About Maggiano's - Milwaukee
Welcome to Maggiano’s first restaurant in Wisconsin! We are located at 2500 N. Mayfair Road, at Mayfair Mall in Wauwatosa (just outside of Milwaukee). Our 250-seat dining room is ideal for group meals, festive gatherings and romantic lunches or dinners for two.
Maggiano’s specializes in serving lavish portions of authentic Italian-American cuisine served family style. Our menu is large and varied, offering a great selection of homemade pastas, signature salads, prime steaks, fresh fish & memorable desserts.
Come visit us and allow Maggiano's the opportunity to serve you some of the best Italian-American food you have ever tasted.
Hours of Operation:
Lunch: Daily: 11:15am - 3:00pm
Dinner: Monday - Thursday: 3:00pm - 9:00pm, Friday - Saturday: 3:00pm - 10:00pm, Sunday: 3:00pm - 9:00pm
$30 and under
AMEX, Carte Blanche, Diners Club, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
Maggiano's delivers! Just place your order, and we'll take care of the rest. All delivery orders include: table coverings, plates & utensils, a complete setup to keep the food warm throughout your event, party-sized pans providing generous portions for all of your guests. Please call 414-978-1010 to schedule your delivery. Orders must be placed by 7 p.m. for next-day delivery. Minimum order required. Delivery fee applies.
Banquet/Private Rooms, Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Delivery, Full Bar, Non-Smoking Restaurant, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Private Room, Takeout, Wheelchair Access, Wine
Give your guests a reason to celebrate. Whether you’re hosting a business meeting, holiday party, wedding event or birthday celebration, our expert team will ensure it’s executed flawlessly. Host your event in one of our rich, beautifully appointed banquet rooms and enjoy a fresh-made Italian feast.
Maggiano's - Milwaukee Ratings and Reviews
My first time for my birthday and we rea ...
My first time for my birthday and we really enjoyed it.
graduation & birthday dinner
Dinner for grandson's 8th grade graduation and his mother's (our daughter's) birthday. Pleasantly surprised by lack of large crowd early Sunday evening, thus we were able to eat outside. Graduation weekend for at least two local universities, but only one college graduation dinner outside. They were a bit noisy, but that was to be expected given the reason for their dinner. Salads and entrees fine. Enjoyable meal.
We had a graduate party and everything w ...
We had a graduate party and everything was excellent. Everyone left more than satisfied and some with another complete meal. The service was excellent and the chef took care of those with food allergies. Thank you so much! This is our place to eat!
we had a great waitress and the food was ...
we had a great waitress and the food was wonderful. I love the rigatoni D and it was perfect. My Mom ate her whole bowl of spaghetti with meat sauce. We got the Marco meal for 2 so we had an appetizer and dessert--calamari (yum) and tiramisu (my fave). the whole meal at the restaurant was very good. My only complaint is the pasta we got to take home. My Mom got the baked zitti and it transported well. I got the lower calorie alfredo. It looked like it was just thrown together with giant chunks of chicken, the wrong type of pasta (papardelle noodles) asparagus but virtually no sauce. it was like paste when i got home. Kind of a bummer when the whole rest of the meal was awesome. I will definitely go back again but i would not order that dish again.
Always love coming here...mozzarella mar ...
Always love coming here...mozzarella marinara is to die for. Lobster carbonara and Chef Mann's country pasta were quite tasty this time around!
Maggiano's always lives up to expectatio ...
Maggiano's always lives up to expectations. I ordered from the special menu to raise money for Make A Wish Foundation as I do every spring. The peach-pomegranate lemonade was very delicious (free refills) and the filet mignon rosotto/asparagus entrée was very good also. At $24.95 the entrée included a take-home selection from the regular eat-in and take one home menu.
Great food! The salmon was a bit salty, ...
Great food! The salmon was a bit salty, but the rest of the entrees were superb!
Delicious as always!
Maggiano's is a really nice place to catch up with friends. We had a booth thanks to Open Table, and our waitress was really nice about our requests for extra bread. The food was delicious as always and we all enjoyed the charity drinks!
One of my favorite places in the Brookfi ...
One of my favorite places in the Brookfield/Wauwatosa areas to go for dinner with friends and/or family in town. Love the menu options, something for everyone. Food is always great, have never been disappointed with the service or quality of food. Noise levels usually very low and manageable, easy place to have a conversation with friends.
Great value for all food! Waitress and ...
Great value for all food! Waitress and service were excellent!!! Disappointed in the Italian side salad; only 2 onions which were cut too thick and croutons were soggy because the salad had sat in the refer and was not prepared specific to our meal. Rest of our food was fantastic. The lighter side meal for chicken Marsala was excellent. A very pleasant surprise! Will we go back, absolutely! Hope they correct a soggy salad!
genuinely discussed with the service received
I was prepared for an additional wait time due to mother's day. But the lack of services was unforgivable from start to finish. We had reservations for 6:45 and was not seated until 7:20. My family of 6 was placed at a table for 4-5 guest, leaving no room on the table for our food to sit or for anyone to eat comfortably. The food and drinks took an extended amount of time to come out, and the waitress came around once in 2 hours to fill cups. On three occasions I had to request service from other individuals working other tables around me. When I became fed up with the service and asked to have fresh plates boxed, she simply placed 3 boxes on the table and left. For a family of 6, only 4 desserts were brought out, two guests did not have any. I was so upset with this lack of service that I choose not to leave a tip for a $265 bill. Up until this visit, I have always received excellent service and food at Maggiano's, It will be a very long time if ever I return because of this. The strange thing is that a manager came to our table, but he did not bother to ask us any questions or offer an apology.
Great overall experience.
Food including the appetizer was excellent. Will definitely go back again to try other dishes. The restaurant was recommended by others and did not disappoint. Overall great experience with the wait staff and the bartender. You will not leave hungry. A little higher priced that most restaurant of this type but still a good experience.
Met all my expectations and more
Went here for mothers day. Amazing food, fantastic food..... Got to eat a meal there and take one home. Love the old school table cloths and big Italian booths.
Good food and a good value
We went to Maggiano's for Mother's Day. We were seated at our table at our reservation time, which I thought was fantastic given how busy they were. The service was good. For a chain restaurant, the food was very tasty and a good value. We had three chicken dishes and one pasta dish at the table and all were yummy. Don't skip dessert either. The apple crostada is scrumptious. This wasn't the first time I was there and it won't be the last.
Terrific Mother's Day lunch! And a very ...
Terrific Mother's Day lunch! And a very good deal: brought home a lot of leftovers!
Food was great. Service very good
Food was great. Service very good
Good Italian Restaurant
We find Magianno's to be a good Italian restaurant. Food is better than average but the restaurant is quite loud.
Excellent Food & Waitstaff
Have eaten here many times, we have relatives that travel 2 hours for the experience, our waiter Dino was just fantastic, one of the best I have ever experienced
I love it hereit's mine and my boyfriend's "place"
They forgot to pack our dessert though. :( We always get the two-for special which includes appetizer, 2 meals,2 take home meals and dessert. It was a bummer to get home and not have a slice of cheesecake to share as usual.
Great food but way too crowded
The service was great and so was the food but the owners should seriously reconsider the amount of tables that are crammed into the main dining area. It is unacceptable, not to mention unsafe (think fire safety), that as a guest in your restaurant I get bumped into multiple times during my meal by staff and customers trying to walk to and from tables.
Our recent dinner at Maggiano's was simply excellent. We hope to be back soon!
Best restaurant in a very, long time!
This was my first visit to Maggiano's. All was wonderful! Great food, perfect service, comfortable and welcoming environment, and even a meal to take home for tomorrow, all included in the price of my dinner! I highly recommend Maggiano's, and I will definitely visit again and again.
Worth the time...
Many times a restaurant is judged on food and service - but sometimes, you need to see if it is worth your time. Maggianos at Mayfair is worth it. From the friendly host/hostess, to the good natured and attentive wait staff, you are constantly being reminded that you are important and a valued customer. It doesn't hurt that the food is incredible as well. The menu, though standard Italian cuisine, is peppered with options and regularly runs specials to entice the diner who wants something different. The pricing is not too high or too low. Many restaurants give you a huge plate of food and you have to take half home. Maggianos gives you a regular size serving and then you can get a totally different item to take home. For a larger family or a group, you can try multiple items in 2 days. The vegetarian items are wonderful and more than one choice on the menu. Register on line and you get coupons... more savings! My only suggestion... for the take home items, put a sticker on the container with the reheating instructions. It's only a few paragraphs and that would make it easier, especially when you don't want to look things up. SO GO GO GO to Maggiano's at Mayfair. You will not be disappointed.
The service was top notch. They even spr ...
The service was top notch. They even sprinkled stars all over the table as we were celebrating two birthdays. We all had a very good time. I would order my dish again.
Not my first time here. I love this restaurant.
I like to go to a nice restaurant and relax . I don't want to sound heartless but the waiter was soliciting for Make a Wish. I found it somewhat annoying. I believe in these causes, but I don't expect to be cornered while trying to dine and enjoying the company of a friend.
The tables are so close, you can hardly hear your party talking. Your crammed in like a can of sardines.
Great place to eat and hang out with friends.
We made a reservation and they took us in right , the service was outstanding, the was excellent, was nice and welcoming. As usual we and back again soon.
The food was excellent and portions were ...
The food was excellent and portions were large. We left very satisfied, and with take home portions for the next day. We'll definitely be back.
Great Food, Great Service
Excellent Italian Cuisine, great service. We were in a hurry and they got us in and out in jig time. Moderately priced. We stop in every time we go to Milwaukee!
The food was good and plentiful. The Lin ...
The food was good and plentiful. The Linguine di Mere was great. The manager had great hospitality. Everyone was helpful and nice.
Good, not great
My husband and I recently treated some of his colleagues to dinner on a Wednesday evening. The ambiance was nice and the noise level was acceptable. Our server was prompt, but lacked personality. She got the order correct, but appeared very robotic throughout the meal. The appetizers and salads were good, but salads were a little heavy on the lettuce, rather than the tasty toppings. The entrees were all served hot and fresh to our liking. We all ordered something different, so we all got to try a little bit of everything. Our Two of our meals came with a bonus "take home" pasta. Those entrees were less than desirable. We ended up pitching both of them. The quality was nowhere near what we experienced when we dined in the restaurant. My vegetable primavera was topped with uncooked, unseasoned vegetables! Overall, we were pleased with the experience and the price point. However, we are unlikely to order any of the entrees that include an additional entree in the future.
Each time my husband and I visit, we are ...
Each time my husband and I visit, we are satisfied with the whole experience. What a wonderful place to visit either casual or for a special occasion.
The location was central to our evenings activities . The selections offered were excellent. The quality and quantity of the meal was over the top. Looking forward to returning soon.
Perfect spot for an occasion
I love it here the staff is amazing and they reward customers with free apps for bringing new people in! Always a fun experience plus amazing food and wine!
a little bit off on this night
We have had many, many great meals at this location but tonight was a little off. Our service was mixed up. Entrees came before our salads, server was very busy and we didn't see her much. Chef brought our salads after we told a runner who delivered our entrees that we hadn't received them. It took a while for our wine to show up. Just unfortunate. We will be back because one bad night won't detour us. We really do enjoy this Maggiano's.
They need to not bring the dinner when we are still eating salads. This is a constant issue with them. Then they say they will bring the dinners back, but guess what they are COLD, they just let them sit and then just bring them back. Tired of the same issue every time, but it is a constant issue. Their policy is to get them in, quick feed them, then get them out. Not acceptable way to treat customers
Poor service, incorrect food orders, che ...
Poor service, incorrect food orders, check was wrong not an enjoyable experience
We've dined at Maggianos many times, and ...
We've dined at Maggianos many times, and love the take One dinner home offer. We requested a booth and didn't Get one even though there were many available, which Was disappointing . We also had one of the wrong take home dinners, than was ordered, which we noticed when we got home.
Wonderful Italian Food
We have dined at Maggiano's on a number of occasions. The quality of the food and service never disappoints. I still find it a bit noisy to consider it a romantic restaurant. A lot of the noise is because of how busy the restaurant always is.
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.