside which wasn't a problem. We ordered the Burrrata, for 19$ and it was 1/8 a slice of tomato and some cheese. When the dish was addressed with the waitress she simply stated "this is how it comes". We left after the small snack.
Really a gorgeous night! We were seated ...
Really a gorgeous night! We were seated immediately in garden-nice al fresco experience. Drinks, raw bar and a lovely heirloom tomato/stone fruit salad all were lovely. Great entree choices beyond steaks-the pan roasted lobster sounded so tempting but we were trying to switch it up so focused on aged steaks. All perfect and sides were presented /seasoned well. Kids enjoyed as well and devoured it all... Hard to get the perfect mix across ages, trends and palates...but it worked! Coffees, desserts also great-passionfruit sorbet and a brownie sundae. On par w/NYC restaurants but in a absolutely lovely Nantucket locale. Really a nice experience to round out the weekend. We'll be back they are doing all the right things from service, food and overall experience--it is obviously well planned/orchestrated to be this successful...So happy we chose this!
Great setting! Great food! Great barten ...
Great setting! Great food! Great bartender. But what happened in the kitchen? After waiting almost 30 minutes for our salads/starters; we then waited 45 minutes more for one entree (the other 3 came 6-7 minutes later) we truly enjoyed the food and the bartender waiting on us in the fun outdoor bistro worked very hard, but the manager made excuses and really never handled it the way she should have. We'll give Prime another try as setting superb, food excellent. Hopefully my next review will be even more positive.
When you have to send 3 out of 4 steaks ...
When you have to send 3 out of 4 steaks back, that's the sign of a bad "steak house". One was way too rare (and we like our steaks medium rare) and two were lukewarm at best. For $65 a steak I expected things to be much, much better. There are way too many other great options on Nantucket to have to put up with sub par food. Maybe that's why we got a reservation just two days ahead of time.
I do have to say that the sommelier/manager did the right thing. I told her that they needed to do something on the bill and she rightly took the most expensive steak off the bill (we still spent over $400). She had heard about our food and was mortified. She didn't push back when I asked for some kind of credit.
I couldn't recommend this place to any one looking for a good meal on Nantucket.
The food was fabulous and the service wa ...
The food was fabulous and the service was fantastic - everyone was very attentive. We sat outside by the bar and enjoyed the music played by the bartender - not too loud which was awesome. The wine list was very nice but would have been better if it had more moderate priced options. Although the food was deliious - the sides were ala carte. If I am buying a $49.00 piece of steak - it would have been nice if sides were included. The experience was good, outsiding dining fabulous but a bit pricey.
This place was dead in terms of diners. ...
This place was dead in terms of diners. We were the only ones seated inside on a Sunday night. Place was boring, overpriced, and slow. Perhaps would've been a different experience if we had been seated outside, which we requested but were told our request could not be accommodated. Would not return or recommend given the other options available in the area.
We've been coming to Nantucket for over ...
We've been coming to Nantucket for over 20 years, we've got our favorites. The Summer House has long been on the top of the list, it's now off the list. Prime is a MUST GO restaurant, we will never visit without at least one dinner at Prime. By far the best steak on Island.
Service was unfriendly. Hostess tried to ...
Service was unfriendly. Hostess tried to put us inside when reservation acknowledged outside only. Steak under cooked; raw, not medium rare. Sent it back and it came out the same. No steak knife. No salt and pepper. Shouldn't have to ask for these items.I could go on but you get the idea.
Nantucket Prime did not disappoint. We ...
Nantucket Prime did not disappoint. We come at least once a season to have their tomahawk steak which was cooked to perfection. The couple at the table next to us had the same. We paired it with bearnaise and bordelaise sauces as well as the best carrots I have ever tasted (fresh from Moor's End farm). My wife had the Daou Cabernet which she raved about. It was a gorgeous, cool night and we sat on the terrace. The service was friendly and the manager was very attentive. Only good things to say. Will definitely be back
Overall very disappointed. We booked t ...
Overall very disappointed. We booked through Open Table and that means you are inside. At best it is a small ballroom from the 1950's with little or no character. Service was great. Calm chowder very bland and the pear salad had maybe a quarter of a peer. My husband loved his tuna and the steaks got mixed reviews from the kids. Definitely a miss.
We were reluctantly seated inside - havi ...
We were reluctantly seated inside - having thot we reserved outside. Inside is newly renovated but not well spaced or lit. A bit cavernous. Our food and service made up for it. I had scallops that were four large Scallops alone on the plate. They should have used a smaller plate but the quality was outstanding. My wife had a hamachi crudo on a house salad. Fresh and tasty. Our waitress was on top of everything. Great ipa from the bar and pinot grigio. Over all nice
The food was alright.. The guacamole was ...
The food was alright.. The guacamole was pretty bland. Oysters were local and delicious. I split a fish which was a mistake because serving sizes were very very small.. Otherwise our waitress was very helpful and sweet and the atmosphere is great!
FOOD WAS GOOD BUT THE KITCHEN DIDNT GET ...
FOOD WAS GOOD BUT THE KITCHEN DIDNT GET THE FOOD OUT IN TIMELY FASHION. OUR BAKED POTATO CAME OUT AFTER WE FINISHED OUR MEAL.. WHO WANTS TO EAT A BAKED POTATO FOR DESSERT. YOU ONLY HAD 3 TABLES DINING INDOOR. OUTSIDE PATIO WAS BUSY.
PORTIONS COULD BE SLIGHTLY LARGER. I ALSO THINK YOU SHOULD ADD OTHER OPTIONS FOR CATEGORY RECOMMENDATIONS.. NONE OF THE ABOVE MATCHED MY DINNER ATMOSPHERE.
SIDE NOTE. THE COUPLE SITTING IN THE NEXT BOOTH EXPERIENCED THE SAME PROBLEM OF FOOD NOT MAKING IT TO THE TABLE IN A TIMELY FASHION...THANK YOU
I don't know why I don't go here more of ...
I don't know why I don't go here more often. The outdoor seating is really fantastic and the food is solid. Wait staff did a nice job. They have outdoor televisions which were playing a Red Sox Yankees game which was great to be able to check in on once in a while.
A nice steak but that's it!
While we thought the quality of the steak and the preparation was great, we were disappointed with our overall experience. When dining in Nantucket you expect that there will be a substantial mark-up for location and quality. However, you also expect remarkable service, extras and a unique experience. This did not happen. We felt that we were charged and even over-charged for each morsel. Perhaps for this restaurant to compete and sustain in Nantucket, they should make clients feel that they are pampered. We had a wonderful and similar meal at The White Barn in Kennebunk, ME and it was a total dining experience. At Nantucket Prime we had only a well cooked steak.
Great dinner. We sat outdoors on a cool ...
Great dinner. We sat outdoors on a cool September night but the heaters made it just right. Great food and service. We have children with food allergies and we always appreciate it when people handle that well for us. Everything wax great.
My fiancé and I had dinner here to celebrate getting engaged earlier in the day. It was perfect - small and cozy, romantic and just absolutely lovely. The service was excellent, our bottle of champagne stayed chilled and our glasses were never empty. The server was extremely polite and friendly - providing a complimentary dessert at the end of our meal which was amazing. My fiancé had the 24 ounce porterhouse and I had the 9 ounce filet. Both were cooked to perfection. We had mashed potatoes and the corn risotto side dishes; potatoes were very good but I didn't really care for the corn dish. I would recommend this to anyone who enjoys a fine meal on the island and look forward to returning !
First time -- Not the last
Everything a meal on Nantucket should be: A warm summer night, with a full moon... Terrific food... Attentive, friendly service (including our genial host)... Great atmosphere. Smoked bluefish pate, NY strip, swordfish, and spinach side were perfectly prepared and seasoned. Lemon curd dessert was fresh and fabulous. We'll be back!
Our dinner at Prime was delicious. The s ...
Our dinner at Prime was delicious. The service could not have been better. We were told upon arrival that "open table" reservations were for inside dining and on a beautiful night on Nantucket, when the rest of the island was outdoors enjoying mid-July beautiful weather, we sat alone in the dining room. It would have been nice to have some kind of special "touch" for our very expensive steak and potato dinner. ( greetings from the Chef or owner, perhaps a special complimentary roll?) They have the function down but need work on the "value added."
Been here several times. Do not like the ...
Been here several times. Do not like the indoor section of this restaurant. Very bland and stuffy. Outside is the place to sit but it seems to be turning more towards a bar crowd than the dinner crowd. Food is very good. Service is spotty. Our waitress was overwhelmed and undertrained. Probably won't return. Too many better choices.
Please sign in to record your input. Thanks!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.