About Mastro's City Hall Steakhouse
Mastro's collection of sophisticated, classic Steakhouses and Ocean Club seafood locations are recognized for their combination of world-class service, highly acclaimed cuisine, and live entertainment in an elegant yet energetic atmosphere. A truly unparalleled dining experience.
Hours of Operation:
Dinner: Sunday - Thursday: 5:00pm - 10:00pm, Friday - Saturday: 5:00pm - 11:00pm
$50 and over
AMEX, Diners Club, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
Live entertainment & dancing nightly at the piano bar.
Banquet, Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Counter Seating, Dancing, Entertainment, Fireplace, Full Bar, Late Night, Outdoor dining, Private Room, Wheelchair Access, Wine
Special Events & Promotions:
Please contact Suzi Ayers for your next event.
Send a Gift Card
Buy now and send it instantly by email, or print a card to give in person.
Mastro's City Hall Steakhouse combines atmosphere, comfort and elegance for the perfect setting for your next corporate, social or charitable event. Our private dining rooms offer the perfect setting for every type of event for groups of 10 to 500 guests. It's an unforgettable experience!
Mastro's City Hall Steakhouse Ratings and Reviews
Food was amazing as always. Server was ...
Food was amazing as always. Server was subpar. Wanted a desert/after dinner drink to go with desert but by the time our waitress came back our desert was done. Very inattentive during the whole meal and it was not very busy so she did not have many tables.
We went to this restaurant for Thanksgiv ...
We went to this restaurant for Thanksgiving dinner and it was lovely. The food was cooked perfectly and our waiter was very friendly and informative about the menu choices. We would definitely go back again for that warm butter cake!
Husbands birthday celebration, looking f ...
Husbands birthday celebration, looking for great steak place with good appetizers and ambience for family and friends. Prisoner 2015 Zin blend, so rich and smooth was to die for. The appetizers, including sweet shrimp, perfect scallops, tartar, amazing oysters (west and east) were so good we were all raving. The 6 oz filet MR and lobster tail were also amazing - never a better l-tail, and I've had a few. Service, despite a slightly slow start was attentive. The take away: highly recommended, no reservations (you WILL need reservations)
We have been at City Hall Steakhouse sev ...
We have been at City Hall Steakhouse several times before and have always had great meals. This visit was no exception. The food was excellent. However we did have a couple of issues on this visit that we hadn't seen in our past visits. 1) my sister-in-law ordered the veal chop cooked medium and she received it very rare and had to send it back. (which effected everyone else since all meals were served together) 2) My wife asked for Béarnaise sauce and never received any. That was a little disappointing for a meal that cost over $350 for three people!! But the food was fantastic once everything was fixed.
My husband and I love Mastro's whether i ...
My husband and I love Mastro's whether it be for date night, birthdays, or anniversaries. From the moment you walk in you feel welcome. Great service, food, and ambience. You can't go wrong with choosing Mastro's and you will not be sorry you did.
Our servers were excellent, Darren and J ...
Our servers were excellent, Darren and Juan were on point all evening long. The food was wonderful. My only suggestion is I order my steaks medium rare and was influenced to consider ordering between med and med rare, I wish I would have kept my original temp request. Filet was still delicious but I think might have been even better a little less cooked.
Go wary - the place gets hopping after 7 ...
Go wary - the place gets hopping after 7:00 pm. Valet parking saved the day - small, crowded parking lot on busy intersection. Steaks were excellent, Lobster Smashed potatoes, beyond. Follow up phone day later was unexpected but appreciated.
It was my birthday and a special friend, ...
It was my birthday and a special friend, who I had seen in over 4 years, came into town and we thought this would be a great place for an intimate celebration for 2. While the setting was nice, the table was too big. The place was extremely loud, much too intense and in chaos. Very Oppressing. The energy was too intense. I couldn't hear the wait. I couldn't hear my companion across the table. We were right in the servers' pathway, as well as pathway to the restroom. Our table and my chair was constantly bumped. A couple of customers stood for a longtime blocking the pathway and engaged in intense conversation, standing directly behind me trying to talk over the noise. Overall, I would say this was a terrible horrible experience, especially for the extreme cost of the dinner.
Excellent food and service. A bit pricey ...
Excellent food and service. A bit pricey even for the quality given the vast other options available in the downtown Scottsdale area. Not a great value, but a nice location and food is very tasty. The house specialty butter cake for dessert is worth the trip by itself. We also enjoyed the lamb rack cooked to perfection and the king crab, truffle gnocchi is another must try...
The steak was prepared to the perfect te ...
The steak was prepared to the perfect temperature. For those who ike Carpaccio, the portions were very generous and enough to share btwn 2. The star of the night was the Warm butter cake for dessert. Areal experience that must e tried when you go.
We had an unfortunate experience for a r ...
We had an unfortunate experience for a restaurant that had a good reputation prior to being bought out. We are gluten free and we were pleased to know they had a GF specific menu. We ordered French Onion Soup and a petite filet and a bone in filet. We were told the dry rub is not GF, so the steaks will come plain. We asked if there were other sauces and was offered Worcestershire or A-1. Who would put those sauces prime beef??
When the soup came out, it had croutons in it. I asked if it was GF and they took it back. After a back and forth, it was determined that the soup was not GF and they were sorry it was on the menu with the excuse that they forgot to remove it when they changed the recipe. So no appetizer. When the steaks came they were so bland, we had to use A-1. My wife's steak was like a filet, tender but mine was not. I asked why the dry rub was not GF and was told when they switched from Mastro's to Landrey's, the Landrey's rub is not GF. I asked why couldn't they just put some garlic butter or something on the steak to give it some taste, they just shrugged.
I will say they did comp my wife's steak and were apologetic. They said they would put our GF requirements in our record for future visits??? Despite those nice gestures, I don't think the quality of Mastro's is what it was and certainly not worth the price of those cuts of meat. My puppy did enjoy the bone in filet tho!! Steak 44, owned by former Mastro's folks is the best steak house in AZ..
I LOVED everything about Mastro's...exce ...
I LOVED everything about Mastro's...except the portions. At fine dining experiences I have had before, the food is exquisite while the servings are "civilized". While Mastro's food was wonderful, I could have fed a family of 4 on the vegetable dishes and 6 on the lobster bisque serving (which was OUT of THIS WORLD!!!) Yes, I took the left-overs home and have had 3 different meals with leftovers (still) for at least 1 more meal.
Great place to have dinner! My wife and ...
Great place to have dinner! My wife and I have been into Mastros a few times now and I am always amazed by the wait staff. The meal is always amazing and there discounts for military is unheard of. I will always suggest Mastros to anyone looking for an amazing meal and a luxurious atmosphere.
We were very disappointed. We were celeb ...
We were very disappointed. We were celebrating my wife's birthday so we came to our favorite special occasion restaurant. We were seated in the back room which is usually quiet. This night we were surrounded by three large groups of men celebrating. the noise was outrageous , the service not up to the usual level and the doors were closed. We felt we were being held captive and punished.
There is really NO reason not to have th ...
There is really NO reason not to have the Tomahawk cut available at 7pm on a weekend evening. There are many steakhouses in the Valley with the same menu items, but what sets apart your menu is the Tomahawk. We were extremely disappointed not to have this.
We celebrated my husband's birthday at C ...
We celebrated my husband's birthday at City Hall, joined by our two young adult sons. We were greeted warmly and our special occasion was noted. Service was well paced, warm, friendly, helpful -- the service was really spot on. The food is very good and cooked exactly to order. My son and I split a large steak and this was done without fuss, plated separately in the kitchen. I had noted on the reservation that my husband was particularly looking forward to their butter cake -- they brought it as a complimentary dessert with a candle. What a lovely touch.
Dinner for 4 with 2 glasses of wine (1 split entree) was $375, not a great value but pretty comparable yo other high end steak restaurants in town.
My only complaint is that the dining room is so dark you can't read the menu. Other tables also had their phone lights out to read, so it's not just our eyes! I find that so ridiculous. Otherwise, it was a perfect birthday dinner for my steak-and-butter-cake husband.
The drinks were fantastic, wait staff wa ...
The drinks were fantastic, wait staff was very attentive and knowledgeable. The steaks lacked flavor, and tasted like they hadn't been seasoned at all. We also got the scalloped potatoes, Mac and Cheese, and grilled asparagus, and all of the sides were extremely greasy. The sea scallop appetizer was delicious. For a $300 tab, I certainly expected the food to be some of the best I've ever tasted.
Lange Wartezeit trotz Reservierung. Gute ...
Lange Wartezeit trotz Reservierung. Guter, persönlicher Service, allerdings viel zu viele Empfehlungen. Gute Vorspeisen, Hauptgang lieblos angerichtet, aber lecker, insgesamt für die Leistung ein sehr hoher Preis...
Th service was horrible. Plates never c ...
Th service was horrible. Plates never cleared, beverages never filled, cake for "Tonia" brought to our table 3 times (we did not have a Tonia in our party). As soon as the staff realized what was happening they avoided us altogether. We have always had wonderful service at Mastros. It will be a tough decision if we go back in the future.
We are regulars that appreciate this pla ...
We are regulars that appreciate this place. Until our last visit. Steaks were just ok. Service was good. They hire young kids as bussers, however they are not trained properly. Also profile cards they use to impress their regular clientele needs an updating. Things change.so should City Hall.
Please sign in to record your input. Thanks!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.