About Mahogany Prime Steakhouse - Tulsa
Authentic American cooking including corn-fed prime beef, fresh seafood flown in daily, and "Everything made from scratch".
Steak, Seafood, Steakhouse
Hours of Operation:
Monday - Thursday: 5pm to 10pm
Friday & Saturday : 5pm to 11pm
Sunday: 5pm to 9pm
E 68th Street S
$31 to $50
AMEX, Diners Club, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
Private Party Facilities:
Please call for details.
Private Party Contact:
Banquet, Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Full Bar, Non-Smoking, Private Room, Takeout, Wheelchair Access, Wine
Mahogany Prime Steakhouse - Tulsa Ratings and Reviews
The meal this time was not as good as us ...
The meal this time was not as good as usual. One of us ordered the Bison steak that was recommended and while it's taste was OK, the cut was about 30% sinew and inedible. The Ribeye was excellent as were the sides and the suggested wine.
The other thing I would suggest, and will request next time, is less people attacking the table. We had two servers, a lady that came by to refill the water as soon as you took a drink and the manager stopping by to see how the everything was. That is to many people and interruptions. Once the water glass hits 50% refill it, leave it alone until then. My colleague was trained in an upscale restaurant in Germany and knows the restaurant industry and these are some of his observations.
We eat at Mahogany's every time he comes to town and he has mentioned the interruptions from the team waiting approach each time.
We will continue to patronize Mahogany's in the future but I wanted to pass this input along.
Our server was Taylor, she was a delight and did a great job.
I was very impressed when we walked in t ...
I was very impressed when we walked in the door. Service was superb, food was cooked to perfection. Both my husband and I had steak medium rare and was cooked exactly the way we love steak. My husband told them we were celebrating my birthday so my desert was served with a candle and also received a small gift box of truffles from Mahogany Prime Steakhouse. All in all it was a wonderful evening.
Restaurant was beautiful and staff was v ...
Restaurant was beautiful and staff was very friendly/proffesional. It was my first time going to a high end restaurant and the food was definately worth the price. I had an outstanding off-menu Bison Fillet with saute'ed Greenbean, my girlfriend had some calamari to start which comes with an amazing sweet and spicy sauce, then a ceasar salad, followed by a new york strip and a loaded baked potato, we both thoroughly enjoyed our food and will be going back ion March for more.
Great steak, crab was amazing. Lobster w ...
Great steak, crab was amazing. Lobster was overdone both times. However they didn't complain about having to replace it and I wasn't going to complain twice about the over cooked lobster. I won't order the lobster again though.
The sides were sides. They had to be ordered in addition to the main entree. Portion size was good. Nothing spectacular or notable.
The servers where on par with other formal steak houses. Great service, but a little stuffy. I wish they were able to show more of their own style and personality.
If you're from The Midwest this beef is on par with quality Nebraska beef. Corn fed and finished, wet aged, and trimmed properly. They sear the steak properly, but I prefer mine to have been rested a little longer.
Overall, I thought it was a poor value for the high price. The restaurant inside was showing wear. Not quite as nice or high end as the price would warrant.
I never new this place existed. Wished ...
I never new this place existed. Wished is was a little closer to where we lived. We were celebrating our anniversary so we were looking for a nice place to go and this met our expectations. It was fairly quite, very good service and our meal was great. We will return.
I eat out at nice restaurants 5-5 nights ...
I eat out at nice restaurants 5-5 nights a week as a traveling business man. Tonight's dinner at Mahogany was by far one of the most pleasant experienced I've had in a long time! From the minute I walked in the door until I left was an absolute delight! The service was professional, the food excellent, and the ambiance was lovely. I. Ant wait to dine there again!
The filet and creamed spinich were very ...
The filet and creamed spinich were very good. For the price, I felt like the ribeye wasn't as tender as I had hoped. Steaks were cooked correctly and service was excellent. It's just pretty pricey so no room for error on the steaks.
One of Tulsa's finest restaurants. Menu ...
One of Tulsa's finest restaurants. Menu is not long but excellent choices available. Ala carte sides are family-style (enough for 3) and delicious. Adequate but nice choice of wines and cocktails. At least two servers per table, but they don't tag-team you and constantly bother. Reservations most advisable. Do expect to pay for this level of service and quality of food. Tip: If you’re hosting friends, you can get menus without prices; ask for them when making reservations.
Excellent. While there are other local r ...
Excellent. While there are other local restaurants with a higher per plate cost, don't let price be an indicator of quality. Mahogany has the most excellent steaks in the area, with the most attentive and friendly staff. The staff and management will go to great lengths to accommodate any request you may have.
This is the first time that we have been ...
This is the first time that we have been disappointed with our experience. Our server seemed disinterested to be there, never smiled and barely found time to check on us. Our table was in a crowded room. It was our anniversary, we left feeling dissatisfied with our visit. The only shining moment was the food, excellent as always!
This was our first visit to Mahogany and ...
This was our first visit to Mahogany and by far it is the best place in Tulsa for steak. The service was great, the food was the best we have had in Tulsa. Prices are perfect for the quality of food. We will be back for sure.
Our favorite place for something special ...
Our favorite place for something special. Very expensive. Plan on $100 per person. Crab cakes are awesome. Steak was perfection. Service fabulous. Key lime pie was unique and yummy! Pink diamond cocktails are a must.
The food and atmosphere is fabulous! We ...
The food and atmosphere is fabulous! We love Mahogany's and our waitress was fantastic. Her name was Erma and she made the best recommendations (we basically took all of them), the food was amazing. From the first cocktail to the dessert we thoroughly enjoyed ourselves. We will be back!
We dined here for our first anniversary ...
We dined here for our first anniversary and were treated to a wonderful evening. The food was outstanding, the service was outstanding, and the chocolate cake was worth the trip alone. Numerous staff members offered their congratulations to us, and when we arrived, there was a card on our table saying "Happy Aniversary", as well as a box of truffles. Mahogany's has been the best fine-dining experience I've had in Tulsa
Please sign in to record your input. Thanks!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.