Reserve now:

Esca Reservations

Restaurant Reviews List > New York / Tri-State Area Restaurant Reviews > Manhattan Restaurant Reviews > Theater District / Times Square Restaurant Reviews > Italian Restaurant Reviews

Restaurant Reviews for Esca

Esca

402 West 43rd Street
New York, NY 10036

Esca is a Southern Italian Seafood Restaurant created by Mario Batali, Joseph Bastianich & David Pasternack. Esca showcases the style & sensibility of Italian coastal cooking. Dave went to Italy & saw firsthand what they were talking about. After years of cooking French food, Dave had finally found the food he had always wanted to cook. The best fish available, prepared in a simple & delicious way. In Italy that means the local catch, but in New York that means the best fish of the Pacific, Mediterranean & our own backyard.

At Esca you can eat the most sought after Pacific Ocean delicacies along side Fluke that Dave caught on his day off. The menu changes daily & is driven by the fish markets of the world & the farms of Dave’s friends. Esca is the place where you can have stunning raw fish, an incredible bowl of pasta & then a Mediterranean Branzino cooked in sea salt. Esca is the best of Italian coastal cooking with access to the world’s greatest fish.

Dining Style: Casual Elegant
Price: $30 and under
Parking: No
Cross Street: 9th Avenue

See more Esca details

Average Diner Rating
Overall Rating		4.1 out of 5 (365 Reviews)

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

Summary of Special Features

Diners classify this restaurant as:

fit for foodies (223)
notable wine list (160)
special occasion (145)
neighborhood gem (102)
romantic (73)
great for lunch (64)
hot spot (55)
good for groups (22)
late-night find (15)
great for outdoor dining (10)
vibrant bar scene (8)

+ see more special features/tags

Esca Reviews List

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"This is a superb restaurant. It had great food, we especially liked the Sturgeon. This place is a seafood lovers dream. Service was excellent too."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

FEATURED REVIEW

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/05/2010

(review submitted 02/14/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 2 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"As always, the food was perfectly cooked. We especially like the sommelier, who has led us to try some very interesting and unusual wines."

Special Features: vibrant bar scene, fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/17/2010

(review submitted 03/19/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 3 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Delicious food! When we first arrived, the noise level was fine. Within the hour, the place was packed and very noisy~~to the point that we could not speak without yelling. Did put a damper on the experience. For that kind of $, I want to be able to enjoy and have a conversation."

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, great for outdoor dining, neighborhood gem, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/17/2010

(review submitted 03/19/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 4 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"CAn you imagine a best-friend reunion after (for real) 40 years! The rendez-vous was Penn Station, converging from DC and Boston, and then to Esca - a fitting setting for this really special occasion. That is, just the insouciant best, and effortlessly romantic."

Special Features: romantic, special occasion, great for lunch

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/15/2010

(review submitted 03/17/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 5 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"It was pretty noisy and the service was just OK. We were very excited to dine there, but unfortunately the food was rather disappointing. I ordered pasta with shrimp and there were literally two small shrimp...it was also lacking in flavor. For the money, I didn't feel it was worth it. We will not be going back."

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/08/2010

(review submitted 03/16/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 6 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Great selection and outstanding preparation. Puts other seafood restaurants to shame. If you can sit by the fish preparation table you will learn more about filleting than in any cooking class! THe only drawback is the noise level, but that should not keep you away."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/10/2010

(review submitted 03/14/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 7 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"The food was really good, but our waiter was a bit snooty and not very helpful or good. A lot of money to pay for poor service."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/09/2010

(review submitted 03/13/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 8 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"The best restaurant in the theater district, never disappoints and we've been there often. They really know how to prepare fish but even the vegetables are wonderful. Unusual and always good wine as well."

Special Features: fit for foodies, great for outdoor dining, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, great for lunch, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/11/2010

(review submitted 03/13/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 9 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Had high expectations for Esca based on terrific experiences at other Batali/Bastianich restaurants, but this was a mixed bag. Food was uneven. At its best, it was thrilling and satisfying (the pesci azzurri in particular). The pasta (nettle gnocchi with mint) was solid but bland: underseasoned and not enhanced by the seafood in the dish. Secondi (monkfish and spotted bass) were both fine -- tasty enough, nicely cooked -- but undistinctive. Also had the misfortune of being seated next to a guy (apparently a regular) who spent 2 hrs. boasting about himself at top volume to his unfortunate date, who barely got to finish a sentence. This isn't the restaurant's fault, but it says something about the crowd. Next time I stay below 14th :-)"

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/06/2010

(review submitted 03/09/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 10 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"We celebrated our 25th anniversary at Esca and thoroughly enjoyed ourselves. The service was spectacular and the food was quite impressive.
Overall, this is a wonderful spot to enjoy some high quality food and wine."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/06/2010

(review submitted 03/09/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 11 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"I thought this was an overpriced, very small portions (went home hungry), restaurant with way too many waiters hovering to remove plates, but not to provide service. Waiters were much more attentive if you were ordering bottles of wine, many courses, etc."

Special Features: fit for foodies, hot spot

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/03/2010

(review submitted 03/06/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 12 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"What a meal. Load up on the crudo. You won't find anything quite like it elsewhere. I also had the chance to try 3 pasta dishes (we made friends with our neighbors). I almost overlooked the gnocchi and I'm so glad I sampled it. WOW. Don't miss it. Go for as many courses as you can, bring friends and share. It's that kind of place.

As for the front of the house, it was a battle royal between the sommeiller and the waiter for best service. We couldn't have had a better night.

This restaurant, celebrating it's 10 year anniversary, has managed to maintain it's excitement while offering the well-polished refinement that only comes with experience."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/02/2010

(review submitted 03/04/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 13 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Dinner at Esca is always delightful. They have the best grilled octopus in town and the branzino is to die for."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/02/2010

(review submitted 03/04/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 14 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"great dining experience.
loved the dover sole."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 03/01/2010

(review submitted 03/03/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 15 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Very good food. The spicy squid ink pasta and the Casale Del Giglio Petit Verdot wine were the highlights of the meal. All the food was executed very well, but it was only the pasta dish that was truly memorable and worth going back for. The cod w/ mushrooms was very good, but not crave-worthy, and the other dish of crispy flounder w/ spinach and chickpeas was way too buttery tasting. The vegetables were actually much better than the fish, which is a nice change, but would have liked the fish to be more memorable. Would go back to try more pasta dishes. The crudo was also good, but not worth the $17-18 price for only 3-4 tiny bites of raw fish. The sommelier was great and had a perfect recommendation for us!"

Special Features: notable wine list

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/27/2010

(review submitted 03/03/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 16 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Mario Batali has quickly become one of our favorite chefs. We had a great meal last time in Cafe Mono and now in Esca (tasting menu). I think it's time to try Babbo next..."

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/21/2010

(review submitted 03/03/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 17 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Great experince for us celebrating 34 years of marriage....The food was amazing and the service was unbelievably superior .....They made our evening enjoyable and even wrote
Happy Anniversary on our dessert plate in chocolate..Food was a bite pricy but worth it..."

Special Features: notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/28/2010

(review submitted 03/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 18 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Overall the experience was good; very nice service. However, we will not return. There is not enough variety on the menu for my husband. The only seafood he eats is shellfish. Even though he normally enjoys bouillabase; this one was too fishy, he especially did not enjoy the skin on the fish."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/27/2010

(review submitted 03/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 19 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Awesome food. Too loud (bad 80's music blaring, not necessary)and cramped quarters, too pricey. BUT, truly, the most tremendous fish I've ever tasted (outside of Europe)."

Special Features: fit for foodies, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/26/2010

(review submitted 02/28/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 20 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"The food was overpriced and generally poor to average. Heard great things about the crudo (sushi). For $18 -- 4small compact (not juicy) pieces of hamachi with tapenade. Good, not great. Clams in a wine broth as a hot app -- basically baked clams in a very salty broth. Clams not great, preparation like your average Italian restauraunt. Halibut came to the table poached to a hard flaky finish that was inedible with a pairing of salty leeks and mushrooms that overpowered the overcooked fish. THey graciously took it back and provided a medium cooked piece on a bed of spinach and pureed parsnips. Much better -- by no means award winning. Desserts excellent- caramel gelato with espresso, sorbet as well. My client was very disappointed."

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/24/2010

(review submitted 02/26/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 21 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"It's always a treat to enjoy a meal at Esca. Great food, pretty space, and attentive service. My guests were highly impressed."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, special occasion, great for lunch

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/27/2010

(review submitted 02/26/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 22 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"My fiancee and I had dinner here just before heading to the Majestic Theatre to see Phantom of the Opera. This trip to NYC was my Valentine's Day gift to her. She absolutely loved this restaurant! We would highly recommend it. The food was fabulous, the atmosphere was great and the service was impeccable."

Special Features: neighborhood gem, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/06/2010

(review submitted 02/26/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 23 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Poor)

"We were so disappointed the food was terrible. The first course with raw fish that salted was good but way too small for the high price. I had the Mahi it was burned and tasteless. My husband had gnochi it was gummy and no flavor. I tried dessert of torte which was soggy and chocolate outside was not good. I can not believe this meal cost us around $200.00, for such poor food. The service was amazingly good, they were so attentive and professional. The restuarant was packed, I do not know what they were eating because our food was barely eatable."

Food		(Poor)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/13/2010

(review submitted 02/25/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 24 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"It was great..Enjoyed every mouthful"

Special Features: fit for foodies

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/13/2010

(review submitted 02/25/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 25 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Esca overall was very enjoyable. The food is excellent and the service is superb. The food we order surprised us in many ways."

Special Features: fit for foodies, romantic, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/15/2010

(review submitted 02/25/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 26 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"The only reason this place exists is because of Batali's. He should really be ashamed of the food coming out of this place. Not worth the money and plenty of other places in NYC that are better. Service and wine were good, the food was nothing special."

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/23/2010

(review submitted 02/25/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 27 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"This is my third time here at Esca and it was outstanding as always. The Hawaiian Tuna crudo melted in your mouth while the vongole appetizer was like heaven on earth. The neri pasta was al dente with a taste of perfection. The waiter, Joe, was personable, knowledgeable and tended to our every need. This is a phenomenal eating experience every time and a personal favorite of mine. I can not wait to go back."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/20/2010

(review submitted 02/24/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 28 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"The wine recommendation was excellent and very reasonable. The food was very good but a little pricey. We really enjoyed the atmosphere; the restaurant was elegant but also has a nice seating arrangement were we sat next to two other couples who were very pleasant. We enjoyed a conversation with one of those couples who frequented NYC and Esca's. The staff was very helpful with our dinner choices. We enjoyed our dinner experience."

Special Features: fit for foodies, late-night find, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/20/2010

(review submitted 02/23/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 29 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"As my wife mentioned on our walk back to the hotel, "It was the best meal she ever had". The food was incredible. The presentation remarkable. The wine list was extensive. The sommelier and the wait staff were so accommodating.

A truly grand experience."

Special Features: notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/20/2010

(review submitted 02/23/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 30 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"As usual, suburb! Everything was just perfect."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/21/2010

(review submitted 02/23/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 31 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Wife loves seafood; went for her birthday. She enjoyed her entree, the mixed fried seafood, describing it as delicately fried, crispy on the outside, still moist on the inside. I had the gnocchi, decent. Thought the restaurant was a bit overpriced. Used to work in Manhattan, used to high Manhattan prices. Didn't mind paying $30. for my wife's entree; she enjoyed it. My gnocchi at $24.00 was overpriced, but didn't really mind. What did annoy me was the overpriced salad at $17.00; described as having "apples" and pumpkin or squash. Were 2 tiny dollops of squash; one tiny piece of apple. Most jarring to me was mainstream American rock music; this totally out of character for such a place. Not expecting Bach, but jazz, bossa nova, samba etc."

Special Features: fit for foodies, special occasion

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/20/2010

(review submitted 02/22/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 32 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"I went to this place five years ago with my wife and really enjoyed. This time around it was four for a business dinner. Service and food was fantastic, but in more enjoyable was the service from waiter, to greeter, to bus boy. Everyone wa pleasant and on the top of their game. Excellent experience, highly recommended."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/18/2010

(review submitted 02/21/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 33 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"it's super,- really,- but somehow kind of tiring-- when you get the 2 main guys looking after you, the it's like being in Rome and so it's fun and delicious,-- but some of the younger staff need to ask advice about where your bread was kneaded,--before they bring it to you,.. and then are are tourists taking pictures of each other...it's Felidia or Caravaggio on 'speed'-- but we do go back whenever we're at the theatres on theatre row, and it's very useful for that..."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, hot spot

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/14/2010

(review submitted 02/21/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 34 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"The restaurant was more than we expected. The staff was extremely attentive, especially the sommelier. The wines, however, are very over priced."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/13/2010

(review submitted 02/21/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 35 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"We got to Esca every time we're in NY and always have a great meal, with great wine and service."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, special occasion, great for lunch

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/07/2010

(review submitted 02/20/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 36 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"This place is a gem. Convenient if you're catching a show.

My food was so good it was just like being back in Rome at a great fish restaurant. It's much better looking in the summer with the patio open, but even in the dead of winter it's a great place for seafood. More than a decent wine list and great service. I met the chef at the bar on the way out and he was wonderful, and much too modest."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, special occasion, great for lunch

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/08/2010

(review submitted 02/20/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 37 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Awesome Valentines dinner. Wine choices by Terrance were outstanding and the fish in salt crust was the best ever!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/14/2010

(review submitted 02/20/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 38 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"The wine list was superb. Better yet, the food was cooked and/or seasoned well."

Special Features: notable wine list

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/11/2010

(review submitted 02/20/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 39 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Poor)

"I have eaten at this restaurant many times. On this occasion the food was overcooked and poorly presented. I felt the dishes were overpriced for their content. Quite unfortunate as this was always one of my 'special occasion' venues."

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/09/2010

(review submitted 02/19/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 40 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Esca is always good. I live in the neighborhood. I like this restaurant because the food is always good, the service is very good and 'invisible', and the door staff etc. are always friendly."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/09/2010

(review submitted 02/19/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 41 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Too much salt on the Nero squid pasta. Fish was exceptional. Nero at Cafe Boulud beter."

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, special occasion

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/05/2010

(review submitted 02/13/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 42 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"At first we were disappointed with the menu choices. However, the entire party truly enjoyed their meals. What a pleasant surprise!"

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/03/2010

(review submitted 02/12/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 43 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"The food and service were excellent. The noise level is so high that holding a conversation with your dinner partner is impossible. If you are early for your reservation there is nowhere to wait comfortably. I would not recommend Esca primarily due to the noise and I wouldn't go back."

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/04/2010

(review submitted 02/09/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 44 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"The food was tasty and fresh but the service was very pretetntious. We had a waiter who paid us no heed as the next table ordered wine and had his attendtion. The gentleman at the next table had ordered a pasta dish with clams and received a lemon scented towel to clean his hands. My wife had the same dish and was never offered anything.There were plenty of waiters but no management. In addition at the end we were rushed as the staff was being served their lunch. For the price it was NOT worth it. Our waiter was like a phanton and was very rude especially after we made it clear despite repeated proding we did not wants drinks or an extra entree. I fely more warmth in the Middle East"

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/05/2010

(review submitted 02/09/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 45 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Beautiful space but tight. Delicious food. I found the there to be too many wait staff who were too dramatic and phony for my staff."

Special Features: fit for foodies, special occasion

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/04/2010

(review submitted 02/09/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 46 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Poor and uninspired desert choice on the Restaurant Week offering."

Special Features: great for outdoor dining, neighborhood gem

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/05/2010

(review submitted 02/08/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 47 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"This place is outstanding! The food was so delicious and perfectly prepared. Wines were good. Service was very professional; I never felt rushed. This is my new favorite place—I can't wait to go back."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, special occasion, great for lunch

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/05/2010

(review submitted 02/07/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 48 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Excellent experience overall, with outstanding food and service."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, special occasion, great for lunch

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/05/2010

(review submitted 02/07/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 49 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Went to Esca for Restaurant Week and was very pleased. Some restaurants on Restaurant Week seriously under deliver and it's a disappointment. I always figure that a smart restaurant will strut their stuff and entice one to return and Esca certainly obliged. The food was very tasty and there was a nice selection. In addition there was a 10.73 wine tasting...It was a treat, particularly the dessert wine...."

Special Features: fit for foodies, great for lunch

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/04/2010

(review submitted 02/06/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 50 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Food is good, little Salty though."

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/04/2010

(review submitted 02/06/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 51 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"If you love Mediterranean and fish this is your place. I had the spotted sea bass and it was wonderful. Excellent wait staff. Delicious homemade Bellini too!"

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/04/2010

(review submitted 02/06/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 52 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"The food was uniformly outstanding: super-fresh fish, very creative flavors, lovely presentation. The service was attentive without being overbearing. The atmosphere feels a little close, but we could carry on conversation easily. And the bill was not bad considering what we ate and drank! I would return."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/04/2010

(review submitted 02/06/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 53 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Food was well prepared although selection on Restaurant Week menu was limited. Service was pleasant, professional, friendly and attentive. Dessert was a great complement to the meal. It was a pleasant dining experience though for me, not outstanding."

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/03/2010

(review submitted 02/05/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 54 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"This was a fantastic dining experience! The service was outstanding! OMG....the best mussels I've ever tasted! The atmosphere was excellent...I look forward to my next visit."

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, great for lunch, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/29/2010

(review submitted 02/05/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 55 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"We were seated at our reservation time. No waiting. The waiter and staff were polite, friendly, knowledgeable. We were not rushed. The service was excellent. The 2 dishes we tried, gold bass & fuscilli with clams, mussels and shrimp, were well prepared and nicely presented. The noise was at a reasonable level. If it were not for the high prices we would eat here more often."

Special Features: notable wine list, great for lunch

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/01/2010

(review submitted 02/04/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 56 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"I have dined at Esca several times. The food never fails to impress me. The execution of the recipe preperation is focused and enhances the flavor of the main ingredient. The service staff is trained to educate your palate and anticipate your needs.I have always left learning about a new ingredient or technique."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/02/2010

(review submitted 02/04/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 57 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"This is my second time to Esca and I was not disappointed. The food, its presentation and service was excellent."

Special Features: fit for foodies

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 02/02/2010

(review submitted 02/04/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 58 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Esca is good, but not spectacular. Of the big meals we had during our visit to NYC, Esca suffered in comparison to City Lobster (fabulous lunch for restaurant week) and Grammercy Tavern. Esca is good, close to the theaters and a good choice for pre-Theater."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/29/2010

(review submitted 02/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 59 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"I was looking forward to eating at Esca but was very disappointed. The service and ambiance were great. The wait staff and the sommelier were friendly, helpful and not snooty. We got the food sampler. The portions were extremely small, which was sort of okay because there were about 6 courses, but I found everything very salty and the cod was tasteless. The prices are high and the portions small. I will not return."

Special Features: notable wine list, romantic

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/30/2010

(review submitted 02/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 60 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"eXCELLENT FOOD AND SERVICE AND LOVELY AMBIENCE"

Special Features: fit for foodies

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/29/2010

(review submitted 02/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 61 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Esca's food is hearty and exquisitely served. Loved the gnocchi, sea bass for three, spaghetti with lobster and the roasted brussel sprouts! Breads were divine..."

Special Features: fit for foodies, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/30/2010

(review submitted 02/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 62 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"was really great. anticipated that it would be "solid", but exceeded my expectations. the menu was great, ambiance was wonderful (for lunch! want to check out dinner!) and service was really outstanding. will definitely be returning for more. thanks!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion, great for lunch

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/28/2010

(review submitted 02/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 63 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"The waiter was fair. The bus staff was very good. The apps were fantastic. The Bay Scallops dinner, average. I have been there several times, other times the service was excellent, perhaps it was an off night. If I go again, I shall just order apps."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/31/2010

(review submitted 02/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 64 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"great food and service is a tough combination but you pay for it, $$$."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/31/2010

(review submitted 02/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 65 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Even though I'm a big fan of the Molto man, I have to say I was slightly underwhelmed with the food that actually came to the table. The menu sounded wonderful but some dishes were hits and others were unfortunately misses. I have to say, I expected more consistency and given the prices, I probably won't be coming back. Such a great attempt, but not quite there."

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/31/2010

(review submitted 02/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 66 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"As usual, Esca delivered a wonderful dining experience. The waitstaff was attentive and helpful. The food was delicious; the pannacotta alone is worth going for...yummy!!!!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, special occasion, great for lunch

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/26/2010

(review submitted 02/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 67 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"The Bartender was great. Overall the food was good but I thought it would be better."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/29/2010

(review submitted 02/02/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 68 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Food was very good, buit wervice was awful. At lunch tiem is a a premium. It took almost 2 hours for lunch. We waited a long time to order, and it took 20 minutes for appetizers aand another 25 minutes for the entree to arrive."

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/28/2010

(review submitted 02/01/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 69 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Excellent restaurant and experience. We've been to many italian restaurants in our day but this one stands out as having a very unique and creative fish-based menu. All courses were superb. Try the raw sampler. If you're an Uni lover, the spaghetti with crab meat and sea urchant was delicious. Staff was very attentive and friendly. Service was great and theater conscious."

Special Features: fit for foodies, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/29/2010

(review submitted 01/31/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 70 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Staff was both friendly and highly professional. Very nice ambiance. Quiet. Excellent food and service. Reasonable prices. Will definitely go back."

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/24/2010

(review submitted 01/30/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 71 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Heavy hand with the salt. From a person who thinks pizza is better with extra salt.

Funny, because when I told a coworker where I'd gone, the first thing out of his mouth was, they're salty. The dessert and oysters were the high points.

Breaded flounder was on the bland side. Veggies were overcooked. Rigatoni with tuna was good but there was no Wow.

From sit down to ordering took 30 minutes. Sorry, I have a job to go back to, it's lunchtime! Overall okay experience, but I probably won't go back."

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/28/2010

(review submitted 01/30/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 72 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"The Restaruant Week menu was quite extensive offering 3 or 4 choices in each category. A nice feature was the offer of 3 tasting portions of wine with each course and all were excellent. We ordered the scallops, which was delicious. Would definitely go to ESCA again."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, great for lunch

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/27/2010

(review submitted 01/29/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 73 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Overall, we had a lovely evening. The food was fresh and delicious, the service attentive, and the table was in a great location. I would have to agree, however, that the portions were very small in light of the high prices. (This comes from someone who enjoys good food prepared simply with the best ingredients and who does not prefer huge portions.) It's also difficult to carry on a conversation due to the noise level."

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, notable wine list

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/27/2010

(review submitted 01/29/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 74 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Restaurant week prix fixe was a great menu, lovely service. Fish is fresh and delicious, entire meal great with lovely service. Could use a few more white wine by the glass choices."

Special Features: fit for foodies, special occasion, great for lunch

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/27/2010

(review submitted 01/29/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 75 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"If you love fish, this is the place for you. Simple but delicious presentation, excellent service, and a satisfying experience."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, great for lunch

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/25/2010

(review submitted 01/27/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 76 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"waiter was knowledgable and not overbearing"

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, great for lunch

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/25/2010

(review submitted 01/27/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 77 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"I love fish and couldn't wait to try Esca. Was looking forward to the dining experience and found that the quality of the food fell short. Most of the dishes were overseasoned. The vegetables were overcooked. I did not expect a "Le Bernardin" experience, but given the 25 rating in Zagats and the few reviews I read, I was expecting better."

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/21/2010

(review submitted 01/26/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 78 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Service somewhat spotty until we called someone over. Waiter very kind and knowledgeable but seemed to have too many tables. Though fish dishes very good and well prepared, seemed very expensive for what we got. We had nothing with the dishes and some main courses could have been bigger, i.e. the whole butterfish. Something should have been included along with main courses for price. Salad also high priced for what it was-few components, a lot of greens. We were disappointed, though we had been to Esca several times prior to this time."

Special Features: fit for foodies, hot spot

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/23/2010

(review submitted 01/26/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 79 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Exceptional service. Crudo amazing."

Special Features: fit for foodies, great for lunch

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/22/2010

(review submitted 01/24/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 80 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Fantastic - I went 2 nights in a row and planing on 3 - The perfect restaurant"

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/22/2010

(review submitted 01/24/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 81 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Waiter insisted that we order more food than we needed or wanted."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/21/2010

(review submitted 01/23/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 82 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Great food and service, we had theater tickets and they helped us get there in time."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, romantic

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/19/2010

(review submitted 01/22/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 83 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"This is a place for lovers of (mostly raw) seafood. Don't go if you have an appetite for anything else. It's a very narrow "range" restaurant."

Special Features: fit for foodies

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/17/2010

(review submitted 01/22/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 84 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Excellent food and service ... relaxed atmosphere"

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/19/2010

(review submitted 01/21/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 85 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"World class restaurant (as reflected in the price) but worth it. Very helpful wait staff; she spent time helping us through the entire menu, understanding our likes and dislikes and then designing a meal that was right for quantity and pacing. Unique food, perfectly blended ingredients with excellent presentation."

Special Features: notable wine list, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/28/2009

(review submitted 01/21/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 86 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"After-show reservation for a late dinner was perfect. The food was completely sublime - don't be afraid to order multiple pastas and have them split with your dining partner, creating your own tasting menu. The grilled octopus appetizer and the spaghetti neri were both impossibly good."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/16/2010

(review submitted 01/20/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 87 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"The quality of the food was superb and the atmosphere very comfortable. The baby octopus salad was unique and delicious. The gnocchi was voted best in New York by The New York Times.
This will be a regular stop for us every trip to NY. I highly recommend reservations. We ate at Esca on a Wednesday night at 7pm and a party of three walked in ahead of us without a reservation and were told it was a two plus hour wait."

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/13/2010

(review submitted 01/19/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 88 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Great food and fantastic service."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, romantic

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/17/2010

(review submitted 01/19/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 89 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Food was delicious outstanding restaurant - certainly would recommend highly - 2nd visit both times have been very good. It is small restaurant, noisy and because it is so good crowded. Overall great night - great wine list and delicious food."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/16/2010

(review submitted 01/19/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 90 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"The food and service is always excellent - we love Esca!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/16/2010

(review submitted 01/19/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 91 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Food and service were outstanding. We have been before and will be back!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/15/2010

(review submitted 01/19/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 92 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Delighted to try one of the Mario Batali restaurants conveniently located in midtown. The noise level was a bit deafening especially as the waiter tried to talk us through the menu. The spaghetti nero was as good as any we had in Venice. My monkfish was on the verge of being overcooked but still delicious. The staff was great about choosing wine pairings and even humored me when I changed my mind about one of the choices I was given."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/16/2010

(review submitted 01/18/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 93 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Always a first rate dining experience. the epitome of Italian seafood. great service."

Special Features: fit for foodies

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/15/2010

(review submitted 01/17/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 94 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Went to Esca for my daughter's birthday - had the tasting menu which was amazing. Portion sizes were perfect - left feeling satisfied but not overfull. Service was wonderful, ambiance comfortable. Would definitely return!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/14/2010

(review submitted 01/16/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 95 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Esca is one of my favorite restaurants. The food is beautifully prepared and it is also possible to eat healthily without sacrificing taste and complexity. The waiters are professionals. Everyone in the restaurant is on their toes, ready to serve you in a warm, unpretentious way. The wines are wonderful. Everything about Esca is superb."

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, great for outdoor dining, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, special occasion, great for lunch

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/13/2010

(review submitted 01/15/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 96 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Poor)

"Four women dining. The food was not fit to eat. One women said that he entree tasted burnt. The waiter said that was the way it was supposed to taste, but he would check with the chef. He then returned with the answer that the chef said it was nit burnt. He did not take the fish back. She never ate it, and was charged for her dinner.
The other 3 women ordered pastas and took one bite and did not eat any more.
The food was digusting.
This was my 3rd time at this restaurant, but I will not return not so much because the food was awful, but because the waiter did nothing to find out why each of us had not eaten our dinners. Obviously, the chef was not concerned to see 4 full plates come back into the kitchen"

Food		(Poor)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/13/2010

(review submitted 01/15/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 97 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"The food was wonderful. Nice ambiance. Our waiter was fabulous, very professional and knowledgeable about the menu and willing to offer advice. He even recommended a spot for dessert after the show. We followed his recommendation and it was tremendous. The restaurant contacted me by phone to confirm the reservation. I had to contact them again to revise it. On both occasions, they were friendly, professional and lovely to deal with. I would definitely go back again."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/10/2010

(review submitted 01/13/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 98 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"ESCA is by far the best seafood/fish restaurant in the country in its price range with Le Bernadin being the one place better. Textbook service, food, setting."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, romantic, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/09/2010

(review submitted 01/12/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 99 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Wonderful restaurant! Fabulous food, great service. I try to go everytime I am in NYC."

Special Features: notable wine list

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/09/2010

(review submitted 01/12/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 100 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Fabulous food. (Loved the grilled mackerel.) Knowledgeable wait staff. Perfect, unhurried setting for a business lunch."

Special Features: fit for foodies, great for lunch

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/08/2010

(review submitted 01/10/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 101 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"Overall the food was fair - each dish was too salty, and the main dish - grilled sea bass - was overcooked. I would not return."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/08/2010

(review submitted 01/10/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 102 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"When we arrived through front door of Esca on a cold Wed in Jan , we had a warm welcome and the interior of the restaurant had warm glow and warm feel to it. We were seated at a cozy table for 2 along a leather banquette that looked out onto the intimate dining room with a rustic wood floor, white linen covered tables with sleek leather chairs . Waiter offered special cocktails or wine, then came back with tasty amuse of a smoked makerel, followed by really good olives to nibble. Menus were then brought andwe were asked if we had dined here before. It was explained that the Crudo was what they were known for . King salmon with pink peppercorns was excellent. Both Fish entree terrific! Impressed that loose tea still served!! Off to show"

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/06/2010

(review submitted 01/08/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 103 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"We go here regularly - both with friends and with business partners.
Never disappointed. Our favorite place for fish."

Special Features: notable wine list

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/05/2010

(review submitted 01/07/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 104 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Overall the experience was great. The restaurant was smaller than I expected, but we sat in the second dining room and due to the cold weather, that was preferred. The front dining room gets the draft from the front door. It is touted as a fish lover's dream, but that's really an understatement, fish was superb. If you are a twosome, get the branzino in salt -- fabulous. If you are going for a pasta course as well as app and entree, skip the sides, way too much food. Did not have dessert, but looked good. Service was impeccable."

Special Features: fit for foodies

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/30/2009

(review submitted 01/06/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 105 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Great, wonderful, fresh seafood, and staff who were spot-on with their service, as well as their suggestions and recommendations. Loved it and would love to go back."

Special Features: fit for foodies, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/04/2010

(review submitted 01/06/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 106 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Restaurant was very good. The wine list had options on both the lower and upper end of the price spectrum. The restaurant's emphasis is on fish, so we ordered a seafood appetizer and shared the Bronzini fish for 2, both of which were delicious. Cost was a little high at this restaurant, and the open table $ signs are not accurate in my opinion. This was at least a $$$ kind of restaurant and not $$. Service was excellent and I would recommend this to friends."

Special Features: notable wine list, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/31/2009

(review submitted 01/04/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 107 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Esca was a very nice experience. The food was wonderful. Great wines. Sophisticated atmosphere. A nice surprise in the theatre district. Service was a little slow, but not enough to dampen the fun."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/02/2010

(review submitted 01/04/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 108 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"The gnocchi was to die for!! Best gnocchi I've ever had!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, notable wine list, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/01/2010

(review submitted 01/03/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 109 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"How wonderful to find a restaurant this good in the theater district. Their fish is outstanding. The squid ink pasta was fantastic and we had one of the most memorable deserts we've ever had."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/01/2010

(review submitted 01/03/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 110 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Excellent food and wine. Would not change a thing."

Special Features: neighborhood gem, romantic, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 01/01/2010

(review submitted 01/03/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 111 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Our dining experience at ESCA was a very pleasant one. The meal was superb from the beginning to the end. We would recommend ESCA to all friends and family."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, great for lunch

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/31/2009

(review submitted 01/03/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 112 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Three of us had a fabulous dinner at Esca capping off a 5 day visit to NYC. Started off with 3 types of crudo (tile fish, scorpion fish and yellowfin tuna carpaccio). Fantastic! Proboably would not order scorpion fish again but glad to have tried it. Texture a little chewy and not as delicate as the other two. Went on to have a grilled octapus salad and mussles,clams and scallops in a spicy pumpkin broth. Both were superb. Intermezzo was a shared serving of squid ink pasta done perfectly. Finally, we had the whole sea bass baked in salt - divine. Service was impeccable. Attentive without being intrusive. The sommelier steered us to a delicious bottle from the extensive list of Italian wines. I will definitely go back again."

Special Features: fit for foodies, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/29/2009

(review submitted 01/01/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 113 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"In spite of the fabled wine list, our first preference for a Sardinian wine was not available. The sommeliar said he had just sold the last bottle to another table. Found that a bit difficult to believe."

Special Features: fit for foodies

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/29/2009

(review submitted 01/01/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 114 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"We had a wonderful meal at Esca. The food was fresh, well priced and well prepared. The service was attentive and professional and we had a lovely bottle of wine. We look forward to returning."

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/29/2009

(review submitted 01/01/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 115 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Always great - and this visit was no exception. Our waitress (British accent) was superb. Katie? Happy New Year to the entire staff at Esca!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/30/2009

(review submitted 01/01/2010)

Share this Review:

Review 116 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Every time we eat at Esca the food is fabulous. Everything is cooked perfectly (except the crudo which is always as fresh as can be)."

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/29/2009

(review submitted 12/31/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 117 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"An amazing experience: heavenly food, an attentive and fun staff, and a romantic setting. Salmon roe were outstanding and penne with baccala was delicious. The combination of ingredients generated new flavors."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, romantic

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/28/2009

(review submitted 12/30/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 118 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"This restaurant lived up to the hype! Lively atmosphere, yet cozy. The food and wine were superb."

Special Features: notable wine list

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/10/2009

(review submitted 12/29/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 119 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"I have wanted to try one of Mario Batali's restaurants for a while. We finally had the chance to dine at Esca, and I have to say that I was somewhat underwhelmed. There were a lot of items that we wanted to try on the menu. I thought that the tasting menu would be a good way to go. The first hiccup occured when we realized that there were one or 2 items on the tasting that didn't sound that appealing to us. We asked if we could swap one or two items, and the chef in charge that night and she said the only thing she would do was alter 1 dish on 1 of our menus. Other fine restaurants I have had tasting menus at have been much more accomodating. Basically the courses and wine pairings were unimaginative and rudimentary. I expected better."

Special Features: fit for foodies, special occasion

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/27/2009

(review submitted 12/29/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 120 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Food at ESCA is top notch. Waiter was very knowledgable about the menu. Overall a very pleasant evening."

Special Features: fit for foodies, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/27/2009

(review submitted 12/29/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 121 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Quite simply, Esca is a regular stop on my NY food visits. Classy, simple, elegant, always delicious. I love Esca.

We lucked out and sat next to the wooden table where they filet the salt encrusted fish, and plate some of the other items. So it was continuous show of awesome looking food, detail-oriented work by the team, and a lovely conversation with their young service manager, who could not have been nicer. Her dessert recommendation (caramel ice cream with toffee crunch and espresso poured over it?) was ridiculously wonderful. Thanks again!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/26/2009

(review submitted 12/28/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 122 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Fish (branzino) was gorgeous, cooked as in Italy! I would not expect that! Very good olive oil. Shame for the tomato souce of the kid's pasta...just out of a can, stirred with butter and milk...the Batali's one on Zabar's shelf taste much better...I'd rather use that! Pasta was not cooked right...sticky...but the child appreciated and that counts!
Very nice and well presented desert. Very good and kind service, though a bit too much formal. Not the best place for children though she was treated as a little queen.
Overall rate Very good!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, great for outdoor dining

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/24/2009

(review submitted 12/28/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 123 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"The Linguine with clam sauce was a bit dissapointing. Extremly salty!! I love salt, but I was unable to finish my meal because of it. My husband enjoyed his cod very much, and the deserts were amazing."

Special Features: fit for foodies

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/26/2009

(review submitted 12/28/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 124 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"It was my wife's birthday and i put that on open table. However, when we checked in at the hostess, there was no mention of it and even our waiter had no clue. They don't read what you write on open table so no reason to even waste your time. In addition, even when the waiter found out, there was no acknowledgement."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/16/2009

(review submitted 12/25/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 125 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"We loved the whole place, however my venison was a disaster. It was overcooked and almost tasteless. The waiter tried to make it up, but I should have sent it back to the kitchen."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/21/2009

(review submitted 12/23/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 126 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"This was my second trip to Esca and it was as good as I'd remembered it. The food is wonderful, fresh and originally prepared. The service is terrific; friendly and efficient, without fawning. The sommalier is a sweetheart and so helpful. I'd highly recommend it and look forward to going back myself."

Special Features: fit for foodies, late-night find, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion, great for lunch, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/21/2009

(review submitted 12/23/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 127 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"There was a loud electronic buzz coming from a light fixture near our table that was fairly annoying,adding to the aggressive background music it made for a fairly noisy ambiance. Service was outstanding, and the food was good. A word of caution --- non-fish eaters will find very little on the menu without fish or shellfish components."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/20/2009

(review submitted 12/22/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 128 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"This was our second visit to Esca and again it didn't disappoint. The food was outstanding, the service impeccable and the atmosphere was lovely. The three of us shared their gnocchi which were the best we had ever had. We also shared the full fish entree which was portioned perfectly. It is a great place to eat prior to the theater as it is on a couple blocks from most theaters and the staff were diligent about getting us out in time without ever feeling rushed."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/18/2009

(review submitted 12/22/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 129 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"Esca is known for its marinated fish (crudo, I believe. The portion for $18 was a ripoff. three teeny tiny pieces of fish. The entree fish was delicious but also a small portion for the amount of money."

Special Features: special occasion

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/17/2009

(review submitted 12/21/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 130 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Beautifully paced, beautifully presented dinner. So loud we could not hear our waiter and had to ask him to repeat, and repeat (we could hear all our neighbors quite clearly). The food was terrific, quartinos of wine were delightful."

Special Features: fit for foodies

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/15/2009

(review submitted 12/20/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 131 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"We were a party of three. We ordered 3 pastas and 3 entrees. All three pastas were very
salty, one of which was inedible(tho we were warned it was "somewhat salinic" due to the
clams). We probably should have returned them back to the kitchen but we didn't have much
confidence in their ability to detect the salt content of their dishes. Doesn't anyone
taste what is being served before it's presented to the diner? The entrees were good tho 2 were slightly salty. I felt uncomfortable making a scene(returning all three pastas) but in retrospect I probably should have. At these prices there is absolutely no excuse to
serve obviously oversalted food. Basic food service 101 in my opinion. We won't return."

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/14/2009

(review submitted 12/19/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 132 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Food and service were absolutely superb."

Special Features: notable wine list, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/15/2009

(review submitted 12/19/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 133 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"I am sorry there are only 5 stars available to give Esca. The dinning experience was perfect. We started with the Yellow fin tuna carpaccio and Insalata di Aragost, they were wonderful, the tuna carpaccio was fresh and very delightful. We then shared a plate of Taglierini Piemontese. This is a must, the white truffles were to die for. We then shared the Branzino per Due. The sea bass was expertly prepaired and presented. Overall the experience was ideal."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/15/2009

(review submitted 12/18/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 134 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Poor)

"I was VERY unhappy with the service and therefore i did not even stay. My reservation was at 4:30pm and i got there at 415 but they could not let me in b/c they were getting ready for dinner and having a meeting in the main seating area. It was pouring raining. At 435 they still have not acknowledged me and have yet to open the doors. Their meeting was still taking place as emplyees were laughing and talking while ppl were waiting in the rain. I called and they said they were still having their meeting. At 4:39 I was still not let in and I left ! VERY UNPROFESSIONAL ! !"

Food		(Poor)
Ambiance		(Poor)
Service		(Poor)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/13/2009

(review submitted 12/17/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 135 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Great location. Intimate setting. Noise level on a par with other NY restaurants. Food was wonderful, presentation superb, wait staff very attentive and informative."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/08/2009

(review submitted 12/17/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 136 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"We really enjoyed the 7 course dinner with a variety of wines. The waiter did an excellent job of being attentive and explaining each dish and wine. Would definitely return next time we're visiting New York."

Special Features: late-night find, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/12/2009

(review submitted 12/16/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 137 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"I absolutely LOVE this place. We went in the middle of December; it was cold, wet and for the most part quite dreary. ALthough frazzled and disoriented, the minute we stepped foot into Esca everyone was helpful and warm. They quickly took our sopping coats, and gave us a table in the beautifully decorated dining room. we had the friendliest waiter who was helpful in getting us out with enough time to make it to our show. The tuna here is amazing and there are not words to describe the mussles! The wine that we were recommended was delicious and suitable for the meal. I orderd the pasta with clams- it was light but very flavorful. My boyfriend had the scallops and he wont stop talking about them. This place is EXCELENT and DELICIOUS!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/13/2009

(review submitted 12/16/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 138 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"This was my 3rd of Lydia's amazing dining experience - only one left to make it complete. Each one creates more of a frenzy than the last. What will I do when there isn't a 5th??"

Special Features: fit for foodies, late-night find, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion, great for lunch, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/12/2009

(review submitted 12/15/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 139 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Just a fabulous experience top to bottom. The food was outstanding, innovative, perfectily finished and presented. The wait staff timed the meal perfectly and helped with choices. The sommelier helped choose a wonderful wine that was moderately priced."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/09/2009

(review submitted 12/15/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 140 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"２０時からRadio City Hallのショーを見るので16:30に来店してその旨をウエイター伝えたが料理の出てくる合間が長く最後はタクシーでホールに5分前に着くこととなった。サービスはいまひとつさえない。料理に関しては材料は特に魚介類は新鮮だが素材の味を引き出していな。パスタもエスニック的な辛さがあり、期待していたイタリアンではなかった。"

Special Features: great for outdoor dining, kid-friendly

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/29/2009

(review submitted 12/13/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 141 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Came for a pre theater dinner and had exceptional seafood, perfectly prepared, with service that allowed us a perfectly timed meal that was unrushed but got us to Hamlet on time. This was a special occasion restaurant for my wife and I and it lived up to it. Unlike the old NY Times review, we preferred sitting in the smaller room for our "special date night". The octopus, scallops, wild striped bass and even the desserts were excellent."

Special Features: fit for foodies, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/04/2009

(review submitted 12/13/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 142 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"We were a bit disappointed. Esca has been my husband's choice for years, but we had to wait 30 minutes for our table and there is no where to wait since they have all but eliminated their bar. We had guests and that was not fun. The service was not as good as we remembered and the food was not really very special. The best thing we had was dessert, the affocato. The rest was pretty ordinary. That white bean brushetta is tired. They have served it since they opened. It is time to change. We will probably not go back."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/08/2009

(review submitted 12/12/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 143 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"The food was exquisite and unusual, the waiter knowledgeable and personable, the space tastefully decorated. The ruby shrimp and the sea urchin were the highlights, but everything was wonderful. For us it was expensive, at $250 for two--but worth every penny. Plan to go back next time I'm in NYC."

Special Features: fit for foodies, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/06/2009

(review submitted 12/09/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 144 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"We were seated timely and greeted nicely, then our waiter disappeared. We had to ask the manager for menus and then had to wait too long to order. Once that happened, we got doted on nicely, but should not have been in that spot.

The restaurant is a nice size with comfortable decor, however even at "NY rates" we thought the food was pricey for the quantity and minimal sides. What we had was good, but given the number of food options in NY, we are unlikely to return."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Fair)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/06/2009

(review submitted 12/09/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 145 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"The crudo bay scallops in meyer lemon and olive oil were ambrosial! The wait staff was informative, helpful and friendly. All in all, it was one of the best meals we had while in NYC and in a city known for its restaurants, that's saying something!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/02/2009

(review submitted 12/08/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 146 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Fair)

"service was incredably slow and stressed me out because we had a 2 pm show."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Poor)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/05/2009

(review submitted 12/07/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 147 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"The service was excellent, food was good, expensive menu, too noisy. Would not rush back."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/14/2009

(review submitted 12/06/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 148 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"This is the 4th time we have eaten at Esca in the past 18 months. Up until this visit it was one of our favorite restaurants. This evening was a disappointment. While the appetizers were fine (grilled calamari and tuna), our main courses were overdone. We ordered the dorado and scallops. The dorado was tough and chewy. The bay scallops were cooked too long. At the prices they charge, this is unacceptable. We were frequent customers, but will not return soon. A table by the door was not appreciated."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, hot spot

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/27/2009

(review submitted 12/06/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 149 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Greeat service, fantastic food, MUCH better than we expected. Will be back!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/04/2009

(review submitted 12/06/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 150 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"The Branzino melts in your mouth and the Baccala Mantecato is very good. Highly recommend the crudo tasting dish."

Special Features: romantic

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/01/2009

(review submitted 12/06/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 151 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Every time we go to a B/B restaurant you are guaranteed a great meal. Hands down some of the best spots around town. Food is always fresh and Authentic to the regional cuisine."

Special Features: fit for foodies, good for groups, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/23/2009

(review submitted 12/05/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 152 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Great choice for a special occasion. The entrees were very good but were outshone by the incredible pasta(Bucatini) and appetizer choices(Calamari). Triple Chocolate Tort for dessert was memorable. Waiter and staff were very attentive and helpful. Don't look at the bill though..."

Special Features: fit for foodies, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/28/2009

(review submitted 12/05/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 153 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"A welcome respite in a busy visit. One of the highlights of our Manhattan stay. The very best seafood, fish, and wine, money can buy. Plus a knowledgeable server,who made the experience all the more enjoyable."

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/25/2009

(review submitted 12/05/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 154 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"we had a wonderful evening.the food was wonderful starting with the choices on the menu......the service was perfect.our every need was met before we even realized the need"

Special Features: fit for foodies, great for brunch, kid-friendly, romantic, special occasion, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/27/2009

(review submitted 12/05/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 155 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"Being from an Italian seaside community, I discriminate greatly when it comes to fresh seafood. We order tuna for appitizers and I had the lobster and spagetti and my wife had the haddock filet (crispy) with the mushrooms and truffels. Outstanding can only discribe the flavor. My uncle the head fishmonger in Molfetta would be impressed. I will diffently be there again soon."

Special Features: notable wine list, romantic, special occasion

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Quiet)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/25/2009

(review submitted 12/05/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 156 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"We enjoyed our evening at ESCA, however, the restaurant was very noisy (background noise) and the music did not match the atmosphere. The service was exceptional and made the evening. The gnocchi was the best we have ever tasted. The main courses (fish) were overcooked but tasty. The chocolate dessert was out of this world (and the only thing worth the menu price). Over all I thought the pricing about 25% higher than the quality of the meal justified. Our waiter was fabulous. Dined on Friday evening."

Food		(Good)
Ambiance		(Fair)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/20/2009

(review submitted 12/05/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 157 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"The best restaurant in the theater district in my opinion. Consistently wonderful. Don't miss the branzino and the gnocchi."

Special Features: fit for foodies, great for outdoor dining, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, great for lunch

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/01/2009

(review submitted 12/03/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 158 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

"Excellent food; fine service; obviously still an 'in' place to be. We particularly like to go after the theater because the restaurant is always full and lively. My one reservation is that, as is the case with so many restaurants these days, it is far too noisy. However, the restaurant lives up to Mario Batali's high standards and we will certainly return."

Special Features: late-night find, notable wine list, hot spot

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 12/01/2009

(review submitted 12/03/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 159 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Outstanding)

"What a pleasant surprise!! Esca was recommended to us by a friend who knew we were going to NYC for the Thanksgiving Weekend. (I guess it should not have been a surprise as our friend as never let us down;-) The food, wine, service and decor was all top notch! Seemed to be a hot spot for pre-theater lunch. We arrived as those patrons were leaving so we had most of the place to ourselves. We will certainly add this one to our NYC standards! Highly recommend!"

Special Features: fit for foodies, neighborhood gem, notable wine list, great for lunch

Food		(Outstanding)
Ambiance		(Outstanding)
Service		(Outstanding)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/28/2009

(review submitted 12/02/2009)

Share this Review:

Review 160 for Esca

Overall Rating

(Good)

"I have eaten at Esca before and this was my first disappointment. The monk fish main course was so over cooked that it was dry and inedible. The brussel sprouts on the other course were black as charcoal. I understand carmelized but this was so burned that my dining companion could smell the burned from across the table! When we complained, the waiter said he checked with his manager and that is how they cook things. I find this hard to believe as a well-traveled diner and a cook myself that this would be acceptable in any restaurant. Then we were basically ignored because we had dared to complain. Why ask, "How is everything?" I would NOT recommend Esca to anyone with so many other choices in NYC. Expensive for the poor quality."

Food		(Fair)
Ambiance		(Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Energetic)

By an OpenTable.com user

who dined on 11/20/2009

(review submitted 11/22/2009)

Share this Review:

Ratings-Only Reviews for Esca

Based on the average of (205) ratings-only reviews

Overall Rating

(Very Good)

Food		(Very Good)
Ambiance		(Very Good)
Service		(Very Good)
Restaurant Experience:
Noise Level		(Moderate)

Restaurant Reviews for Esca

Esca Reviews List

Review 1 for Esca

Review 2 for Esca

Review 3 for Esca

Review 4 for Esca

Review 5 for Esca

Review 6 for Esca

Review 7 for Esca

Review 8 for Esca

Review 9 for Esca

Review 10 for Esca

Review 11 for Esca

Review 12 for Esca

Review 13 for Esca

Review 14 for Esca

Review 15 for Esca

Review 16 for Esca

Review 17 for Esca

Review 18 for Esca

Review 19 for Esca

Review 20 for Esca

Review 21 for Esca

Review 22 for Esca

Review 23 for Esca

Review 24 for Esca

Review 25 for Esca

Review 26 for Esca

Review 27 for Esca

Review 28 for Esca

Review 29 for Esca

Review 30 for Esca

Review 31 for Esca

Review 32 for Esca

Review 33 for Esca

Review 34 for Esca

Review 35 for Esca

Review 36 for Esca

Review 37 for Esca

Review 38 for Esca

Review 39 for Esca

Review 40 for Esca

Review 41 for Esca

Review 42 for Esca

Review 43 for Esca

Review 44 for Esca

Review 45 for Esca

Review 46 for Esca

Review 47 for Esca

Review 48 for Esca

Review 49 for Esca

Review 50 for Esca

Review 51 for Esca

Review 52 for Esca

Review 53 for Esca

Review 54 for Esca

Review 55 for Esca

Review 56 for Esca

Review 57 for Esca

Review 58 for Esca

Review 59 for Esca

Review 60 for Esca

Review 61 for Esca

Review 62 for Esca

Review 63 for Esca

Review 64 for Esca

Review 65 for Esca

Review 66 for Esca

Review 67 for Esca

Review 68 for Esca

Review 69 for Esca

Review 70 for Esca

Review 71 for Esca

Review 72 for Esca

Review 73 for Esca

Review 74 for Esca

Review 75 for Esca

Review 76 for Esca

Review 77 for Esca

Review 78 for Esca