About Maggiano's - Indianapolis
Maggiano's Little Italy specializes in Italian-American cuisine served in a warm & friendly atmosphere. We are open daily for lunch & dinner, offer a convenient Carryout service as well as beautiful & accommodating Banquet space for every special occasion.
Maggiano’s menu features both classic & contemporary Italian-American recipes – homemade pastas, signature salads, prime steaks, fresh fish, regular chef specials & specialty desserts, accompanied by a large selection of wines & specialty drinks. The food is made from scratch daily & served in a welcoming environment. Family style service or individual entrees are available.
Hours of Operation:
Daily: 11:00am - 3:00pm
Monday - Thursday: 3:00pm - 10:00pm,
Friday - Saturday: 3:00pm - 11:00pm,
Sunday: 3:00pm - 9:00pm
Thanksgiving *Special Hours*: 12:00pm - 7:00pm
$30 and under
AMEX, Carte Blanche, Diners Club, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
Maggiano's delivers! Just place your order, and we'll take care of the rest. All delivery orders include: table coverings, plates & utensils, a complete setup to keep the food warm throughout your event, party-sized pans providing generous portions for all of your guests. Please call 317-814-0717 to schedule your delivery. Orders must be placed by 7 p.m. for next-day delivery. Minimum order required. Delivery fee applies.
Our Guests may use valet or park in the public lot.
Banquet/Private Rooms, Beer, Delivery, Full Bar, Private Room, Takeout, Wine
Give your guests a reason to celebrate. Whether you’re hosting a business meeting, holiday party, wedding event or birthday celebration, our expert team will ensure it’s executed flawlessly. Host your event in one of our rich, beautifully appointed banquet rooms and enjoy a fresh-made Italian feast.
Maggiano's - Indianapolis Ratings and Reviews
Generous portions of food. Service by o ...
Generous portions of food. Service by our waiter was very good. We had a party of nine, two of which were over 85 years old and a four year old and the staff was really pushing me to order off the family menu. The two 85 year olds would have eaten maybe $5 worth of the $32 price and the 4 year old had about 2 bite of mac and cheese. Family style just wouldn't worked for us but staff REALLY pushed it. Almost to the point of being uncomfortable.
The family style was pushed on us becaus ...
The family style was pushed on us because we were a group of nine (6 adults, 3 kids) and it's very expensive, $32.95 per adult and $16.95 per child. We had to ask for regular menus and kids' menus. Then, they only brought one regular menu for the 6 adults to look at. We ended up doing family style for the adults and ordering off the kids menu for the 3 kids. They didn't refill the dishes that got low, we had to ask. I don't feel that we got our money's worth. The price for family style is way too high.
As always, we had a wonderful dining exp ...
As always, we had a wonderful dining experience. Maggiano's is our go to restaurant for special occasions!
Maggiano's was as usual delicious , Peyt ...
Maggiano's was as usual delicious , Peyton was a great server :-) would have given all 5 stars but we sat in the large dining room which was too busy and noisy for us we normally set either in the bar or outside which we enjoy much more
Great Expectations Met
We selected Magianno's for a special wedding anniversary. The atmosphere was extremely nice. We were especially pleased and liked the "Dinner for Two" offering and we enjoyed all three courses. Our waitress was extremely attentive and met our expectations. I also appreciated their backing of The Make A Wish" organization and also donated to it. It was also very nice that the manager came by and thanked us for the donation. Overall a great experience and I have already shared the positive experience with friends.
food was very good. Waiter was excellent ...
food was very good. Waiter was excellent. It was our first time dining there, so we got extra attention. All the staff very helpful as we asked lots of questions.
Sam was an excellent waiter. He was quic ...
Sam was an excellent waiter. He was quick to serve any requests we had. Dinner for 2 was sumptuous. Our mushroom ravioli was delicious as was the salmon- prepared and presented beautifully. Always recommend reservations for the weekends.
We have been to Maggiano's many times, w ...
We have been to Maggiano's many times, we always have a good meal there! We even had our Anniversary Celebration there two years ago in their Party Room. The only complaint we have, is that we have always loved their Calamari, but for the money they charge, the portion isn't worth it, plus it is not near as good as it used to be either! We really miss having the Calamari that we were used to for over 17 years!
nice relaxing evening
food was fabulous.... once waiter determined our time table, no hurry, we had a relaxing evening; it was our servers first week and he did fabulous
We had a reservation for 6 p.m. on Frida ...
We had a reservation for 6 p.m. on Friday and we were seated promptly. Our server was very friendly and made several suggestions for menu items. Our food was good, and we had the bonus of two entrees to take home. Very good value for the money.
I love Maggiano's! I come every month to meet with old friends. The food is amazing and the portions are extremely generous. I find the service is always the same which is great. Our server was very attentive and I was very pleased.
Our guest has a severe food allergy, the chef went out of his way to not only make sure the food was safe, he even "specially" created a dish that is not on the menu, and it was delicious! We had a wonderful time!
Food, service and value were outstanding ...
Food, service and value were outstanding! Unfortunately, we were seated, had ordered, had our drinks and appetizer when a party of 8 was seated right next to us. From then on, our conversation was extremely difficult. There were numerous open tables and it would have been thoughtful to offer to live us because the group next to us was extremely loud. There were only 3 of us and we were so close to the table of 8 that our experience was definitely diminished because we couldn't converse and hear each other. Service from Sam was outstanding!
Magianno's never disappoints, your server can!
Consistently good food. Servers can add or detract from the experience however. We were sold a "pitcher" of Sangria which was barely large enough to serve all four of us AFTER the glasses were stuffed with ice. So come on Magianno's, we all know what a "pitcher" looks like. Either provide the correct quantity OR charge more! I didn't ask "how much" when she suggested a "pitcher". So yeah, that was less than ideal. But the meal was good.
Food was very good with large portions. ...
Food was very good with large portions. Only issue was the 10 minute wait fir the waiter to return with our credit card.
Just ordered the wrong thing--had never ...
Just ordered the wrong thing--had never tried the beef with noodles on the value menu. Little beef with a stroganoff type sauce was disappointing. I'm certain that the lasagna I took home will be yummy; it always is delicious. I would suggest a white sangria made with a sparkling wine rather than the moscato--not as sweet as the moscato, but more sweetness is not needed with the peach vodka, etc. Finally, my wife is gluten-free and would prefer a vegetable choice with the value menu rather than only the gluten-free penne.
Great experience, food and deals!! Too ...
Great experience, food and deals!! Too bad regular wait so very long thank goodness for opentable app. Will be back soon!
Love this place!
I'm never disappointed when I come here. Food is always fantastic and the staff is always friendly and attentive!
The waiter was horrible. He had to be p ...
The waiter was horrible. He had to be prompted for EVERYTHING from getting us silverware (who forgets the knife), to refilling the bread bowl. AND why was he so stingy with the butter patties?
Higher prices/ lower quantity of food
I've been a customer of Magguano's from the first week they opened in Indy and have been a steady customer ever since. It's still one of our go-to locations when we have an occasion to celebrate . Back in those beginning days, they served an obscene amount of food which they finally corrected with the advent of their "today and tomorrow" pastas. But we have noticed every time we visit recently it seems like there is less and less in both the "today" and especially "tomorrow" portions. The servings bowls that used to be filled almost to the rim are now at best 2/3 full or even half full sometimes. (The desserts are proportionally shrinking too) this wouldn't be quite as bad but they've recently instituted a price increase to go along with the decrease in food. Finally, I would really appreciate it if they would stop hiring as wait staff millennial guys who forget your order, take off for 15 minutes ( no doubt checking their phones), and are only attentive when it's time to pay your check. We seem to get one of these guys every.singke.time we go. (The food is still good.)
We received terrible service. Our waitress came by to take our order and we didn't see her until she took our dessert order. No drink refills. They didn't bring bread until we stopped two people to ask and it finally came out right before dessert. They messed up our to-go order and we didn't notice until we got home (an hour away). They had about 10 people standing around doing nothing but chatting in the back.
Maggianosis consistently good. The servers are friendly. The drinks are delicious. The seasonal sangria was fabulous.
Food was good, but I can park my own car
The food and wait service was good for this visit. I've been here many times in the past and always had a good time. This visit, they refused to allow people to park their own cars. Instead you must use the "complimentary" valet. They put cones in all the empty parking spaces and go so far as to yell and run out into the street to get you to use the valet. Don't get me wrong, the food is good and its a decent restaurant; but it is not fancy enough to be a valet parking only establishment. And I don't want someone driving my car when there are plenty of spaces to park in if you remove the cones. I've been parking in spaces my whole life, I think I can manage in that parking lot.
We love Maggiano's. As a couple, with friends, business meetings/banquet hall or catered delivery. Always good service and good food. On this visit, we had requested to sample a wine. Our waiter brought another variety to try in addition to the one we requested. And he brought two samples of each, so more than one could sample before deciding on a bottle for the table!
Very quiet and soothing. Francisco was a ...
Very quiet and soothing. Francisco was an excellent waiter. The food was excellent and the dessert was amazing.
I should always ask not to be seated nea ...
I should always ask not to be seated near parents and their young children. Probably a 2 yr old and a 4 yr old sitting right behind me and loud and fussy. Or your hostess should know not to seat guests near a table with young children.
This restaurant has been going downhill ...
This restaurant has been going downhill for the last year. Last night it was intolerable. Service was atrocious. Appetizers never came out and food appeared before we even had a chance to start our salads. When we asked to speak to the manager they did not want to send him over. It took several requests for him to appear and he had no clue what was going on. When I asked him why the seat in the booth was ripped he replied that manY of the booths had ripped seats and had been ripped for months. When I was leaving I walked by the kitchen entrance and found an overpowering and atrocious smell coming from the carpet. I don't think this restaurant has had a good cleaning in months. We used to dine there frequently and noticed in the last year you never see the same managers or wait staff. We will never dine there again and recommend that others avoid this establishment also.
Great food, but service gone downhill in recent years.
server was wonderful. Food was great! Since it was Mother;s Day it was packed! Good thing I made reservations and that saved us so much time. Great dining experience. Will go back again. Love the buy one take one home pasta. Perfect for our busy life.
Awesome food and time!
Awesome food and time!
Mother's Day surprise lunch
My daughter and I wanted to surprise her mom and my wife with one of her favorite places to eat. She was surprised and enjoyed them meal. We had reservations at 12:45 and we arrived early. They were ready for us and we were seated and the waitress had already taken our drink order by 12:45. The place was hopping lots of people in and out and for a big day. The waitress kept us filled with drinks and bread and our food was hot and tasty. I would go again even on a busy day like this.
Maggiano's Little Italy with BIG Taste
Most chain Italian restaurants are not much better than any other, but Maggiano's is one of my favorites. The food is always excellent and the order one for your meal and take one home is ideal for those of us who are either single or not into weeknight cooking. Love it! Love it! Love it!
Mother's Day lunch
Fantastic meal & service for Mother's Day lunch. One of our favorite restaurants. Reasonable prices definitely a plus.
It was an extremely busy evening. The n ...
It was an extremely busy evening. The noise level was extra loud, making conversation a bit difficult; but the tasty food and harried server made up for all short comings.
The tables were really close to one anot ...
The tables were really close to one another, my family and I could hardly move our chairs out to with out bumping someone.
Not as good as the first time
Our first time with just my husband was just amazing so I thought for Mother's day I would take a group. Maybe because it was Mother's day they were just overwhelmed but the food was not as good and the service was not as top notch as our first time. My husband did not even get his food until everyone else was done eating. The server was good about this and did apologize. We understand things happen. But then when he got his food the meatballs were overcooked it was just not what we expected. Do go and enjoy this place just not on a holiday.
The table smelled like a musty dishrag, ...
The table smelled like a musty dishrag, we had to wait too long for our order to be taken, and the food was moderate at best. The waitress asked if anyone had allergies they should know about and my wife mentioned her allergy to tree nuts. That was a mistake! We had to wait for her to round up the manager who questioned my wife further about her allergies. This was totally unnecessary and very patronizing. Everything has gone downhill at Maggiano's. It would be forgivable if the prices weren't so high. I do not recommend!
Food was great, managers always pleasant, but seemed to be forgotten by waitress. We did a lot of waiting and waiting on our food and then on our check even though the crowd at the time we arrived was light.
Consistently great experiences
Exceptional service, great food and ambiance never change, always love going here
Food was very good. They were very busy we had reservations but still had to wait 20 minutes for our table. We felt very rushed with our waitress. We've been there mant times and have never felt so rushed.
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.