Excellent food and service. On the pricey side but they do steak perfectly!

Best ribeye I've had in years.

Visiting town for a business conference and wanted a nice dinner. There were 3 of us so we each ordered a starter, an entree meat, and a side and shared them all. The portions are large so this was more than enough food and we left quite full.

We started with the soup of the day, a New England clam chowder, the classic wedge salad, and the burrata appetizer. All were fantastic! The clam chowder was creamy with salty bacon and large plump clams. The salad was fresh, with delicious blue cheese dressing, the burrata- so good! The plate comes with six garlic toasted crostini, the jar full of fresh burrata, cubed tomato, prosciutto, and vinaigrette dressed arugula- when combined these made a perfect bite! Creamy, crunchy, smooth, salty, vinegary, fatty, fresh!

Next up meat and sides! We got- a 14oz CAB Ribeye, a 14oz bone-in Ribeye, and a 10oz filet mignon. All cooked to a perfect medium, season with salt and pepper and finished with butter, melt in your mouth deliciousness. We chose the Brussels sprouts with bacon, a tad too strong on the mustard but did cut through some of the rich fattiness; the Yukon gold mashed potatoes, do yourself a favor and definitely order these! A luscious creamy bite alone or even better with the steak and you’ll thank me; and finally the Mac and cheese- creamy and rich with spiral noodles, we asked for it sans chipotle which we were told was only in the crumb topping, and it was comfort food at its best!

Our server Roberleigh (awesome by the way!) let us know about the chocolate lava cake during the appetizers so we could mull over the idea of ordering one since it takes 20-30 min for it to be made. No pre-made cakes here! It was dark and rich, served with vanilla ice cream, a crunchy and slightly sweet pistachio cookie, and a bowl full of the best ever chantilley cream.

This is a place for a memorable dinner. We will definitely try another Fleming’s in another city and come back here the next time in Madison!

Was a great evening. Wine, food, service and atmosphere all came together.

My boyfriend and I came here to celebrate our anniversary and everything was wonderful! We even received a box of truffles and a gift card for our next visit! Great service!

Food was good (marginal)
Ok for a special occasion but would not go back anytime soon

As always we had a great meal at Flemings. What sets them apart from almost every restaurant out there, though is the attentive staff. We always feel pampered when we go there.

Excellent service and good for a business group of seven.

Prime rib was just the way we like it - rare and tender. Dessert was yummy. Salads were excellent. Service was excellent.

Let's face it, we cannot grill steak at home like Flemings. So when a special treat is in order, make it Flemings. Melt in your mouth steak, delicious Flemings potatoes, yummy new brussel sprouts and superb carrot cake to top it all off. And don't forget the extensive wine list! We will be back....

Terrific dinner, great staff, wine list was fabulous, pairings to meals and fun facts involved with the wines themselves. Overall my wife and I had a terrific, quiet date night.

Great food and wine as always with Flemings. We appreciated the accommodation of our children (ages 8 and 10). They provided a children's pre fixe menu that was great. All around a great experience.

Excellent staff! Food was great and so was service!

Overall nice experience. The price is a little high for what you get, wine in particular is over priced, but overall an okay experience. Steaks are good, not great, but good.

Wonderful dinner with friends that had never been there before. Laura took very good care of us. Flemings is our new "go to" restaurant for special occasions. We will be back.

Both Ruth and I were delighted with our dining, especially the food and the fine details to make it a wonderful evening.

Very nicely decorated, ample parking, ample space between tables (so you don't have to hear everything going on at other tables), great steaks. Service was pleasant but rather slow for me. 2 hours from placing order, round of cocktails, salad, entrée & dessert to getting the bill.

We usually have outstanding experiences at Fleming's, however this location left much to be desired. Our server seemed annoyed to be there and could not handle the amount of tables he was assigned. I don't think he cracked a smile once. Each course took a long time to come out and then we sat with dirty plates in front of us as we waited quite a while for them to be cleared. The manager did notice the shortcomings and apologized, but did nothing to rectify the situation. This was a very disappointing anniversary dinner. Stay clear of this location.

My wife and I, along with another couple, enjoy coming to Flemings for the prime rib special. Every time we have eaten at Flemings the meal has been outstanding. Last Sunday's meal was less than satisfactory. To begin with, my French onion soup was basically tasteless. My wife ordered her prime rib rare, It came back medium. I ordered my prime rib medium, it came back medium well. It tasted fine but it was not what we ordered. My dessert was 1/3 of the size it was the last time I ate at Flemings. I asked the waiter about it and he said he would check into it. As it turned out, I received the portion that was designated for restaurant week. The waiter did bring me another small slice of dessert, but I don't think it was equal to what I should have received. The service was great,especially the waiter.

Fleming's is always good and consistent. We don't live in Madison but we lucked into restaurant week. A good value.

This visit was for a special occasion and it delivered! Party of 6, treated with special attention to detail. Most of us had the prime rib prix fix special and it was delicious and properly prepared. We enjoyed a wonderful dinner in an atmosphere that is both polished and yet casual. It is definitely also a romantic place. The booths are comfortable and the tables are not squeezed in for maximum seating. I have eaten here several times, both in the bar and in the dining room and have never been disappointed. Their desserts are all spectacular; but my favorite is the chocolate lava cake served with a scoop of ice cream, a sprinkling of pistachios and two crispy cookies artfully served. Even though it is a franchise, I have never felt as though the staff is ho hum about their service; the manager is present and friendly, greeting and visiting each table.

140.00 bill for a salad, steak, potato dish, baked potato, vegetable plate, coke, and a glass of wine. Includes tip. Each item was priced as ala carte. In most restaurants these would not be separate costs but considered a part of an entree. As a result one really has to think about how much you want to spend. Most budgets today could not afford Flemings.
In addition, there were no tap beers which was a disappointment, especially considering the persona of Flemings.
The waitress was very nice and took wonderful care of us. A special surprise was the gift card and truffles as a way of congratulating us on our anniversary. To bad we could not have used it right away as we do not see ourselves returning. Too expensive.

Amazing steak and calamari! Definitely recommend to anyone who appreciates a perfectly cooked steak. Moscato was very good as well. *

The 3 course Prime Rib special on Sundays and special nights is a very good value. A very enjoyable & delicious evening

Food was excellent. Service was excellent. We always enjoy dining at Flemings.

I ordered the 14 oz ribeye. It was cooked perfectly. The sides (creamed spinach & specialty potatoes) have far better tasting at other Flemings (Arlington Va & Richmond Va).

Beautiful decor, Outstanding food, and Excellent service. That's why Flemings is still the best steak place in town. Fresh baked bread, Lobster bisque, Prime Rib with home-made steak sauce and from-scratch creamy horseradish, Chipotle Cheddar Mac and Cheese, Carrot Cake

Great wine selection and steaks but brunch leaves much to be desired.

I used to put Fleming's and Ruth's Chris in the same category, but due to the noise level and the "pretty good" service, I would place Ruth's Chris way above Fleming's. They kindly gave us a chocolate dessert and $25 gift card for our anniversary (and a card for our table) but it was just too noisy and the service didn't blow us away like at Ruth's. Still, VERY nice place.

The food was fantastic. They catered to my needs without hesitation. I proposed to my girlfriend of 3 years and they helped me pull off the perfect proposal.

Awesome. We had never been. We will be back. Great server.

Our new favorite steakhouse in town. Excellent meat, perfect temps and professional wait staff. Great ambiance - not sleazy like some other places in town - and noise level was non-intrusive. Really enjoyed!

We had two different Rib Eyes-the aged and the not aged. The aged was much better and worth the extra $10. We had leftovers for brunch the next day! The food is PRICEY! I haven't paid that much for a meal in a long time, but we had a gift card that covered half. We were unsure what wine we wanted, so the waiter brought us three glasses to "blind" test. We chose one from those and it was a delicious Malbec (hard to find around Madison at restaurants). I wear hearing aids and they gave us a booth off to the side, so even though I can see it getting loud in the restaurant, I didn't have any problem hearing my date.

Service was excellent. Food was good; steak had to be sent back to cook a bit more. Music was pop; didn't set the mood for elegant dining. Very expensive, making us question if we'll be back.

Food, Se4rvice... all very good. Mothers' Day brunch must have had a few extra tables set out since it seemed a bit crowded. Overall nice meal, not cheap.

We went for brunch on Mother's Day. It could not have been better. The food was delic, the service was great, and the atmosphere was perfect for young and old family members! Can't wait to try it out for dinner! Highly recommended.

Went to celebrate our son's Law School graduation with family. Although the noise level was high that evening due to many people there celebrating graduations as well, the quality of the food and great service more than made up for that.

top notch food and wine, and service to match.......not cheap, but you will have an excellent meal.

Excellent evening and dinner. Excellent wait staff - truly appreciated.

We've been to Fleming's's several times for excellent food, cozy ambience, friendly and attentive staff and manager. We'll continue to dine at Fleming's. I wish they'd put the wagyu steak back on their menu. Or maybe add Kobe steak.