I made a reservation 30 minutes prior and the hostess mentioned, "oh you're the one who made a last minute reservation."
We had a nice table and the restaurant is nice for Stillwater. Menu is lovely, but I found it not to be true to descriptions. The Parmesan garlic fries were just frozen coated fries from a frozen bag. I thought they would toss them in Parmesan and garlic. I asked for pickles with my burger and was told they didn't have any. Then a few minutes later server brought them and said the kitchen found some. As a chef, it sounds like the kitchen is cutting corners and not following recipes.
The ambiance and decor is very nice and location on Main Street is cute, next to boutique stores.
Brooklyn's was an excellent choice for brunch. The server (Cat) couldn't have been better and our large party's orders were correct. We were never left waiting for anything and had a wonderful time.
One of the best places in Stillwater to have a cocktail and well prepared meal.
Overall the restaurant was pretty good. Our server had a difficult time due to the computers being down and as a result, I order a salad and did not get it until after they brought the main meal. She apologized but otherwise she did a great job. The food is good and an overall good value. Thanks.
Food was great! The deviled eggs were awesome!
Brooklyn's had excellent food. The prices were great for the amount received. Good atmosphere although a little loud if you're wanting a nice, quiet dinner.
This restaurant has great food and a nice atmosphere.
We always enjoy eating here when we are in Stillwater! Such a great place! Our favorites are almost all of the appetizers....especially the Brussel Sprouts, and for dinner the coffee-rubbed Ribeye! YUM!!
We like Brooklyns because it is one of the nicer restaurants in Stillwater. We have been several times since they changed the menu and have not found the food to be as good as it used to be. Our favorite things on the menu are appetizers- especially the brussel sprouts and the fried green tomatoes. The shrimp and grits are also good.
Was looking for a Stillwater brunch option and Brooklyn's delivered! The biscuit & gravy was disappointing, but the cornmeal hash was delicious
Nice place to go that's not the usual college town scene. Nicer can get good entree or sandwich.
We enjoyed tasty chicken and waffles! Nice wine selection. Excellent service!
Really great ham burger with sunny side egg on top - had a side of bacon and carmalized onions - very good -
Brussel Sprouts are fairly obnoxious in regards to the smell.
Good food but very small portions
Great service in a wonderful location
Took my son to celebrate starting college at OSU. Wait staff was great and very efficient. Food was great. Atmosphere of a big city restaurant, which was fun!
The entrées sounded better than they actually were. The chicken special was described by our waiter as "okay"...said the meatloaf (which they were sold out of) was better. Haha They advertise that they're a wine bar but the 2 wines I got (rosé & pinot grigio) were really bad and syrupy sweet. Atmosphere was okay, probably won't be back but could've just been a fluke- we were visiting stillwater just for the night.
Excellent!! The food was delicious!! Highly recommend.
We had shrimp and grits and the chicken and waffles both were great. For dessert we shared the chocolate flourless cake. To die for.
All four entrees were quite good. Chicken and waffles were the table favorite.
Almost never have an issue with service or food, and the ones I have experience have been minor. Would recommend it for lunch or dinner, and is a great place for a date.
Great food, great vibe. Portions are generous and delicious.
Our family chose Brooklyn's for our Easter brunch. Everything was perfect. My husband and I indulged in a Bloody Mary with our meals. I had the Chicken Fried Steak and Eggs and he had the Eggs Benedict. Our 3 year old daughter loved her short stack of pancakes. Everything was great! We will be back.
WILL DEFINITELY DINE HERE AGAIN! THE FOOD WAS AMAZING! AND THE SERVICE WAS TERRIFIC TOO! LOTS OF GREAT GREAT FOOD CHOICES!!
I can't wait to go back and try chicken and waffles. The waiter was outstanding. The restaurant is classy and has a great atmosphere.
Raw chicken. Raw chicken. Raw chicken. Then the manager had to be convinced that it should be removed from our ticket. No, after chewing into raw chicken, one doesn't really want to eat chicken.
Made reservations through OpenTable and they were ready for us when we arrived. Food and service were great. Bloody Mary bar was an awesome touch. Prices were reasonable though maybe a little high if you are a college student.
Haven't been to Brooklyn's Restaurant in a while. The food is still as great as ever. Even though they have reduced the number of menu items, they have kept the best. Our group loved the Beef Cottage Pie, Italian Meatloaf and Seafood Pasta. The Coffee Rubbed Rib-Eye is always excellent too. As I'm gluten-free, I always look forward to the Flourless Chocolate Pie.
Very nice restaurant in Stillwater. A nice restaurant with creative food. Great service. Enjoyed the meal immensely.
Had a group of five, and server was polite and friendly, however, the courses were not timed well. Members of my party were disappointed regarding questions asking to remove appetizers and then salad prior to being finished with the previous course. I would encourage the wait staff to be more cognizant of the pace of the diners and communicate that to the kitchen. Otherwise the server was good and the food was enjoyable.
We visited Oklahoma family and wanted to include a student for a nice dinner. We had reservation that was promptly answered and staff was very attentive. We were served drinks and dinner in quick order. Everyone has it prepared to their liking. Very nice overall experience.
Food is good but seating is not great!
i really wish I could remember the waitresses name, so I could give her a shoutout. The food was great, the atmosphere, wasn't crazy loud, the menu wasn't overwhelming, and we were given extra coffees for the road.
Chicken fried steak and eggs for brunch is good. I believe we had a new server and new manager, who handled our service very poorly. The separated checks were wrong. We got a run credit card from another table (and they got ours). And then the wrong cards were run on the wrong checks. Very poor experience at a restaurant that is normally descent.
THE BEST FOOD my wife and I have had in Stillwater and we have eaten everywhere from sushi to sandwiches! We absolutely loved everything from the waitress to the desert. My wife had the shrimp and grits minus the sausage, which they added more shrimp no charge. I had the Ahi Tuna Steak and we ordered calamari appetizers and had bannana bread pudding desert. We both agreed that everything was wonderful and very reasonable for the price. I have already recommended this place to everyone I know and we live in Ponca City, so alot of people from here eat out in Stillwater. We will for sure be returning!
We were seated immediately with our reservation. I had the taco special which is a good value, but the thin tortillas quickly disintegrate. Waitress was ok. I always like the ambience of the restaurant.
Brought my parents here for their wedding anniversary. The table was ready for us, but we sat forever until the hostess saw no waitstaff had come by so she helped us. She was very good and gave the kids colored pens and paper to entertain themselves. The kids liked their chicken strip meals; my husband enjoyed his burger; my Italian grilled cheese was good but not as warm/crisp as usual; my parents disliked the taste of the Mac-n-cheese but that's individual.
Their food is unique to our little town and it makes for a great little retreat. Service was "meh". Mostly due to a lack of customers on a Tuesday night. Food was quite good however.
The weather was great for patio dining. As always, the service was good and the food is consistently delicious.
One of the best things about Brooklyn's is its consistency. I can expect consistently good food and consistently good service. Many of the staff are attending OSU's hospitality school so they take service seriously. Every time I make a special request, it is honored and then made better. Well done!