About Maggiano's - Milwaukee
Welcome to Maggiano’s first restaurant in Wisconsin! We are located at 2500 N. Mayfair Road, at Mayfair Mall in Wauwatosa (just outside of Milwaukee). Our 250-seat dining room is ideal for group meals, festive gatherings and romantic lunches or dinners for two.
Maggiano’s specializes in serving lavish portions of authentic Italian-American cuisine served family style. Our menu is large and varied, offering a great selection of homemade pastas, signature salads, prime steaks, fresh fish & memorable desserts.
Come visit us and allow Maggiano's the opportunity to serve you some of the best Italian-American food you have ever tasted.
Hours of Operation:
Lunch: Daily: 11:15am - 3:00pm
Dinner: Monday - Thursday: 3:00pm - 9:00pm, Friday - Saturday: 3:00pm - 10:00pm, Sunday: 3:00pm - 9:00pm
$30 and under
AMEX, Carte Blanche, Diners Club, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
Maggiano's delivers! Just place your order, and we'll take care of the rest. All delivery orders include: table coverings, plates & utensils, a complete setup to keep the food warm throughout your event, party-sized pans providing generous portions for all of your guests. Please call 414-978-1010 to schedule your delivery. Orders must be placed by 7 p.m. for next-day delivery. Minimum order required. Delivery fee applies.
Banquet, Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Delivery, Full Bar, Non-Smoking, Outdoor dining, Private Room, Takeout, Wheelchair Access, Wine
Give your guests a reason to celebrate. Whether you’re hosting a business meeting, holiday party, wedding event or birthday celebration, our expert team will ensure it’s executed flawlessly. Host your event in one of our rich, beautifully appointed banquet rooms and enjoy a fresh-made Italian feast.
Maggiano's - Milwaukee Ratings and Reviews
We have been going to Maggianos, both in ...
We have been going to Maggianos, both in Milwaukee and other states, for years. We have not visited for a few months now and noticed the difference in what we used to enjoy and how it is now. Portions are much smaller and prices are higher. I ordered the chicken Parmesan. Therewas possibly two tablespoons of pasta on my plate. Come on now. Pasta is inexpensive and certainly could have been a little more plentiful. The two chicken breasts were tiny. I am never able to finish my serving and always take part home. This is not the case any longer. For those not used to how it used to be, this probably is a acceptable but not in my case. $19 for an inexpensive dish with small portions. I can see this in a fine dining restaurant but don't consider this the case. To top it off, I found a foreign object in my food and asked the server to take it to the kitchen to find out what is was. She returned to tell me it was a piece if asparagus that found its way onto my plate. They didn't even remove it but returned my plate with this object still on it. Too many fine restaurants in Milwaukee to have to deal with this..
Service was very good. Making our reser ...
Service was very good. Making our reservation online was very easy. Although we really enjoyed our appetizer (zucchini), we were very disappointed with our fettuccine Alfredo as it didn't have much flavor and not very creamy. Weve also been disappointed with the Rigatoni D the last couple of times at different locations, so we thought we'd try something different. The Rigatoni D has also not had much flavor and sauce almost seemed watered down. It's a shame because we've loved going there for the ambiance.
Wonderful dining experience. Made rese ...
Wonderful dining experience. Made reservation online but called to change time with no issues. Arrived 15 minutes early and our group of 5 was seated immediately. We ordered a variety of the Classic Pastas, all were generous portions. I ordered the The lighter portion of Baked Ziti with chicken vs. sausage and it was excellent.
Third visit. Worst visit. Seated immedia ...
Third visit. Worst visit. Seated immediately, 10 minutes for water to come. 10 minutes for waitress to take order. Gave order, she came back immediately and said they were out of what we ordered. (6:30pm, already out ?).
Her meal had little to no sauce, mine......... I had to swim through the sauce to "find" my ravioli.
Order two glasses of house red wine. Waitress never gave "size" options. She gave us the $12.50 size. We were not aware there was a smaller glass.
The restaurant was not that busy, but service was slow. My best guess was they just were understaffed and our waitress had to work more tables than normal.
Once check was received, we complained about not being aware of a small glass of wine available. She grab the check and returned by dropping it on our table. She did remove the wine charge.
We look forward to visiting Maggiano's i ...
We look forward to visiting Maggiano's in Wauwatosa every Christmas season when we drive over from Madison to shop at the nearby Crate & Barrel and Container Store. Our experience at Maggiano's was everything we've come to expect: cozy seating, lush Christmas decorations, abundant quantities of delicious pasta, and excellent service from friendly staff.
We had an Open Table reservation but the ...
We had an Open Table reservation but they put us at an awkward table upstairs that sticks out into the aisle. Not sure why, as we were there early and other tables were available. The food is usually very good but this time it was not to my liking. However, the gluten-free dessert was to die for!! Our two waitresses were very nice and attentive.
We enjoyed the food, the restaurant has ...
We enjoyed the food, the restaurant has a good atmosphere and seating arrangement. The waitress was very friendly and took care of us very well. The food did not take that long to be served, we loved the extra food to go except mine was not as much as what husband's it looks Iike it was a left over this was the first time it happened to me.
I have always made an open table reservation but I don't receive points.
Felt very rushed with Thanksgiving, rese ...
Felt very rushed with Thanksgiving, reservation was for 6pm, didn't get seated until 6:15ish and were signing the bill by 7:15 even though we specifically asked for some time in between courses to actually digest, talk, enjoy the holiday. Were prompted to be making decisions on our order before we could even sit down it seemed and before our drink orders were even made... plus I have a feeling the server never would have even asked if I didn't go ahead and place my drink order as he asked about salad. Very hesitant to refilling a pasta dish when the whole meal is family style, stating at 7pm that the kitchen was closed and they were out of XYZ. Food was okay, by no means hot or some dishes even warm by the time they hit the table. Have had much better experiences with this restaurant on non-holidays, and much better experiences at other Maggiano locations on holidays.
Have had Thanksgiving dinner at Maggiano ...
Have had Thanksgiving dinner at Maggianos many times, was very disappointed this year. Never received full order of Bruschetta. Salads were great. Ziti lacked sauce and flavor....looked like save was labeled over pasta, not tossed. Gravy was cold and lacked flavor and color. Stuffing was horrible....was very wet like it was never baked. Dark meat turkey was tough and undercooked. Gnocchi was spot on as well as Rigatoni D. Desserts were great.
It had been several years since I had la ...
It had been several years since I had last been to Maggiano's and since that last time I was there, I would say that everything was just as good or improved. The food was excellent, spiced just right, service as fantastic, decorated very tastefully for the holidays. Overall a wonderful experience and I will not wait as long to return.
We had a most wonderful time. We were ex ...
We had a most wonderful time. We were extremely impressed when the chef visited our table with an appetizer welcoming us to our first time at Maggiano's VERY IMPRESSIVE!!! This is by far the best dining experience we have had in many months....we were still trying to recover from a miserable Buca Di Beppo/Greenfield, WI experience. Maggiano's Wauwatosa, WI is first class ALL THE WAY!! Thank you!!!!!
Maggiano's is traditionally a solid safe ...
Maggiano's is traditionally a solid safe restaurant for Italian food. Thry have added meat to all pastas that it used to be an up charge for. This just a scheme to jack up the bill for customers especially ones that don't want the meat and still are charged for it.
They added sausage to the gnocchi dish and have ruined it. They have changed the vodka sauce to a ragout type thing that is not as good as it used to be to accommodate the sausage profile.
Instead of jacking up prices because of the buy one get one deal, just go back to the basics of making good Chicago Italian food.
They seem to be driving this into olive garden territory.
Our visit was extremely worth the drive ...
Our visit was extremely worth the drive to get there. Food was excellent and Tina our waitress was fantastic. We had the dinner for two. Everything was wonderful. It was our 30th anniversary and we could not have asked for a better evening.
We made a reservation in advance since w ...
We made a reservation in advance since we had a large group of 11 for 6:30pm - the table was not ready and we waited in the bar. We had a guest who could not stand long and could not sit on a bar stool, so we asked again if our table was ready and needed to get a low chair for her to sit in the bar area . When we got to the table, I was disappointed because 11 were very crammed in - that would have been fine for a walk in group - but when you make a reservation a week in advance you should receive a table that is comfortable and maybe in less of a traffic walk through area (as it was right on a main aisle)
the restaurant was very crowded - as it was a Friday night.
I had also hoped we would do the family style ordering, but all the guests I was with thought the pricing was too expensive to do that - so I was disappointed by that.
We did however have great food and great service and they did bring a special treat for the two birthday folks - so overall a very good experience.
Never thought I would say this, but I wa ...
Never thought I would say this, but I was disappointed at how fast the food came! Clearly it was sitting somewhere, just waiting to be spooned onto a dish. The consistency of the meat reflected this - dry and hard. I miss the old Maggiano's when they first started and served high quality food. Now it is just a factory, cranking out average tasting food as fast as possible at a higher than average price. Now not much better than Chili's and Applebee's. Sorry, won't be going back.
We had a gift card and since we do not d ...
We had a gift card and since we do not drink, our entire bill was less than the gift card and we each had a meal to take home! First Date Nite for my husband and I in a very long time and it was very nice! Great food!
Made a reservation and mentioned we were ...
Made a reservation and mentioned we were celebrating a birthday. They gave my husband a card that staff had signed but at the end of the night they never brought him a birthday dessert. I was very disappointed for him.
While I loved most everything about are ...
While I loved most everything about are whole meal and are service was great. I have to say the pumpkin ravioli was a huge disappointment. There was barely anything in them and if I hadn't been told I would have never guessed there was even pumpkin in it. I love pumpkin which is why I ordered the seasonal pumpkin special but "where's the pumpkin?"
Please sign in to record your input. Thanks!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.