Reserve now:

Butter Reservations

Restaurant Reviews List > New York / Tri-State Area Restaurant Reviews > Manhattan Restaurant Reviews > NoHo Restaurant Reviews > American Restaurant Reviews

Restaurant Reviews for Butter

Butter

415 Lafayette Street
New York, NY 10018

Butter is located in downtown Manhattan in the heart of the city's famed Greenwich Village. Our Executive Chef, Alexandra Guarnaschelli offers traditional American Fare highlighted and enhanced by subtle global influences with the grace notes of seasonality.

Dining Style: Fine Dining
Price: $31 to $50
Parking: Public Lot
Cross Street: Astor Place and East 4th Street

See more Butter details

Average Diner Rating
Overall Rating		3.8 out of 5 (429 Reviews)

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

Summary of Special Features

Diners classify this restaurant as:

fit for foodies (196)
special occasion (182)
hot spot (155)
romantic (144)
good for groups (98)
neighborhood gem (73)
notable wine list (70)
vibrant bar scene (57)
late-night find (39)
great for lunch (26)
scenic view (10)

+ see more special features/tags

Butter Reviews List

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"What a great experience! I am rarely rendered speechless, but the rack of lamb shut my mouth. The food was perfectly cooked, the brussel sprouts were fantastic, and the raspberry bengiets were delicious. While Th service wasn't gushing or bubbly, our server was on the spot and efficieant. She let us enjoy our meal and was knowledgable about the menu. Thank you for a great experience!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

FEATURED REVIEW

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/15/2010

(review submitted 02/24/2010)

0 of 1 people found this review helpful.

Share this Review:

Review 2 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Butter was a backup when other standards in the area were booked but it did not disappoint. Another place to recommend to foodies! Excellent food, enthusiastic service. I would certainly go back when in town and take friends."

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/16/2010

(review submitted 03/18/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 3 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Food and decor was great. Server kept bringing us food meant for other tables. Noise level (loud disco-type music) and young women wearing tiaras made this a better spot for young b&t."

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/13/2010

(review submitted 03/16/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 4 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"Alexandra needs to refocus on the food and it's preparattion... To overcook the food is not attention to detail. Everything from appitizer to dessert was overlooked and not prepared correctly. A beautiful venue with nothing inside!"

Food		(Poor)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/11/2010

(review submitted 03/13/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 5 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"This was my first time dining at Butter - and it was fabulous. The staff were extremely friendly and helpful. The space and decor are stunning, yet still warm and inviting. And the food was fantastic. The foie gras was as good, if not better, than any I've ever had, and the pork porterhouse was tender and delicious. They have an extensive wine list which should suit every taste (and pocketbook). I would definitely recommend Butter for any occasion."

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, late-night find, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/11/2010

(review submitted 03/13/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 6 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"my friend and i both thought the food was wonderful a terrific ambience and somewhere we would recomend highly to friends"

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion, scenic view, hot spot

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/10/2010

(review submitted 03/12/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 7 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"Nice space, though looking tired. Water stained walls, large dried-out floral arrangements in cloudy water. Food is "good", not world class. Bar has the ambiance and lighting of a Howard Johnson's, circa 1970. Lastly, the service is outrageously bad to non-existent. Oddly, there a are a lot of people standing around doing NOTHING. A rather severe-looking woman, who I suppose is the boss-lady, roams around glaring at staff and customers. The waiter was way over his head....I poured the wine all evening in his long absences, had to ask passerbys to clear used glasses and plates....you get the picture. Butter has seen its day. P.S., take your BOSE noise blockers. Acoustics of a bowling alley."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Poor)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/10/2010

(review submitted 03/12/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 8 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"The food and atmosphere were exceptional. Can't wait to go back!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/05/2010

(review submitted 03/10/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 9 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Great restaurant! Exceptional food, friendly staff with excellent service. Would definetlely reccomend :)"

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, romantic, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/05/2010

(review submitted 03/09/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 10 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Over-rated and over-priced food. Small restaurant and weird bar area. Great place to pop in for some cool appetizers and a drink, but would not recommend for dinner."

Special Features: notable wine list, hot spot

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/05/2010

(review submitted 03/08/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 11 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"First of all, the staff was very friendly. Butter Cheff's should consider putting less garnish on their meat dishes. I had the Lamb. It was very good after setting aside all the sauce, onions, roasted tomatoes and more on top of it, otherwise, it tasted superb. The meat was tender and it was perfectly cooked. It took 20 minutes for my Malbec to arrive to the table. We ordered Sambuca after dessert and they only had one Snifter, so my boyfriend "Birthday Boy" had to drink his in a whiskey glass. I was not impress!!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, neighborhood gem, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/27/2010

(review submitted 03/03/2010)

1 of 1 people found this review helpful.

Share this Review:

Review 12 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"The food was very good but won't return. Didn't seem all that special."

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/27/2010

(review submitted 03/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 13 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"We hit up Butter on what turned out to be a quiet evening due to a blizzard, and thoroughly enjoyed the evening. The food was delicious (the best chicken I have had in a long time), the drinks tasty & strong, and the vibe was cool and energetic. Our waiter recommended the Sticky Date pudding for dessert and it was yummy as promised. I expected there to be more of a bar scene, but imagine it's busier when there's less snowfall. The dining room was rather loud (I read in another review to request a table upstairs, and I would second that motion if you don't fancy dining in the club), but for us the music was great. All around a great evening, when we left they were closing up for the night."

Special Features: hot spot

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/26/2010

(review submitted 03/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 14 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"As usual, I had a great time at Butter. But I was a little disappointed that the place was basically empty (I went on a Tuesday in February)."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/23/2010

(review submitted 03/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 15 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"I was traveling with a group from NH and we were looking for a fabulous NYC dinning experience and Butter was it. I was disappointed that you did not offer a Merlot wine."

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, special occasion

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/27/2010

(review submitted 03/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 16 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"It was such a great dining experience!
The Service was Excellent! Everyone was so attentive of everything, and made the night so enjoyable.
The food was to die for! Had the Swordfish Special. Deliciousness.
The wine list was also very well picked, with decent prices, and a great selections.
We finished the night at the bar, and I loved the Butter Martini!

Cannot wait to go back! :)"

Special Features: neighborhood gem, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/27/2010

(review submitted 03/01/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 17 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Everything was top notch, from the white birch themed decor to the excellent cuisine and service. Make sure you have the beignets for dessert."

Special Features: fit for foodies, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/27/2010

(review submitted 03/01/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 18 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"Didn't feel the love from our server which makes or breaks a meal. Appetizers very good, entrees disappointing. When we told our server, after a round of cocktails, that we were looking for a bottle of red UNDER $50 he suggested a $68 and a $58 bottle. Not cool and not appreciated. When we pursued a cheaper bottle he was not happy or helpful. We had emailed the chef beforehand regarding our vegetarian guest and although we had an enthusiastic and personal response from him, there was no follow-through upon our arrival regarding any special dish for him."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/27/2010

(review submitted 03/01/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 19 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Delicious food, great music, wonderful experience!"

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, late-night find

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/26/2010

(review submitted 02/28/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 20 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"The food and ambience are superb. We did, however, have to request a copy of the Restauranr Week menu as it was not distributed with the menu."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/25/2010

(review submitted 02/27/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 21 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Poor)

"Food is decent, but the service is terrible. There's a saying that you know it's good service when the only thing you need to ask for throughout the meal is the check. Butter did the exact opposite; we had to ask for everything (multiple times for certain requests) except for the check. They were so rude that they dropped the check on our table and asked for our chair while some of us were still drinking our coffee."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/19/2010

(review submitted 02/26/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 22 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"I don't understand what all the hype is about this restaurant. The food was okay. I thought the appetizers were better than our main entrees. The ambiance was great. But, we had to remind our waiter to bring us our drinks. And, apparently if you're a group of two people, you don't get bread and butter with your meal. Overall, I thought it was just okay."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/24/2010

(review submitted 02/26/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 23 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Had a lovely dinner. Food was really good, bar service and drinks great."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/24/2010

(review submitted 02/26/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 24 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Alex came through again with 2 separate tasting menus for my table with separate wine pairings...outstanding"

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/13/2010

(review submitted 02/25/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 25 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Poor)

"The food was below average - we ordered the tasting menu, but there wasnt really a menu as such. we were told that we would get random things from the kitchen. thought it would be interesting, but the time between courses was too much and the food was not either tasty or creative. some of it was not even hot. would never go back there or recommend it to people either."

Food		(Poor)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/12/2010

(review submitted 02/25/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 26 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"We went during Restaurant Week. The food was delicious, the service was excellent. I would definitely go back."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/12/2010

(review submitted 02/25/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 27 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Excellent meal, service was a bit slap dash"

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, romantic

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/12/2010

(review submitted 02/25/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 28 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"If you have the opportunity to dine at butter, I would reccomend requesting a table in the main dining room, My wife and I were seated in the downstairs lounge area and were seated at a cramped table practically on top of the couple seated next to us. There's also a DJ down there spinning records, which is fine if thats what you're looking for in a night out. Overall I enjoyed BUTTER, my meal was excellent and the service was very attentive, I would go back again but request to sit upstairs..."

Special Features: fit for foodies

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/13/2010

(review submitted 02/24/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 29 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"We had a lovely dinner at Butter. The waitstaff was knowledgeable and attentive without smothering. We tried several items off the regular menu and some specials too and we were pleased with both. My only concern was being seated downstairs, but that turned out to have a cool easy vibe. On my next visit I plan to try the tasting menu (chef's choice) and request seating in the upstairs dining area. At the end of the night I was still curious about both."

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/06/2010

(review submitted 02/24/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 30 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Valentines day dinner was exceptional. Foie Gras and duck breast were excellent. Dinner was pricey for two people ($615 with wine and 20% tip) but worth it."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/14/2010

(review submitted 02/24/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 31 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"Overprized Food for that very lowprized taste. Never ever!"

Food		(Poor)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/22/2010

(review submitted 02/24/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 32 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"The Music was SO loud that I couldnt think. We asked the waitress to lower it and nothing was done. Finally a fellow diner leaned over the DJ booth to lower the music. The waitress forgot our sparkling water (I had to ask her twice) and never bused our table. She never came to check on us. It took 35 mins for our appitizer to come and an hour after that for our meals. She never once checked in with us until I flagged her down and she told me the kicthen was running behind. The food was great though. Our reservations were for 6:30 and we left at 9:20. That was way too long for our food to come. I was unhappy with this."

Special Features: fit for foodies, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/19/2010

(review submitted 02/23/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 33 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"Have previously had a good dining experience at Butter but this time, our waiter was not very attentive and our food was late. Explained that we had theater tickets but even though arriving with plenty of time, the food still arrived 10 minutes before we had to leave, so we had to rush through our meals. Probably will not return."

Special Features: notable wine list

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/19/2010

(review submitted 02/23/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 34 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Fantastic. The butternut squash soup was delicious and the raspberry beignet dessert was divine."

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, fit for foodies, good for groups, late-night find, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/20/2010

(review submitted 02/22/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 35 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"I was expecting a much better experience. I ordered a salad with goat cheese and got blue cheese instead. My porterhouse came to me well done instead of medium. My husbands tuna was was overcooked and extremely overpriced for three little pieces.
I was really dissapointed."

Food		(Poor)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/20/2010

(review submitted 02/22/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 36 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"I went to Butter on a Saturday night and had an early reservation (6:00) so it wasn't too busy but other people were there. The food was EXCELLENT! We had a raw salmon appetizer which was to die for. For our entrees, we had a fillet and a veal chop, both cooked very very well and tasted fantastic! Overall, Butter offers a wonderful dining experience and we will be sure to visit again."

Special Features: neighborhood gem, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/13/2010

(review submitted 02/22/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 37 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"The food was sublime. The service was amazing. The decor was exciting yet warm. I needed a moment to myself after the chicken liver pate. One of the best dining experiences I've ever had - my new favorite restaurant."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, romantic, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/17/2010

(review submitted 02/21/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 38 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Butter is a lush fine dining lair. For the most part, everything was amazing. Pros: the steak w/ crimini mushrooms and balsamic reduction was impeccably cooked, the service was amazing, and the ambiance is cozy and inviting. Decent tuna tartare, fantastic trotters. Cons: cornbread served in place of French bread. The cornbread was dense, cakey, and overly sweet. Sometimes, the classics are better. The lobster entree was tasty but had far too much shell and membrane in the mix making the dish quite awkward to eat. Butter's downstairs presented a possibly opportunity in the nightlife department with an intimate little lounge area. Without a doubt, Butter would be worth a second visit."

Special Features: fit for foodies, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/18/2010

(review submitted 02/21/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 39 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"There was a wait of 25 minutes as the restuarant was running behind schedule. One of the signature drinks was to have Patrone but I received a lesser quality Tequila. The wait staff was unattentive. Therefore, I left a very small tip. The real saving grace was the food."

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/17/2010

(review submitted 02/21/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 40 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"My girlfriend and I went to Butter for Valentine's Day and it was one of the best dining experiences we have had. Gretchen, our precious server, was amazing. She was accommodating and attentive. We dined for about 2 & 1/1 hours and did not feel rushed. The food is delicious and the atmosphere is relaxed. We loved it!"

Special Features: special occasion

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/14/2010

(review submitted 02/20/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 41 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"the service was terrible. the waiter was very unfriendly. they tried to clear our plates repeatedly before we were finished. one of the servers actually rolled his eyes when we asked for a small plate to share our desserts. completely unacceptable, especially for such an expensive restaurant. will not go back."

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/18/2010

(review submitted 02/20/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 42 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Service was less than adequate. Server seemed to be good to there. He could not offer any recommendations at all. The fantastic food made up for his ignorance."

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/17/2010

(review submitted 02/19/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 43 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Went there for Valentine's Day and the food was very good, ambiance was great, and this service was also quite good (though we did stay about a course behind another couple who sat down at the same time as us). Expensive, but worth it, overall for a special occasion."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/14/2010

(review submitted 02/19/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 44 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Great food, great ambience, great service. Great experience!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/13/2010

(review submitted 02/18/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 45 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"The food was great as always! Love Butter. The restaurant held a great table for me as per my request. Thank you OpenTable."

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, fit for foodies, good for groups, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/16/2010

(review submitted 02/18/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 46 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"The ambiance and interior design was beautiful. We were there for restaurant week, but the waiter remained outstanding and did not rush us at all. It was a Monday night, however, so the restaurant was relatively quiet and not too crowded, noisy, or clublike (mentioned in other reviews). We sat upstairs which was lovely. The bar area was downstairs. The appetizers were tasty (shrimp and butternut squash soup), and entrees were very delicious (duck confit, and spare ribs). The dessert was terribly disappointing. I am a huge dessert fan, and I left the chocolate cake half eaten when we finished. My boyfriend also left his banana topped rice pudding half eaten. Not very moist, sweet, or special. Overall, a great night, but skip dessert."

Special Features: fit for foodies, romantic, hot spot

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/15/2010

(review submitted 02/17/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 47 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"Good restaurant. Valentines menu was a gift overpriced for what we recieved. 80$ pp makes more sense than 150$ front of house was not good. Water remain unfilled, Champagne was forgotten until reminded, Time between dishes were long.Ambience was loosely decorated for valentines day and looked a bit cheesy"

Special Features: romantic, special occasion

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/14/2010

(review submitted 02/16/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 48 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"We loved the ambiance! The food was good, but maybe a little bit too rich for my taste... The people I was with thought it was delicious though."

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, good for groups, romantic, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/13/2010

(review submitted 02/15/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 49 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"The wait staff was okay, bussers were great and the waiter that actually took our table and stayed with us was great. some of the patrons were on the snooty side, but most were fine. Wonderful looking place. Regular menu not so extensive, I would not bring a large group here, not enough choices. The restaurant week menu seemed better than normal menu. The taste of the food was great! It is a bit cramped so, even for two it can be a bit uncomfortable. Not really suited(upstairs) for parties over 6."

Special Features: hot spot

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/12/2010

(review submitted 02/14/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 50 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Amazing from start to finish. Food was great...waitress was great...met Chef Alex and it made my day.."

Special Features: fit for foodies, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/12/2010

(review submitted 02/14/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 51 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"I went for restaurant week. The appetizers were pretty good, but the entrees (short ribs & duck confit) i found were nothing outstanding and actually on the salty side for me. I ordered a cocktail and the waiter warned me that it would be very sweet which i like but it ended up tasty salty ! the desserts were nothing special too.. & also the hostesses & our waiter didn't smile and weren't super friendly. All in all it was a meh experience. good thing i tried this place out for restaurant week and not at full price. definately expected better from a $$$$ restaurant. but the one thing i must give to them is that the decor & ambiance was very nice"

Special Features: good for groups

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/11/2010

(review submitted 02/14/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 52 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Great place for who is going to the Blue Man Group Show that is right in front. My and my wife's plate were great, but my daughters plate was cold. You have to get lucky to get a good waiter. Mine was not so good and I kept looking after him."

Special Features: fit for foodies, romantic

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/11/2010

(review submitted 02/13/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 53 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Our restaurant week prix fixe meals were reasonable portions, and the appetizers and entrees were very good. The dessert, however, was horrible--inedible--and two of us sent ours back. The banana and rice pudding concoction, which was bitter and crunchy, not sweet and creamy as expected, left such a bad taste that we did not request another option. An unfortunate way to end an otherwise delicious meal. The downstairs area where we were seated was lively, but the decor was nothing special. If I were to return I would request to sit upstairs. Our server was pleasant and helpful, and his overall service was spot-on."

Special Features: fit for foodies

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/05/2010

(review submitted 02/13/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 54 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Went for Restaurant week. I forgot this was a hipster place but the atmosphere is nice. The bread basket was good (esp. the cornbread). I had the shrimp appetizer. I didn't care for it. My husband had soup which was good. I had the duck confit which was tasty but a little to sweet for me. For desert I had the rice pudding and ice cream which was delicious. Our waiter was nice and very accomodating. Overall nice place to go with friends but not a romantic spot. We saw Russell Simmons as we were leaving."

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, hot spot

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/09/2010

(review submitted 02/11/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 55 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Ate at upstairs dining room during restaurant week. Good selection and generous portion size. Only food misstep was the white chocolate mousse dessert which lacked any discernible chocolate flavor. The dining room is beautiful and there is a warm but cool vibe. Very enjoyable."

Special Features: fit for foodies, special occasion

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/07/2010

(review submitted 02/09/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 56 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"We dined with two friends at Butter during Restaurant Week, and couldn't have been more delighted. The $35 dinner sampled the best of the regular menu, and the portions were as substantial as anything you would get for conventional pricing. The butternut squash soup was fabulous, and we loved the little bowl of popcorn for sprinkling. What a delightful and yummy combination! The short ribs were succulent, tender, and beautifully sauced, served with purple potatoes. My partner's salmon was moist and delicious and our friend's duck confit was rich and savory. Dessert provided the only misstep. I ordered the carmelized bananas, expecting a variation on Bananas Foster, but they were simply sliced bananas with caramel sauce. Overall: solid A."

Special Features: fit for foodies, late-night find, neighborhood gem, romantic, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/07/2010

(review submitted 02/09/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 57 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"I was very disappointed with Butter this past weekend. We had such high hopes for dining there. We went during restaurant week and part of me is wondering if they decided to slack for that reason alone. Service was horrible, our waitress never came by to see how we were doing and how the food was. As for the food, some of it was great and other portions were just okay. I don't think we plan on returning again...restaurant week is supposed to provide an insight and sampling into different places around NYC and this one left us with a not so wonderful experience."

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/07/2010

(review submitted 02/09/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 58 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"It wasn't nothing special when it comes to the food quality. A bit disappointed for what it can offer."

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/07/2010

(review submitted 02/09/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 59 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Butter is my new favorite restaurant. I'm just sorry that I waited this long to try it! Not an off note in the entire meal. I'm glad we were upstairs - it was beautiful; not so downstairs. Bar area plainer, but it looks like a great private party spot should one be so inclined."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/02/2010

(review submitted 02/09/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 60 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Hats off to Butter's Restaurant Week lunch special. The restaurant went all out and we enjoyed not only every course, and the wonderful, personalized, attentive service from Christopher, but also the cozy ambiance. Butter continues to impress!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, neighborhood gem, great for lunch

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/05/2010

(review submitted 02/09/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 61 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Service is REALLY slow. The inside looks really great, but maybe some little things that were cool a few years ago need to be updated."

Special Features: good for groups

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/07/2010

(review submitted 02/09/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 62 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"waiter was extremely rude: when rewquested to have food placed in To Go bag he made some snide comments to the bus boy - something to the effect he could not believe that this was being done. service was painfully slow, we did not receive apps until an hour after we ordered..."

Special Features: romantic

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/05/2010

(review submitted 02/09/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 63 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"The food was good, satisfying but not too filling. The atmosphere was cozy and romantic, but a bit crowded. The servers were friendly."

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, good for groups, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion, great for lunch

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/05/2010

(review submitted 02/08/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 64 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"All 4 of us agreed that each course was delicious. The restaurant is beautifully designed, and creates a wonderful dining "experience". The service was attentive. It's quite expensive, as opposed to overpriced."

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, fit for foodies, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/05/2010

(review submitted 02/07/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 65 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"The food was rather good, but our bottle of wine did not arrive until after the entree was served and we had to ask for the bottle to be brought. Overall the service was shoddy, too much time between courses and seemingly no respect or love for the food and wine served. Possibly our waiter had too many tables, but this is no excuse. A busy restaurant should know and schedule as many waiters as necessary to not have the mishaps that we experienced. No apologies or even recognition that anything was wrong from our waiter was the kicker. Seemed as if this was how service ran as usual."

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, good for groups, late-night find, hot spot

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/05/2010

(review submitted 02/07/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 66 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"The food was enjoyable, but the service and the management was so sub-par that it ruined the entire dining experience."

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/05/2010

(review submitted 02/07/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 67 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"I love this place, though the restaurant week lunch was not my best experience there. It's a very cute and hip place, with excellent food (as a rule) and a very pleasant atmosphere."

Special Features: fit for foodies, great for brunch, neighborhood gem, romantic, special occasion, great for lunch

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/28/2010

(review submitted 02/07/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 68 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"The food was good but not revelatory. The charcuterie plate was excellent- varied and delicious. My mushroom ravioli was good but not memorable. The rice pudding was heavy, mushy, and not well flavored. The bread is dry and flavorless. The butter, particularly the chive kind, was creamy and flavorful."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/05/2010

(review submitted 02/07/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 69 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"I dined at Butter at the end of January, and me and my girls had a great time. The food was great, the waiter was nice. The only thing we had to complain about was the wait for food. We were eating pretty late (around 10pm on a Thursday night) and it took at least 45 minutes between each course, when we had clearly been done for over half an hour. Besides that, it's was great food (limited menu, though), a pretty & stylish environment, and helpful staff. I'd go back - and go to the club next time, too."

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, good for groups, romantic, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/28/2010

(review submitted 02/06/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 70 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Given the reputation of Chef Guarnaschelli I expected excellence. The food was good, but the service was poor. Our empty entree plates sat on our table for approximately 25 minutes and our water glasses remained empty throughout the entree portion of our lunch. The Birch Room was full and the wait staff seemed adequate in number, but not much attention given to the diners. Of course, it was during restaurant week, but the service was so poor that I defintely will not return nor will I recommend Butter to any of my colleagues, friends or neighbors. Certainly not up to the standards Chef Guarnaschelli would demand of others."

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/05/2010

(review submitted 02/06/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 71 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"best food i have had in a while - LOVED the butternut soup with POPCORN!!!!"

Special Features: fit for foodies

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/04/2010

(review submitted 02/06/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 72 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"I thought Butter was alright. My friend and I ordered from the Restaurant Week menu. The Florida shrimp appetizer was pretty good. The tables were a bit too close together for my taste, otherwise the ambience was nice. When I was looking at the pictures of the restaurant, the website gave the illusion that the trees along the back wall were real. When we got there and saw the "forest" was a lighted backdrop it was a little disappointing and somewhat of an eyesore. Would not go back."

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/02/2010

(review submitted 02/05/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 73 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"First time visit - restaurant week highlights - FANTASTIC butternut squash soup, and everything from there was very good, but not out of this world. Service was friendly. Definitely worth a try! Ambiance is extremely comfortable."

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/02/2010

(review submitted 02/05/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 74 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"I went to Butter for Restaurant Week and found it delightful, despite some reviews which indicated bad service; to the contrary, our waitress was sweet, patient, and eager to please. The upstairs room is quite beautiful, although pretty noisy. Not sure about the downstairs room. My dinner (charcuterie platter, short ribs with pomegranate, and cheese plate) was excellent. Their regular menu looks very enticing (pig trotters!), although pricey."

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, fit for foodies, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/03/2010

(review submitted 02/05/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 75 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"My dining experience at Butter was simply delightful :) I was a little bit surprised of its location because I found that I live really close to it. Going inside, it was beautiful and I couldn't believe it existed. The service was pleasant and quick. My friend and I had no problems with anything, and the food came right away. All the courses were delicious (I had the fish of the day, and the creme caramel for dessert - best shortbread ever), and the whole thing was just nice. Sounds too good to be true, but it actually was that good."

Special Features: good for groups, great for brunch, romantic, special occasion, great for lunch

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/03/2010

(review submitted 02/05/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 76 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"I went for restaurant week, so it was crowded as expected. Nice Staff, good food. My only complaint is that the chocolate cake I got was very dense and dry. Bad end to a great meal."

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, fit for foodies, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/03/2010

(review submitted 02/05/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 77 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"i was just disappointed by the food. the atmosphere is great and defintely somewhere i would chose to go for drinks or a night out. young, hip. but i went there for restaurant week and the meat was tough. i also felt that the food was not very out of the ordinary for it's reputation and price point. i was also disappointed by choices of red wines by the glass."

Special Features: good for groups, hot spot

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/03/2010

(review submitted 02/05/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 78 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"The service was not great. First off, we did not get served bread like other tables. Then our server was not attentive in terms of our orders, besides the fact that he mixed up the orders he took the wrong order for our desserts. The server even gave us the check before we were ready to leave which was absolutely rude."

Special Features: fit for foodies

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/02/2010

(review submitted 02/04/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 79 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"Went for Restaurant Week and sat downstairs, which was a bit too dark and depressing. Service was good...waiter and busboys were attentive but not overbearing. Food was really just ok...shrimp appetizer was a bit overcooked and the flavor profile was a bit off (spicy, but lacking a sweet component to counteract the spice). Duck confit was nice, but by no means earth-shattering. Dessert (had the white chocolate custard and my date's dark chocolate cake) was borderline horrific. All in all, a very average meal."

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/02/2010

(review submitted 02/04/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 80 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Main dining room was half empty and even so our entrees took almost 30 minutes to come after the appetizers... Read in other reviews that this is a common problem there. Food was good but not impressive."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/02/2010

(review submitted 02/04/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 81 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"The foods were delicious and the whole experience was great."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, scenic view, great for lunch, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/01/2010

(review submitted 02/03/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 82 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Beautifully decorated atmosphere, food was great conceptually and executed very well. Great place to have dinner in the city with some girlfriends."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/01/2010

(review submitted 02/03/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 83 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"One should have high expectations for the food of Alexandra Guarnaschelli, a network TV celebrity chef and harsh judge of other chefs. The food was less than exciting, extremely overpriced, and the size of the portions is...well...insulting. The charcuterie plate was described in detail featuring duck mortadella and venison salami. The size of the one evident piece of meat was see-through thin and slightly larger than a quarter. The ravioli entree featured four shriveled flat small ravioli. The wine list is extremely over-priced with unusual mark-ups on ordinary wines. Overall, a great disappointment. This place is not at all a decent value for the price point, and the mediocre level of gourmet quality certainly doesn't warrant it."

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/29/2010

(review submitted 02/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 84 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Amazing!

From the service, Mark was excellent-super friendly and knowledgeable, to the food-best complete dinner I've had in a while, Butter satisfied in all aspects.

I will be back soon."

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, notable wine list, romantic, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/31/2010

(review submitted 02/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 85 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"The serve was excellent, beyond the normal attention.I was impressed witht the food and service."

Special Features: late-night find, romantic, special occasion, scenic view, great for lunch

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/28/2010

(review submitted 02/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 86 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"The food was mind-blowing. So delicious! The atmosphere was really cool and relaxed, and the service was fantastic. Can't wait to go back!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, romantic, special occasion, scenic view, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/31/2010

(review submitted 02/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 87 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"The food was good, but the service was extremely poor. We waited over 30 minutes between appetizer and entree."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/31/2010

(review submitted 02/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 88 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"The food was amazing as usual! If you can appreciate a good meal your best bet is Butter. The butternut squash soup was superb, the pork porterhouse amazing, beer carrots as side was delish! Would definitely go back again and again. Its pricey so be prepared to shell out $$$"

Special Features: fit for foodies, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/30/2010

(review submitted 02/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 89 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Fantastic service and food. Will definatly dine here again :)"

Special Features: kid-friendly, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/30/2010

(review submitted 02/01/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 90 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Nice restaurant week menu. Great Duck Confit."

Special Features: good for groups

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/29/2010

(review submitted 01/31/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 91 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"My boyfriend and I went for restaurant week and really enjoyed the menu they offered. The only negative aspect about our experience was our horrible waiter. He was very inattentive, often took over 20-30 minutes to come back with a request. He also mixed up my boyfriend's dessert order which took about 30-40 minutes to come out after the table had been cleared. However, after observation from the other waiters on the floor, I would like to believe that we just had the worst waiter at the restaurant because the rest seemed to be attentive to their designated tables. Overall, we had a good experience. I would go back again, but under the condition I never get seated with that waiter again."

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/29/2010

(review submitted 01/31/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 92 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"I enjoyed the food at Butter and the service was gracious, though a bit slow. However, we were sat downstairs in what had clearly been designated the "Restaurant Week" section. I understand that Butter doesn't make as much money on Restaurant Week reservations, but I also think the mark of a truly stellar restaurant is one that treats all its customers the same, whether they're celebrities, teenagers on a first date, or Restaurant Week locals checking out a neighborhood spot that would otherwise be too pricey. And who knows? I could've been a critic!

Oh, and they played hiphop and R&B all through dinner, which I thought was a weird choice for fine dining."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/29/2010

(review submitted 01/31/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 93 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"My overall experience at Butter was enjoyable, I was truly satisfied with all aspects of the meal, ambience, and service. I would recommend it and go back again!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, romantic, special occasion, great for lunch

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/28/2010

(review submitted 01/31/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 94 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"When you make reservations, make sure you ask to be seated in the main dining area. If you can't some here for the ambiance, the food doesn't make up for sitting in the basement."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/29/2010

(review submitted 01/31/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 95 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Food was superb; beautiful room; slightly chaotic (but friendly) service."

Special Features: neighborhood gem, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/29/2010

(review submitted 01/31/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 96 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"It was hard to imagine a restaurant that would not offer a la carte lunch menu during restaurant week. I could understand if the prix fix had several items but six choices is not thoughtful enough for the customer."

Special Features: great for lunch

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/28/2010

(review submitted 01/30/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 97 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"It would have been much better if we wouldn't have to had repeatedly defend our (still full) plates from being taken away. Maybe because I am European I am especially sensitive to this rushing behavior (especially when it's in a better restaurant)."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/27/2010

(review submitted 01/29/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 98 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"The waitstaff was kind and attentive. The food was stupendous: savory, good textures, good flavours...mmmmm. The overall experience was delightful. Thank-you."

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/27/2010

(review submitted 01/29/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 99 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Came here for Winter Restaurant week 2010 for lunch. The food here was delicious. I ordered the Roasted Mussels. Savory and a little bit creamy. (Maybe it's from all that Butter? lol) My friend and the Veal Shanks. I tried a little piece of that and it was nice and tender. Felt like I was eating pulled pork. As far as the dessert goes... I had the fruit and cheese plate. One of the cheeses had a strong taste to it. Wasn't fond of that. everything else on the plate was fine. Friend had the Creme Caramel. yummmm.. just like flan. nice and sweet. Service was great. Answered my questions regarding the food and also helped with recommendations when it was hard to decide between 2 meals."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, great for lunch

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/27/2010

(review submitted 01/29/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 100 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"Not the best experience. Music was terrible and didn't work with the surroundings. Food was good, service was good generally but it's a little unprofessional to see staff on their mobile phones and not paying attention when you need them."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Poor)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/26/2010

(review submitted 01/29/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 101 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Poor)

"Worst food I've ever had. The restaurant's name is not misleading... The only thing that tasted good at this place was their herb butter."

Food		(Poor)
Ambiance		(Poor)
Service		(Fair)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/27/2010

(review submitted 01/29/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 102 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"I was being seated in the basement, which has no window with poor ventilation. Music was way too loud we could barely hear each other. Service was very slow. It was very difficult even to get someone to refill our water. Food wasn't so impressive for that price range. Server was too busy to serve the big tables. People kept bumping into my chair because the tables were too close to each other. It was just not a pleasant dining experience, and I don't think I will go back."

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/27/2010

(review submitted 01/28/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 103 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"We dined for RW and had a nice enough time. We made early reservations to avoid a RW rush and were seated right away. Both of our cocktails were terrible and I sent mine back because I could barely swallow a sip. I ordered a different cocktail which was good, nothing more, nothing less. For $14 a drink, you would think the drinks would be stellar. The food was pretty good, but I was disappointed in the dessert. We've had dinner at Butter before and the food was amazing so we felt a bit let down this time. On the flip side, the server was great. He was very attentive, knowledgeable, and pleasant. Because I know how great this place can be, I would most likely come back in the future, but not for RW."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/25/2010

(review submitted 01/28/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 104 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"OUR GROUP OF SIX WOMEN WERE TREATED ROYALLY - SOMETHING WE DON'T ALWAYS ENCOUNTER. THE FOOD, SERVICE, AND DECOR WERE FABULOUS AND ENJOYED BY EVERYONE IN MY GROUP."

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/26/2010

(review submitted 01/28/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 105 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"The wait staff hovered a bit too much and the main server bordered on obsequiousness. Our bread was whisked away twice without asking and we had to ask for it back to mop up rthe delicious sauces. The runners/bussers were always looking for something to take away often when we would have liked to be left alone. With all that they were courteous and friendly and the food was truly excellent - all of it. We look forward to returning there."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/25/2010

(review submitted 01/28/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 106 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"Lovely room, but so noisy is hard to hear your dinner companions. They tried to please but the service was soooo sloooww that by the time our entrees came we have lost our appetite. Too bad"

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/23/2010

(review submitted 01/28/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 107 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"The dessert was horrible...I had my first choice, sent it back because I found it unacceptable. They replaced with a chocolate cake, which was equally unacceptable."

Special Features: late-night find, romantic

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/26/2010

(review submitted 01/28/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 108 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"My entree (short ribs)was so tough that I only ate a few bites. But the friend who accompanied me had the same thing and enjoyed hers.

The pumpkin soup was TO DIE FOR; the best I've ever had. The accompanying popcorn was a nice touch. And the cornbread was scrumptious!"

Special Features: good for groups, hot spot

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/26/2010

(review submitted 01/28/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 109 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"What a pleasant surprise!! Between restaurant week business and Gossip Girl craze, I half expected a disappointment. Instead, the service was wonderful, the atmosphere unique and friendly, and the food really quite good (especially the charcuterie plate and the beer-braised carrots). It was a special and very enjoyable evening. We'll go back for restaurant week!"

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/26/2010

(review submitted 01/27/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 110 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"We were a group of 6 and everybody enjoyed their food. Its the ambiance (we were seated downstairs) that was a little disappoiting, specially so after being seated upstairs in numerous ocassions. The music downstairs didn't fit at all... the music upstairs was superb!"

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, good for groups

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/15/2010

(review submitted 01/27/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 111 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"My dinner experience at Butter this week was fantastic. The duck confit entree blew me away, melding the perfect tenderness of the meat with a complementary mushroom sauce and sweet apple puree. The combination was exquisite. Not only was the food memorable, but the ambiance in both the upstairs and downstairs dining rooms was imaginative and well executed. The service was attentive and prompt, even though it was the first day of Restaurant Week and the place was packed. I look forward to returning to what might be my new favorite restaurant in NYC!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, romantic, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/25/2010

(review submitted 01/27/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 112 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Had this been my first visit to Butter, it would have been my last! I have been many times and have always had a great experience so I can overlook yesterday. When we were seated we asked if we could be out in under an hour and were told absolutely.... after waiting 20 minutes for appetizers to arrive, my shrimp ravioli was totally cold inside. Lunch took even longer to get there and we even asked for our dessert to come out while we were still eating our lunch...still trying to figure out why creme caramel and a cheese tray took so long....my friend ended up having to leave and I had to search for a busboy to beg for some bread for the cheese tray. No one asked if everything was okay in between.Service was lackluster to say the least"

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/26/2010

(review submitted 01/27/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 113 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Butter was great, the service was so-so, but the duck confit was incredible and the crispy banana dessert was out of this world...except for the oatmeal type layer beneath. I enjoyed it there"

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, fit for foodies, notable wine list, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/25/2010

(review submitted 01/26/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 114 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"An absolutely wonderful experience. I was in town visiting for the weekend and a friend suggested this restaurant and I'm so glad they did. Everything was amazing. Especially the service."

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/22/2010

(review submitted 01/26/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 115 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"Clearly a venue that has passed on from "in" to "out". So whilst the pretention remained the entertainment has moved on.

The food was fine, the wine list though was outrageous: Cheapest Rioja was over $100."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/23/2010

(review submitted 01/26/2010)

1 of 1 people found this review helpful.

Share this Review:

Review 116 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Food is outstanding and I had wonderful service, but be aware that there are two dining areas. The beautiful upstairs main dining area and the downstairs with a DJ spinning on the weekends. It has the look and feel of the "overflow" room or worse. Make sure they seat you upstairs! If they mention sitting downstairs tell them you will wait."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Poor)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/15/2010

(review submitted 01/20/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 117 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"Our reservation was at 9:30 and we got there on time. Our table was not ready until 10:30. I understand these things can happen but the staff acted like this was the hippest place to be and was not apologetic. They would not give us updates and would not be honest about the wait. The drinks we had at the bar while waiting were not good. In the end, we ordered another drink and the bartender kept us waiting to pay while our table was ready for 10 minutes. They would not let us transfer the tab to our table - I was really annoyed about that. Very disorganized and not well run. The dance area after was super crowded and full or young bridge and tunnel crowd. Overall - really not worth it."

Special Features: late-night find

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/16/2010

(review submitted 01/18/2010)

1 of 1 people found this review helpful.

Share this Review:

Review 118 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"This review is for the downstairs dining area. Try to get a table upstairs. Even with a reservation, unless you specifically ask for it or meet some special case, we were told it would be a 45 minute wait beyond our original 9:00 reservation. The music was great but it was too loud for dining conversation. I had to reach across the table to make my Wife hear what I was saying but had to do it at a volume to also not disturb the people sitting beside us in a row of tables for 2. I would cut it back at least 25%. Great lobster, friendly service and cheaper than expected with drinks and mussels appetizers."

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, late-night find, hot spot

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/16/2010

(review submitted 01/18/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 119 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"Unfortunately it appeared that to increase their revenue this restaurant has decided to bus in large noisy groups of tourists for dinner. We only saw the waiter 3 times during the entire meal (he had perfected the technique of passing the table without making eye contact), however the bus staff tried very hard to make up for this. We tried many dishes but only one was worth wading through. Most were gravely wanting. The wine list, which the wait staff didn't seem to have a clue about, was severely wanting and very over priced.

We eat out at least four times a week at various restaurants not only in Manhattan but many of the outer bourghs and New Jersy as well and Butter is one restaurant that we would definitely recommend you pass on-"

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/12/2010

(review submitted 01/17/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 120 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"Not the best food and mediocre service"

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/09/2010

(review submitted 01/14/2010)

1 of 1 people found this review helpful.

Share this Review:

Review 121 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"An absolutely lovely restaurant and a very fine dining experience. My biggest criticism is that my veal chop was not well trimmed at all. A ton of fat! Also the entire dish was brown. I think a more colorful presentation would have made me feel more pampered. Those pesky comments aside, I think Butter is a very fine place. Oh, and the chicken breast: excellent!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/09/2010

(review submitted 01/12/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 122 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"The atmosphere downstairs was awful. Dark, loud, hot and crowded. The food was very good and service decent. We went upstairs to the bar and while the atmosphere was much nicer, the bartender was terrible! Made a terrible drink and offered terrible service!

Will not return."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/09/2010

(review submitted 01/12/2010)

1 of 1 people found this review helpful.

Share this Review:

Review 123 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"The food at Butter is good, not great. Everything we ordered seemed to have at least one too many elements on the plate. Our server was capable, the bus boys not so much. Watch out for overpriced specials."

Special Features: hot spot

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/09/2010

(review submitted 01/11/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 124 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"DELICIOUS food, and we got to meet the Executive Chef. Service could have been better, but was a wonderful dinner that made up for it."

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/08/2010

(review submitted 01/10/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 125 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"The food was excellent. We tried a bunch of apps and desserts all of which were tasty. I recommend the pasta and spicy lamb ragu app. On the down side, the waiter was unattentive, the soup came without a spoon and the bread showed up really late."

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/08/2010

(review submitted 01/10/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 126 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"We went to Butter after reading all the glowing reviews on OpenTable. We weren't that impressed. I found the nuts on the appetizer of silky salmon out of place and the green herb tasteless and hard to chew. The Duck wasn't crispy, was swimming in grease and I couldn't cut the caramelized endive with a knife."

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/02/2010

(review submitted 01/04/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 127 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Butter was a fun restaurant experience. The food was good, not amazing. Though I don't know if I ordered well so I would definitely go back again to try it once more. The staff were professional and the ambiance was energetic. The cocktails were awesome--especially the pear puree and pear vodka. It gets loud at night."

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, fit for foodies, good for groups, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/02/2010

(review submitted 01/03/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 128 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"The food was cooked perfectly with just the right portions. I ordered the Duck Breast and my guest ordered the Chicken. The duck was cooked with the right amount of flavor and fat and was not tough or gamey. My guest mentioned the chicken was the best she had ever eaten. With a 3 course meal, I left feeling satisfied and not overly full. A perfect place to eat where you can drink afterwords. It was priced right; I would eat there again."

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, notable wine list, hot spot

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/19/2009

(review submitted 01/03/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 129 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"The modern, yet homey ambiance perfectly matches the tone of the food. The service was friendly and knowledgeable without being overbearing. The venison gnocchi was one of the best appetizers I've ever had!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/21/2009

(review submitted 12/30/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 130 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"We travel from Maryland to new york and went to Butter, the food was very good and the service was excellent. i would recomend this restaurant to any one traveling to new York I thought it was very reasonable for 4 people. Thanks"

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, fit for foodies, good for groups, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/28/2009

(review submitted 12/30/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 131 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Our family enjoyed the great food and cocktails. Service was excellent from the moment we entered the restraunt. The Artic Char was delicous and everyone enjoyed the 14 day aged ribeye special.Our server was very insightful and the whole staff seemed happy. We enjoyed the creative lighting (aspen background) and the layout of the restraunt."

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, kid-friendly, late-night find, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/22/2009

(review submitted 12/29/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 132 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Wonderful! The food was marvelous! How nice to see Chef Alexandra. Gretchen is the best!
Music from downstairs too LOUD!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/26/2009

(review submitted 12/29/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 133 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Outstanding, food and service were both wonderful!"

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, romantic, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/26/2009

(review submitted 12/28/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 134 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Great ambiance with unusual food pairings that were delicious! The Butter Martini was divine!"

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/23/2009

(review submitted 12/28/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 135 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Great service, outstanding food, and perfect ambiance. My family and I ate there for the holidays and as I recall they said that the lobster dish was the best they have ever had. We had the Caesar salad which was absolutely delicious. The dressing was out of this world. We also had the veal croquettes which were equally as delicious. The lobster was by far my family's favorite. Even though I don't personally love lobster (I prefer steak over lobster), Butter's lobster was pretty addictive for me. The filet steak was very very tasty as well. The service was perfect and the food came out in a timely manner - not too fast and not too slow. A must for any food lover."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, romantic, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/26/2009

(review submitted 12/27/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 136 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Loved the duck! And the homemade truffles! And our waiter was exceptional - so friendly and knowledgable, he made great drink recommendations that really completed the meal. This dinner was the finishing touch on a Christmas present for a loved one and we couldn't have asked for a better experience!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/19/2009

(review submitted 12/22/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 137 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"We went on a night when there was a snow storm, upstairs tables were sparsly populated and the atmosphere was more subdued than usual, actually made the place even better. Food was good, recommend the mussels. All in a good night out with good service."

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/19/2009

(review submitted 12/22/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 138 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Right across the street from Blue Man Group which I was taking my 10 yr-old daughter and my mother to see. We had pasta appetizer. Duck breast, ravioli, and striped bass entree's. All 3 of us thought it was a home run. We are not "foodies" because we live in a small town and rarely get to nice restaurants; however, we spend time watching food network and cooking great food at home. We all loved this experience and I appreciated the convenience to the show. Of note, Chef Alex of Alex's Day Off came out to talk to one of the young kids who was there and knew her from the show. I thought that was great."

Special Features: fit for foodies, kid-friendly

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/19/2009

(review submitted 12/21/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 139 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"The food was amazing and the service was impeccable. We had tickets to the blue man group across the street and were running a bit late. The maître d’ was extremely nice and gave us some quick apps and booked us reservations for after the show. When we came back we were upgraded to a booth and since we wanted the tasting (but it takes 3 hours), the maître d’ gave us his own version which was amazing. He paired it with wine in our price range and everything that came out was delicious. On top of all this great service,the waitress was very friendly and accomodating. She even sparked up some good conversation. All and all, my GF and I were very impressed and would recommend Butter to anyone."

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/18/2009

(review submitted 12/20/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 140 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"The restaurant is beautiful. Two of the dishes were good. The third came cold. Busboys need to be trained better. After the first course they took everything away including bread plates, but left bread. When we asked for bread plates they became very flustered and set a whole new table."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/17/2009

(review submitted 12/19/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 141 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"We all thought the food was fantastic, plenty of choices, great wine list. I rate restaurants as "go back to or NOT" and this is definately a "go back to"."

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/16/2009

(review submitted 12/18/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 142 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"really good. service fantastic as was the food"

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/12/2009

(review submitted 12/15/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 143 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Excellent food and ambience. Service was terrible and there was a long delay for the delivery of each course"

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/10/2009

(review submitted 12/14/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 144 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"it was really worth the trip although we were a bit confused with the menu, but luckily the food was great
we loved the setting the decor was very nice.
I would recommend requesting a table on the upper level when booking"

Special Features: romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/28/2009

(review submitted 12/11/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 145 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"I was happy to finally go to Butter recently. We had a great experience, the food was delicious (albeit heavy, beware), the service was friendly and informative, and the wine selection was great as well. The wild boar appetizer was fantastic, as were the scallops and the lamb entree; the lobster was a little tough. The ambiance was...interesting. When I read some recent reviews, there were many mentions of the show Gossip Girl, we were a bit weary and nearly canceled. However, if you have the same fears, do not let them deter you. Despite the couple of groups of 20-something ladies living out the their gossip girl fantasies, it's still a solid choice. The majority of the patrons did seem to be there for the food."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, special occasion

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/04/2009

(review submitted 12/10/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 146 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Excellent, I will go there again!"

Special Features: notable wine list, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/05/2009

(review submitted 12/08/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 147 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Yumm, meals were great. Beautiful setting. Very cool NYC restaurant. We went because we have teens who are Gossip Girls, the TV show, fans. They were not disappointed. There was a private party downstairs. We couldn't go. But we were told it was for a prince! Note a glass of house wine was $16."

Special Features: fit for foodies, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/05/2009

(review submitted 12/07/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 148 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"A wonderful experience. Food was superb, service was perfect (not rushed, server was knowledgeable and pleasant)."

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/05/2009

(review submitted 12/07/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 149 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"The meal was outstanding, and the room was beautiful and made the whole evening feel special. My only complaint is the service was a bit slow - friendly, but slow. Overall we had a great meal, and I would go back again."

Special Features: fit for foodies, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/05/2009

(review submitted 12/07/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 150 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Great food, but be sure to request a table upstairs. We sat downstairs which was far too noisy once the DJ arrived and atmosphere was more like dining in a nightclub."

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, good for groups

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/04/2009

(review submitted 12/06/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 151 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Excellent cucumber martini, but the signature Butter martini left no impression at $15. Duck was very good; halibut was good, but nothing special. Pastas were delicious. Overall, the scene was "happening" as a new york 20 something institution. You can't go wrong trying it once, but it is probably more fun with a table of friends, not for a romantic dinner."

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, late-night find, hot spot

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/04/2009

(review submitted 12/06/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 152 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Chef Alexandra Guarnaschelli makes the culinary experience so memorable, through very thoughtful and exceedingly delicious choices on the menu, that you want to keep coming back for more and more. She is clearly and outstanding chef and teacher, as can be noted in her Food Network Shows, ALEX'S DAY OFF, and occasionally on CHOPPED.... one feels fortunate that you can enjoy the actual food of someone you admire watching create."

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, fit for foodies, good for groups, late-night find, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/28/2009

(review submitted 12/06/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 153 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"From the cocktail to the dessert, our meal was excellent. It was our second time there (we had fond memories of our first time and decided to return) and I have a feeling there will be a third for sure!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/27/2009

(review submitted 12/05/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 154 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"The food itself was EXCELLENT! Overall, a lovely experience with a couple of service hiccups. We were first to arrived slightly early for a 5:30 table and wished the bar had been open. The maitre'd escorted 3 other tables first. Finally, from his podium called our name(even though we were now alone in the gallery). He made up for it by indeed giving us a lovely table as promised. Our waiter was attentive without being overbearing, and overall gave us excellent service. However, after leaving the wine list, he failed to follow up & take the order. By the time he came back to us, the entree had been served, so we skipped the wine. In spite of these 2 examples, the experience was excellent."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/21/2009

(review submitted 12/05/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 155 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"The tables are positioned very close together, so it is difficult to have a quiet conversation. The restaurant must realize this because they seem to have over-compensated by playing the music much, MUCH too loud. In trying to shout over the music, adjacent tables are sure to hear your conversation.

Either the waiter or the bartender mixed/delivered the wrong drink; when I mentioned this to another staff member, and asked to send our waiter over, it was more than 10 minutes before the waiter reappeared... The wine list was good, but nothing to really distinguish the restaurant from other expensive places.

The food was excellent, though, and would incent me to try the place again to find out if this was just a "bad night"."

Special Features: fit for foodies, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/20/2009

(review submitted 12/05/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 156 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Food was exceptional. Service was great. Atmosphere very hip. High end dining at reasonable prices."

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/25/2009

(review submitted 12/05/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 157 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Let me start by saying that the restaurant was gorgeous and the food was amazing and perfectly prepared. Our waitress, however, was terrible. We found out about the dinner specials after we had already ordered by listening to another waiter tell an adjacent table. She never asked us if we would like a drink while we looked at our menus. When I finished my glass of wine she didn't ask if I would like another..instead she whisked away my empty glass as she ran by our table. I should mention that we were a table of 5 women and we had two 13 year old girls with us. I have been in the food service industry before and this kind of rushed, inattentive service ruined what could have been a memorable dining experience."

Special Features: fit for foodies, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/28/2009

(review submitted 12/05/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 158 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"We would definitely return to this restaurant again! The atmosphere, food and service were terrific!"

Special Features: good for groups, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/28/2009

(review submitted 12/04/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 159 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Excellent appetizer.
Excellent service.
Too noisy.
Too much salt in food."

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Outstanding)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/02/2009

(review submitted 12/04/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 160 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Went the day before thanksgiving...pretty good dinner crowd given the time we were there.

Our server had 9 tables (that I counted) and still gave excellent service, although appeared at times slightly overwhelmed...

I felt bad for the poor kid because the people at the table next to us were total jerks, who verbally abused him for with almost no cause. Even despite the abuse, the guy kept a smile on his face, and remained professional. I shook his hand on the way out.

The food was very good, the pasta app stood out as being excellent...
thanks!"

Special Features: hot spot

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/25/2009

(review submitted 12/02/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 161 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Excellent food. Service was very slow. Waitress was extremely nice."

Special Features: fit for foodies, late-night find, notable wine list, romantic, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/21/2009

(review submitted 11/23/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 162 for Butter

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"Overall I was very unimpressed with this restaurant. The food was average and did not meet my expectations."

Food		(Poor)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/21/2009

(review submitted 11/23/2009)

Share this Review:

Ratings-Only Reviews for Butter

Based on the average of (267) ratings-only reviews

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

Restaurant Reviews for Butter

Butter Reviews List

Review 1 for Butter

Review 2 for Butter

Review 3 for Butter

Review 4 for Butter

Review 5 for Butter

Review 6 for Butter

Review 7 for Butter

Review 8 for Butter

Review 9 for Butter

Review 10 for Butter

Review 11 for Butter

Review 12 for Butter

Review 13 for Butter

Review 14 for Butter

Review 15 for Butter

Review 16 for Butter

Review 17 for Butter

Review 18 for Butter

Review 19 for Butter

Review 20 for Butter

Review 21 for Butter

Review 22 for Butter

Review 23 for Butter

Review 24 for Butter

Review 25 for Butter

Review 26 for Butter

Review 27 for Butter

Review 28 for Butter

Review 29 for Butter

Review 30 for Butter

Review 31 for Butter

Review 32 for Butter

Review 33 for Butter

Review 34 for Butter

Review 35 for Butter

Review 36 for Butter

Review 37 for Butter

Review 38 for Butter

Review 39 for Butter

Review 40 for Butter

Review 41 for Butter

Review 42 for Butter

Review 43 for Butter

Review 44 for Butter

Review 45 for Butter

Review 46 for Butter

Review 47 for Butter

Review 48 for Butter

Review 49 for Butter

Review 50 for Butter

Review 51 for Butter

Review 52 for Butter

Review 53 for Butter

Review 54 for Butter

Review 55 for Butter

Review 56 for Butter

Review 57 for Butter

Review 58 for Butter

Review 59 for Butter

Review 60 for Butter

Review 61 for Butter

Review 62 for Butter

Review 63 for Butter

Review 64 for Butter

Review 65 for Butter

Review 66 for Butter

Review 67 for Butter

Review 68 for Butter

Review 69 for Butter

Review 70 for Butter

Review 71 for Butter

Review 72 for Butter

Review 73 for Butter

Review 74 for Butter

Review 75 for Butter

Review 76 for Butter

Review 77 for Butter

Review 78 for Butter