Review 1 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 2 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 3 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
| Overall Rating |
|
(Poor)
|
"A $65.00 Bruch not including a drink or coffee is very steep.When you combine it with pressure to order the main entree,from the moment you sit throught the open shell food bar,and the invisible sashimi and tuna/lobster sandwiches and tacos Cart.Their strategy,order the entree 1st,the less you'll have of the others.Entrees terrible:Been heated and try to find the Lobster in the Eggs Benedict;Lobster Cobb salad:Again find the Lobster,a couple of bacon pieces,a bit of avocado,and a pile of greens more than a rabbit can consume.The Raw Bar:some oysters,stale shrimps,and not lobster tails but pieces of it,and the carcass of the lobster body.The bill with 3Teas & no drinks, a$298 (3of us)including 18%tips you're not told so you can tip again."
| Food |
|
(Fair)
|
| Ambiance |
|
(Fair)
|
| Service |
|
(Fair)
|
| Noise Level |
| (Quiet) |
By an OpenTable.com user
who dined on
02/28/2010
(review submitted 03/02/2010)
|
|
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
|
Review 4 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 5 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 6 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 7 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 8 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
| Overall Rating |
|
(Outstanding)
|
"what can I say, this place lived up to its named...great atmosphere, food was extraordinary...best NY strip ever, I had the ash cured venison and was amazed. I never had it before, but will again...Very pricey, but again, well worth the money..went with my 13 yr old daughter, she had the strip and ate the whole thing...that should tell you how good the food really was...she even ate the beef tartare appetizer and wanted more....highly highly recommend, but get your check book out...to give you an idea of price, the two of us had a 3 course meal, wine, dessert, bread and the bill was well over $150...."
Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion, hot spot
| Food |
|
(Outstanding)
|
| Ambiance |
|
(Outstanding)
|
| Service |
|
(Outstanding)
|
| Noise Level |
| (Quiet) |
By an OpenTable.com user
who dined on
02/20/2010
(review submitted 02/24/2010)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Review 9 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 10 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 11 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 12 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 13 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 14 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 15 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 16 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 17 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 18 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 19 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 20 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 21 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 22 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 23 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
| Overall Rating |
|
(Good)
|
"the waiters are nice and take good care of you, however, the hostess girls are horrible, they are not kind at all,they dont even say good evening, they look at you with one brow up and it looks like they make you a huge favor when you ask for your table. they make you wait 20 minutes or more and send you to the bar (even with reservation)honestly thats not a good start... we were close to leave the place since I was there to celebrate my husbands bday...anyway the place is gorgeous and you forget all that when you taste a good wine, some fresh oysters and a very good waiter"
Special Features: neighborhood gem, romantic, special occasion
| Food |
|
(Very Good)
|
| Ambiance |
|
(Outstanding)
|
| Service |
|
(Good)
|
By an OpenTable.com user
who dined on
02/05/2010
(review submitted 02/08/2010)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Review 24 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 25 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 26 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 27 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
| Overall Rating |
|
(Very Good)
|
"The splendor that is the Oak Room. Love the food, love the atmosphere, sat in the main dining room. Unfortunately the seating was not condusive for both of us...halfway thru we were able to be moved, in order for both of us to face out and see the grand spaciousness of the room. We ordered off the Restaurant Week menu and ordered an additional appetizer, that thru off the wait staff and we were left waiting for our second course, they then attempted to bring out the main course before the second appetizer, it continued in that manner with additional bread and finally received our dessert well before our coffee which we had ordered originally.
Overall the room is spectacular and unique, I'll give the wait staff a pass this time..."
Special Features: fit for foodies, great for brunch, special occasion, great for lunch
| Food |
|
(Outstanding)
|
| Ambiance |
|
(Outstanding)
|
| Service |
|
(Good)
|
| Noise Level |
| (Moderate) |
By an OpenTable.com user
who dined on
02/05/2010
(review submitted 02/07/2010)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Review 28 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 29 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 30 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 31 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 32 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 33 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 34 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 35 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 36 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 37 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 38 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
| Overall Rating |
|
(Very Good)
|
"The Oak Room is a NYC institution with an illustrious past. That is not to say, however, that it is tired. I would rather describe it as special. It has warmth and roots and authentic atmosphere. Having been there several times, and having never had a negative moment there, I recommend it unequivocally - particularly if you have an out of town guest and you want to share a memorable, uniquely NY experience. Don't be intimidated by the location; you will be treated graciously. The food is consistently very good - as is the service. If nothing else, go to the bar, have a drink, enjoy the atmosphere, and savor the incredible craftsmanship that went into its creation."
Special Features: romantic, special occasion, scenic view
| Food |
|
(Very Good)
|
| Ambiance |
|
(Very Good)
|
| Service |
|
(Very Good)
|
| Noise Level |
| (Moderate) |
By an OpenTable.com user
who dined on
02/01/2010
(review submitted 02/03/2010)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Review 39 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 40 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 41 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 42 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 43 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 44 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 45 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 46 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 47 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
| Overall Rating |
|
(Very Good)
|
"We all know the Plaza is in big financial trouble, and it's a shame to think this lovely room, one of the most gorgeous in the city, if not the most, may soon be gone. It's romance personified, rich with history and tradition, makes you feel royal just to be there. The Restaurant Week food was superb, the service a bit uninformed (try pronouncing "chenin" properly guys...) but efficient and pleasant. But the real scene is the Oak Bar right next door, that's where "today's" aficionados are hanging out; noisy, social, buzzing, alive. The Oak Room itself needs to have some life injected. No it shouldn't emulate the bar, but somebody with a knack for injecting "foodie excitement" needs to take charge. Maybe Danny Meyer would like to try."
Special Features: vibrant bar scene, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion
| Food |
|
(Very Good)
|
| Ambiance |
|
(Very Good)
|
| Service |
|
(Good)
|
| Noise Level |
| (Quiet) |
By an OpenTable.com user
who dined on
01/29/2010
(review submitted 01/31/2010)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Review 48 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 49 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 50 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 51 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 52 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 53 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 54 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 55 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 56 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 57 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 58 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 59 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 60 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 61 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 62 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 63 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 64 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 65 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 66 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 67 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 68 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 69 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 70 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 71 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 72 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 73 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 74 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 75 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 76 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 77 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 78 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 79 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 80 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 81 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 82 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 83 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 84 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 85 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 86 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 87 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 88 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 89 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 90 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 91 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
| Overall Rating |
|
(Very Good)
|
"The Lobster and Sea Urchin BLT was fun...the aforementioned ingredients with sourdough gnocchi, oven dried tomatoes, crisp prosciutto and lettuce emulsion, served in a bowl. It didn't taste like a BLT as I guess I should have presumed, despite the respective ingredients, but I wouldn't change a thing. Arguably the Gnocchi was the bread, and the marriage of all items created a cloudy sauce that might resemble mayonnaise. The prosciutto came through with its salty, brittle texture. The Ash Cured Venison with cauliflower puree, pickled pear, black trumpets, and huckleberry captivates in print but was not fully harmonious. The pickled pear made no apologies. Can't recall the chanterelles. Instead a cubed, bland root veg. But venison delighted."
Special Features: fit for foodies, special occasion
| Food |
|
(Very Good)
|
| Ambiance |
|
(Very Good)
|
| Service |
|
(Very Good)
|
| Noise Level |
| (Moderate) |
By an OpenTable.com user
who dined on
12/11/2009
(review submitted 12/13/2009)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Review 92 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 93 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 94 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
| Overall Rating |
|
(Outstanding)
|
"Amazing experience, the staff was professional, extremely courteous, very knowledgeable, and very approachable. The food was outstanding, the menu very diverse, and look forward to another quiet evening out for a romantic dinner... Five stars across the board!"
Special Features: good for groups, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion, hot spot
| Food |
|
(Outstanding)
|
| Ambiance |
|
(Outstanding)
|
| Service |
|
(Outstanding)
|
| Noise Level |
| (Quiet) |
By an OpenTable.com user
who dined on
12/08/2009
(review submitted 12/10/2009)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Review 95 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 96 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 97 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 98 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 99 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 100 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 101 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 102 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 103 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 104 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 105 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 106 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 107 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 108 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 109 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 110 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 111 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 112 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 113 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 114 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 115 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 116 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 117 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 118 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Review 119 for The Oak Room at the Plaza Hotel
|
Print this page
