I made a reservation 30 minutes prior and the hostess mentioned, "oh you're the one who made a last minute reservation."
We had a nice table and the restaurant is nice for Stillwater. Menu is lovely, but I found it not to be true to descriptions. The Parmesan garlic fries were just frozen coated fries from a frozen bag. I thought they would toss them in Parmesan and garlic. I asked for pickles with my burger and was told they didn't have any. Then a few minutes later server brought them and said the kitchen found some. As a chef, it sounds like the kitchen is cutting corners and not following recipes.
The ambiance and decor is very nice and location on Main Street is cute, next to boutique stores.
Brooklyn's was an excellent choice for brunch. The server (Cat) couldn't have been better and our large party's orders were correct. We were never left waiting for anything and had a wonderful time.
One of the best places in Stillwater to have a cocktail and well prepared meal.
Overall the restaurant was pretty good. Our server had a difficult time due to the computers being down and as a result, I order a salad and did not get it until after they brought the main meal. She apologized but otherwise she did a great job. The food is good and an overall good value. Thanks.
Food was great! The deviled eggs were awesome!
Brooklyn's had excellent food. The prices were great for the amount received. Good atmosphere although a little loud if you're wanting a nice, quiet dinner.
This restaurant has great food and a nice atmosphere.
We always enjoy eating here when we are in Stillwater! Such a great place! Our favorites are almost all of the appetizers....especially the Brussel Sprouts, and for dinner the coffee-rubbed Ribeye! YUM!!
We like Brooklyns because it is one of the nicer restaurants in Stillwater. We have been several times since they changed the menu and have not found the food to be as good as it used to be. Our favorite things on the menu are appetizers- especially the brussel sprouts and the fried green tomatoes. The shrimp and grits are also good.
Was looking for a Stillwater brunch option and Brooklyn's delivered! The biscuit & gravy was disappointing, but the cornmeal hash was delicious
Nice place to go that's not the usual college town scene. Nicer can get good entree or sandwich.
We enjoyed tasty chicken and waffles! Nice wine selection. Excellent service!
Really great ham burger with sunny side egg on top - had a side of bacon and carmalized onions - very good -
Brussel Sprouts are fairly obnoxious in regards to the smell.
Good food but very small portions
Great service in a wonderful location