We were greeted by the hostess who sat us at a reserved table that we reserved through OpenTable. Then our waiter took our drink order while we waited for friends to arrive. My Crown Royal manhattan was outstanding. Friends arrived, we talked and ordered dinner. When our order arrived my scallops were hot and the sides were cool and my wife's meal was cold. We had to send it back to the kitchen where it was heated in the over and returned about the time our guests and I were finished. Bad kitchen.
My wife and I were very pleased with the service. Hostess and waiter were attentive. But, it went downhill from there. My wife ordered the special (fish, mahi) and it came out really late and completely undercooked (they did take it off our bill). We also noticed the exact same dish was returned by the couple next to us. Must have been a bad night for the chef. To be positive, the restaurant atmosphere was great for a date, and drinks were good.
From the owner to the entire staff and especially our waiter, Andrew.... it was outstanding! We were seated immediately and Andrew made us feel as if we were his only table for the evening. We started with bruschetta for the table and it was absolutely delicious. Probably the best we’ve ever had! Then, we had ahi tuna which was seared perfectly and melted in our mouths. For dinner, 3 of us had filet mignon which was absolutely delicious and cut like butter! One entire was a salad with grilled shrimp and was fantastic! For desert, we had the mini red velvet cupcakes served with homemade vanilla ice cream and fresh whipped cream.... AAAMAAZING!!!! I highly recommend this restaurant and we can’t wait to go back!!
Gift card for my birthday from my son. My husband and I enjoyed the dinner very much. Our waiter was attentive, but not hovering. we enjoyed our evening very much, it made for a wonderful day for me. We left the restaurant to go watch our grand daughter perform in a dance recital . So I had dinner and a show. Who could ask for more??
Was in St Augustine with family for a short break. Felt the lighting was a little dark for my taste. I can see they were going for a cozy intimate feel but felt they went overboard. As far as the food was concerned we were expecting a slightly more expensive bill than usual but didn’t feel the food matched the price. I had the seafood trio and it was far too rich for my taste. I think it would have been far nicer with less sauce and being able to taste the fish. The server was pleasant enough but obviously inexperienced and that will improve in time.
Our waiter Jonathan was pleasant and efficient.
The meals were delicious. I enjoyed the special for the evening which was shrimp curry, others in my party had vegetarian pasta which she describes as “lovely”. Another friend raved about the chicken bev. The salads were uniquely presented.
Cellar 6 is worth enjoying. It is a bit noisy. Acoustics not helpful to enjoying dinner conversations.
Service was great, food was delicious. Weren’t satisfied with appetizers and they remade fish with personal apology.
Josh took great care of us.
On a quiet street like Aviles, you can almost believe you're sitting in Europe.
The service was the best we've ever had at a restaurant. We ordered medium well 10 oz. new York strip. The only sides available were mashed potatoes (about 1/2 ice cream scoop full) and asparagus (3). Our steaks were more like medium rare.
We had several appetizers to share and all of them were amazing. Our server Doug was excellent and very attentive. Can't wait to return.
The only thing that bothered us was a group of men being loud & making weird noises. Nothing to do with the restaurant. The staff was great, the food was great, & the drinks were great!! We will go back again for sure!
Bachelor party dinner, great new atmosphere with IPads to order drinks
We love coming here...always great service and the food is top notch!
Cellar 6 was spectacular in every way from the delicious food, to the fantastic service of ANDREW our server! I would highly recommend Cellar 6 as a charming restaurant in a charming city! Thank you for a memorable dining experience!
It's one of the best places in St Augustine. If you want a romantic dinner with a great Vibe this is the place.
Pleasant surprise among the many St. Augustine restaurants -- everything was top notch!
We had a delicious dinner here earlier in the month and even thought the kitchen was slow that visit, we decided to take out of town friends there for a good meal. Unfortunately it was a disaster of the first order and ended up being one the few times I walked out of a restaurant. The kitchen apparently was in meltdown mode and could ot get foor out to be served. Virtually every table we communicated with had been waiting an extraordinary amount of time for food; for us it was an hour and 45 minutes before we left. I also noticed that none of the wait staff was the same from our previous visit, another red flag. Stay away until they get their act together or go out of business.
Cellar 6 is an incredible intimate dining experience. Food is impeccable, atmosphere perfect for couples or small groups.
Fantastic food & service - Great winelist 👍🏻
Such nice atmosphere. Great date night just for two or a group of friends. The food is amazing. Cocktail variety is such fun.
Cellar 6 in St Augustine is our favorite dinning experience anywhere. The exceptional food .... romantic & historic atmosphere and attentive friendly service brings us into town from a long distance at least a dozen times a year. There are some good restaurants around yet most others are from average to a worse dinning experience. The unique quality, atmosphere and service at Cellar 6 establishes a beyond comparison league of it’s own.
We prefer dinning on the sidewalk by the historic cobblestone street. Some may prefer the more social atmosphere of inside dinning.
My wife and I enjoyed our dinner. The service was friendly, informative, and responsive. The restaurant is very well appointed. We will recommend to friends and family visiting St Augustine.
First time visit. Date night, late Valentine, early Birthday dinner so we had reservations. I checked I and was told 10 mins, they would come and get me, 15 mins later after people kept walking in and were seated immediately I went back and asked how much longer. They said oh, I’m sorry, let’s get you seated and we went to a small table 10” away front a table on either side. Oh well. The appetizer and meal was ok. Nothing phenomenal, but ok. We did get a complimentary b-day dessert which was nice, but I doubt we will go back. Too many other nice places in St Augustine!
This is one of our favorite restaurants. Our meal was excellent as was the service.
I had the walnut crusted Mahi with a balsamic reduction and it was out of this world.
When will Celler 6 stop the policy of trying to seat everything around the edge close together... while leaving the prime seating empty... apparently the owner orders...ask to move or walk out they will get the message eventually
Food and service was great. Only issue was when we checked in early for our reservations the hostess forgot about us and sat other guests ahead of us. The food was prepared perfectly and our server was phenomenal. Very engaging and had a strong grasp on the menu despite being relatively new. We will definitely be back on our next of many trips to St. Augustine.
Great atmosphere and food ! Service was top notch
It was Valentine’s Day, so it was really busy and really loud. The waiter was not specific when describing the specials. The filet came out with seafood on it, not good when the person doesn’t eat seafood. My fish was over cooked and tough and the carrots were raw. The ambiance is nice, loved the red lights ! I would recommend this restaurant for drinks and appetizers or late night
Great food. Our waiter, Jonathan, was great. Can’t wait to get back.
Great time, wonderful service. Took my wife there vantines day and had a nice evening.
Ruined our Valentine's Day! Server was poorly trained and not knowledgeable. Menus (I-Pad)
were scarce, so we both could not view a menu at the same time...very awkward. For a place named "Cellar 6", had a very poor wine selection...only ONE French red and only ONE Italian red, both poor quality choices. They were pushing "wine on tap". Quality and preparation of food were good, but WAY over priced. Many other top quality restaurants in the area are more reasonably priced, with trained servers and quality wine lists. We will never return!
Cellar 6 is a gem hidden along a cobblestone alley downtown. This was our third visit and we have always liked the food. Our most recent visit (Valentines Day 2018) was our favorite. The food was terrific and the portion size was good.
Doug , our waiter was great! Great way to send our Anniversary. Water was awfullllll.
First visit here. Nice intimate atmosphere I would recommend it to friends.
IN TOWN WITH HUBBY FOR A WEEKEND GETAWAY. FOOD AND SERVICE WAS AMAZING! WE WILL DEFINATELY RETURN IN WE'RE IN THE AREA AGAIN.
The food was forgettable, but the Mezcal Old Fashioned was incredible!
We really wanted to love this restaurant. Even with a reservation, our server seemed quite annoyed with us (4 non-drinking young women). In fact, we almost left, but gave her a second chance. Happily, the manager took over serving us and really made up for her. He was a blast. I hope she is an exception, and that everyone else has a great time in the future. However, we will not be back and we wouldn't recommend it.
Always nice to eat here. Cool off-beat place with excellent food and service. Will be going back again
Food was incredible. The Brie appetizer was to die for.