About Carnegie House Restaurant
State College, PA 16803
Awarded 9 years in a row by State College Magazine as the Best Fine Dining Restaurant and Best Romantic!
As you enter the dining room through the glass-pained French doors from the library, a feeling of warmth and elegance beckons you to enjoy leisurely fine dining. A bow window allows dinner guests to view the beautiful flowers that surround Carnegie Inn & Spa and the woods surrounding the golf course. China, crystal, and silver grace the tables on crisp white table linen along with bouquets of fresh flowers. Servers are attentive in providing for the needs of the guests who dine on Contemporary French Cuisine.
From breakfast to elegantly prepared hors d'oeuvres and dinner selections, dining at Carnegie Inn & Spa is as spectacular as it is relaxing. The Library invites casual conversation while savoring a favorite cocktail or glass of wine from the Wine Spectator award winning selection.
Contemporary French / American, Contemporary French, Steak
Hours of Operation:
Mon-Thur 5:00pm - 9:00pm
Fri - Sat 5:00pm - 9:00 pm
Sun - Closed
$31 to $50
AMEX, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
Our culinary and service professionals will work with you to create a legendary experience.
CATA HP Route
Banquet, Bar/Lounge, Beer, BYO Wine, Chef's Table, Cigar Room, Corkage Fee, Fireplace, Full Bar, Non-Smoking, Outdoor dining, Private Room, View, Wine
Special Events & Promotions:
Throughout the year we will feature special menus featuring wines and liquors paired with menus created by our culinary team.
Carnegie House Restaurant Ratings and Reviews
Valentine's dinner here. It was a very n ...
Valentine's dinner here. It was a very nice evening. The food was very good and the atmosphere was great. Not a noisy/modern restaurant. The only slight issue was with the delivery of food. You would think at a restaurant of this level, they would know who ordered which entrée. Instead it was a "food auction" at the table- "Who ordered the ....?" Need to fix that. Wine prices were a little high but the mixed drink prices were very high.
The food was delicious and the service w ...
The food was delicious and the service was prompt and courteous. We enjoyed having a drink in the library before taking a seat at our table.
One thing that really disappointed us was the seating arrangements. The dining room is not very large, but we were seated at an excellent table in the bay window area. Very nice and peaceful, despite a very vivacious and talkative customer at another table. Just as our meal was ending, the hostess seated another couple at the 2-topper right next to ours--I could have touched them with an outstretched hand. Given the fact that there was another 2-topper twice the distance away, it felt extremely awkward to have another couple sit so close to us. We ordered dessert and felt like we were way to close to the other couple for any of us to be comfortable. Had we been the couple being seated, we would have asked to be seated further away but we had no choice and felt bad for everyone involved.
Food was uniformally excellent. Creative ...
Food was uniformally excellent. Creative and fresh tasting beer salad especially memorable. All entrees excellent.
Wine service very disappointing. Selection of wines by the glass limited and generally mediocre and uninspired; wines served in mundane general purpose wine glasses, not proper red or white wine vessels. This seemed so inconsistent when food options were $30-40 each. I don't understand why the wine was served this way.
This is an outstanding restaurant. It i ...
This is an outstanding restaurant. It is located in a hotel, but draws people who are not guests of the hotel for good reason. The service, ambiance and food were top notch. And the prices are not through the roof. All in all it was a great experience.
The waitress/doorman are professional bu ...
The waitress/doorman are professional but not friendly. They give a sense that the guests have to follow their old European style of service. If not, it's the guests that are not following the upper class rule and should be taught a lesson. While they might have good training on the service technicalities, they should get more education on showing more respect to each individual as a free person. After all, this is where America exceeds Europe.
We had a lovely "significant birthday" c ...
We had a lovely "significant birthday" celebration. The service was beyond excellent as well as the ambiance and food. This is a venue for a special dinner with that special someone. We look forward to returning again for another memorable occasion.
I dined at the Carnegie House and also s ...
I dined at the Carnegie House and also stayed at the Inn for my anniversary. The setting is warm and inviting and cozy, with the view of the wine cellar and the library. The food was phenomenal. We were given a complimentary appetizer of smoked salmon from the chef and it was the best salmon I've ever had. The chicken I ordered for dinner was amazing and cooked to perfection, and dessert was the most delicious and rich dessert I've had. The service is wonderful and kind, too. The atmosphere is so calm and relaxing, with candles and flowers on the table and a wonderful view out the window. I will definitely be returning and recommending to friends!
We've been here twice and haven't been d ...
We've been here twice and haven't been disappointed. The short ribs were amazing and the bay scallop appetizer was fantastic. We also enjoyed a bottle of wine from their large wine list. Our waitress, Dawn, was attentive, friendly and made suggestions to help us choose our meals from the menu. Thank you to the staff at Carnegie Inn for an all-around wonderful stay in addition to the amazing dinner!
Romantic & Upscale Dining! Relaxing amb ...
Romantic & Upscale Dining! Relaxing ambiance that is a great choice for a date night or special occasion. I'll be hosting my daughter's graduation dinner here because he atmosphere and food are phenomenal and can't be surpassed by another venue that I know of. Great management with Ken (Restauarant Manger) and Don (Inn Manager). Great service from Dawn and Anita. Excellent check into Inn by Sam. Excellent, cozy rooms in the Inn. Highly recommend with no reservations.
I always have a wonderful experience at ...
I always have a wonderful experience at Carnegie house and so does my mom. We introduced my husband to the experience and he enjoyed it as well. By keeping the dining room on the small side, they can better control your experience and they try to make your visit a warm, classy and consistent culinary experience. Being able to sit in the study/lounge area with a fireplace and have a drink before you go to your table at your own pace is a fantastic part of the overall experience. I've had dinner made by the previous chef before this current chef and their knowledge of food and preparation are equal.
We had a lovely anniversary dinner exper ...
We had a lovely anniversary dinner experience here. This was our first visit and we enjoyed the experience of complementary hors d'oeuvres and drinks by the fireplace before transitioning to our table in the dining room. The restaurant was smaller than imagined but cozy. The service was excellent and the food was well prepared and beautifully presented. This is a great spot for special occasions and most menu items were quite reasonably priced.
My fiancé and I ate here for his birthda ...
My fiancé and I ate here for his birthday. We were brought into the library where we had a glass of champagne and a light complementary appetizer. It was okay; nothing to write home about. The atmosphere was very enjoyable though.
We were then escorted into the dining room where we had the beet and goat cheese appetizer. I loved that. They split it for us on two plates before it was brought out. He got the filet of cod wrapped in bacon. The bacon was slightly undercooked and chewy, but the veggies around it were delicious. I had the mushroom soup and the Kobe sashimi appetizer. The soup was lukewarm and the rice in the sashimi was kind of gummy and needed more sauce.
We had a few cocktails that were expertly made. Then we ordered the apple cobbler for dessert. The waitress brought it out with a candle in it, which was so nice.
Overall it was a nice dinner, but the food wasn't as amazing as I remember it being.
A very nice restaurant inn ffor special ...
A very nice restaurant inn ffor special occasions
Very confortable and nicely decorated quiet ambiance serving delicious food from a very wide assortment of menu items. Excellent attentive service where staff goes out of their way to make your experience a most enjoysable one. A bit pricey but great for special occasions
I like the environment but the food was ...
I like the environment but the food was not impressive. The lamb I ordered was not cooked as I requested, and one piece actually missed some portion which seemed odd. I asked and showed to the waitress but her answer was not very polite. The portion were not big too for the price we paid.
Beautiful place with excellent food! We ...
Beautiful place with excellent food! We were treated to a drink and hors d'oeuvre in their library when we arrived. We tried the mushroom soup, which was fantastic, as were our meals of bacon wrapped cod and crab cakes. We would defnitely return for another try!
The Carnegie experience is always a good ...
The Carnegie experience is always a good one. Sometimes it can be a miss depending on the experience of your server. On this occasion it was quite good since we had a very attentive person managing our table. The food was excellent from appetizers, entrees to deserts.
One negative was the host who seemed bothered the night we were there except for anything he was doing. Upon arrival when I asked him if he could chill a bottle of wine we brought he commented, "I can't take that now, but you can give it to your server." Ouch! Not the reception I expected, but maybe an off night.
My wife and I were disappointed in our d ...
My wife and I were disappointed in our dinner for the first time in many years of celebrating our anniversary at Carnegie House. My wife started with a salad which she found to be very good. At her request the kitchen added some candied walnuts to her salad. I started with a cream of mushroom soup that was flavorful but rather thin in consistency. The main problem was our entrees. We both chose a veal chop special described as being stuffed with prosciutto and fontina cheese and served medium rare. What we got were two beautiful rib chops that were so undercooked that they were difficult to cut and nearly impossible to chew. The cheese stuffing was barely soft and there was no prosciutto visible.
Our server was attentive and pleasant but clearly inexperienced. We received no bread until we requested it after we had finished our first courses.
Great food, atrocious service. Preten ...
Great food, atrocious service. Pretentious and lacking any sense of 'the dining guest should be respected'. 7:30 dinner reservation, not seated until 9(left to languish at a dirty cocktail table) service not completed until almost 11. no clue as to what was wrong, others around us who arrived after us were fed before we were. 3 out of 4 entrees were delivered as ordered, no water service, etc., etc., etc. Bill was incorrect. Excuses but no apologies.
The food was good but was overpriced for ...
The food was good but was overpriced for the portion size. For example, to pay almost $30 and get 3 scallops on an entree seems excessive. 3 oysters for an appetizer at $15 is another example. While very good not a good value. In addition the champagne and white wines were both served warm. At $12 to $15 per glass. In a small room with 5 tables of couples was nice and intimate. Unfortunately 5 older men sat in the middle of the room and spoke so loud you couldn't talk at your table. Finally, the service was poor. We had a 9pm reservation yet waited 15-20 mins between the courses and received our wine order after we finished our entrees. Sad for such a nice place with great foot. Staffing is a real issue. If you want to charge high prices, higher staff.
Exceptional food and service. A place fo ...
Exceptional food and service. A place for special occasions and a date. Pricey for casual dining but you need to pay for the flavors of the food and the environment. The only caveat is: if one is eating outside, which was great when it was early, the lighting is not the best later. Consequently, later in the evening, I couldn't see the food that I was eating. I should have asked for another candle; I am sure it would had been provided. I would certainly return.
Prime Spot in State College. We have be ...
Prime Spot in State College.
We have been celebrating my daughter's 20th birthday in the restaurant. Currently she is studying at Penn State. Frankly we have been afraid not being able to find an appropriate nice place with good food. However, we have been and are still very impressed with the Carnegie House. Excellent service, superb ambience, and great food. Specifically the lounge, sitting down before dinner and winding down was a real treat.
When again in State College, we definitely will go back.
Amazing! Very relaxing. Started with win ...
Amazing! Very relaxing. Started with wine and a complimentary appetizer in the library. Waiter was very knowledgable about their food and wine. Attentive service and great food. Nice and quiet ambiance too. Just what we needed. We I'll return for sure! Perfect evening!
Service was atrocious. Reservation was f ...
Service was atrocious. Reservation was for 7:00 PM. Sat until 7:20 before our drink order was taken. Was told we would receive a complimentary hors d'oeuvre while we waited, but did not. Service after we were seated was very slow and disjointed. Had feeling the staff could have cared less whether we were there or not. It was our 47th wedding anniversary. My wife cried. The evening was a very expensive disappointment. The food was very good, but was overshadowed by the terrible service. We could have been served Spam and we would not have been any less disappointed. Will we return? Probably not.
My wife and I dined with our daughter. ...
My wife and I dined with our daughter. The beets and goat cheese and warm brie salads and bean soup were excellent. The black truffle mac & cheese did not have much (any) truffle flavor. The main courses Halibut, Poulet Rouge and Scottish Salmon. The service and the ambiance were superb as well.
Please sign in to record your input. Thanks!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.